core/store/dist/src/test/java/org/onlab/onos/store/device/impl/GossipDeviceStoreTest.java

package org.onlab.onos.store.device.impl;

import static org.easymock.EasyMock.*;
import static org.junit.Assert.*;
import static org.onlab.onos.net.Device.Type.SWITCH;
import static org.onlab.onos.net.DeviceId.deviceId;
import static org.onlab.onos.net.device.DeviceEvent.Type.*;
import static org.onlab.onos.cluster.ControllerNode.State.*;
import static org.onlab.onos.net.DefaultAnnotations.union;
import static java.util.Arrays.asList;
import java.io.IOException;
import java.util.Arrays;
import java.util.Collections;
import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map;
import java.util.Set;
import java.util.concurrent.CountDownLatch;
import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;

import org.easymock.Capture;
import org.junit.After;
import org.junit.AfterClass;
import org.junit.Before;
import org.junit.BeforeClass;
import org.junit.Ignore;
import org.junit.Test;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.ClusterEventListener;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.ClusterService;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.ControllerNode;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.ControllerNode.State;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.DefaultControllerNode;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.MastershipTerm;
import org.onlab.onos.cluster.NodeId;
import org.onlab.onos.net.Annotations;
import org.onlab.onos.net.DefaultAnnotations;
import org.onlab.onos.net.Device;
import org.onlab.onos.net.DeviceId;
import org.onlab.onos.net.Port;
import org.onlab.onos.net.PortNumber;
import org.onlab.onos.net.SparseAnnotations;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DefaultDeviceDescription;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DefaultPortDescription;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DeviceDescription;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DeviceEvent;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DeviceStore;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.DeviceStoreDelegate;
import org.onlab.onos.net.device.PortDescription;
import org.onlab.onos.net.provider.ProviderId;
import org.onlab.onos.store.ClockService;
import org.onlab.onos.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterCommunicationService;
import org.onlab.onos.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterMessage;
import org.onlab.onos.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterMessageHandler;
import org.onlab.onos.store.cluster.messaging.MessageSubject;
import org.onlab.packet.IpPrefix;

import com.google.common.collect.Iterables;
import com.google.common.collect.Sets;


// TODO add tests for remote replication
/**
 * Test of the gossip based distributed DeviceStore implementation.
 */
public class GossipDeviceStoreTest {

    private static final ProviderId PID = new ProviderId("of", "foo");
    private static final ProviderId PIDA = new ProviderId("of", "bar", true);
    private static final DeviceId DID1 = deviceId("of:foo");
    private static final DeviceId DID2 = deviceId("of:bar");
    private static final String MFR = "whitebox";
    private static final String HW = "1.1.x";
    private static final String SW1 = "3.8.1";
    private static final String SW2 = "3.9.5";
    private static final String SN = "43311-12345";

    private static final PortNumber P1 = PortNumber.portNumber(1);
    private static final PortNumber P2 = PortNumber.portNumber(2);
    private static final PortNumber P3 = PortNumber.portNumber(3);

    private static final SparseAnnotations A1 = DefaultAnnotations.builder()
            .set("A1", "a1")
            .set("B1", "b1")
            .build();
    private static final SparseAnnotations A1_2 = DefaultAnnotations.builder()
            .remove("A1")
            .set("B3", "b3")
            .build();
    private static final SparseAnnotations A2 = DefaultAnnotations.builder()
            .set("A2", "a2")
            .set("B2", "b2")
            .build();
    private static final SparseAnnotations A2_2 = DefaultAnnotations.builder()
            .remove("A2")
            .set("B4", "b4")
            .build();

    // local node
    private static final NodeId NID1 = new NodeId("local");
    private static final ControllerNode ONOS1 =
            new DefaultControllerNode(NID1, IpPrefix.valueOf("127.0.0.1"));

    // remote node
    private static final NodeId NID2 = new NodeId("remote");
    private static final ControllerNode ONOS2 =
            new DefaultControllerNode(NID2, IpPrefix.valueOf("127.0.0.2"));
    private static final List<SparseAnnotations> NO_ANNOTATION = Collections.<SparseAnnotations>emptyList();


    private TestGossipDeviceStore testGossipDeviceStore;
    private GossipDeviceStore gossipDeviceStore;
    private DeviceStore deviceStore;

    private DeviceClockManager deviceClockManager;
    private ClockService clockService;
    private ClusterCommunicationService clusterCommunicator;
    @BeforeClass
    public static void setUpBeforeClass() throws Exception {
    }

    @AfterClass
    public static void tearDownAfterClass() throws Exception {
    }


    @Before
    public void setUp() throws Exception {
        deviceClockManager = new DeviceClockManager();
        deviceClockManager.activate();
        clockService = deviceClockManager;

        deviceClockManager.setMastershipTerm(DID1, MastershipTerm.of(NID1, 1));
        deviceClockManager.setMastershipTerm(DID2, MastershipTerm.of(NID1, 2));

        clusterCommunicator = createNiceMock(ClusterCommunicationService.class);
        clusterCommunicator.addSubscriber(anyObject(MessageSubject.class),
                                    anyObject(ClusterMessageHandler.class));
        expectLastCall().anyTimes();
        replay(clusterCommunicator);
        ClusterService clusterService = new TestClusterService();

        testGossipDeviceStore = new TestGossipDeviceStore(clockService, clusterService, clusterCommunicator);
        gossipDeviceStore = testGossipDeviceStore;
        gossipDeviceStore.activate();
        deviceStore = gossipDeviceStore;
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        reset(clusterCommunicator);
    }

    @After
    public void tearDown() throws Exception {
        gossipDeviceStore.deactivate();
        deviceClockManager.deactivate();
    }

    private void putDevice(DeviceId deviceId, String swVersion,
                           SparseAnnotations... annotations) {
        DeviceDescription description =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(deviceId.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, swVersion, SN, annotations);
        reset(clusterCommunicator);
        try {
            expect(clusterCommunicator.broadcast(anyObject(ClusterMessage.class)))
                .andReturn(true).anyTimes();
        } catch (IOException e) {
            fail("Should never reach here");
        }
        replay(clusterCommunicator);
        deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, deviceId, description);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
    }

    private void putDeviceAncillary(DeviceId deviceId, String swVersion,
                                    SparseAnnotations... annotations) {
        DeviceDescription description =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(deviceId.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, swVersion, SN, annotations);
        deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PIDA, deviceId, description);
    }

    private static void assertDevice(DeviceId id, String swVersion, Device device) {
        assertNotNull(device);
        assertEquals(id, device.id());
        assertEquals(MFR, device.manufacturer());
        assertEquals(HW, device.hwVersion());
        assertEquals(swVersion, device.swVersion());
        assertEquals(SN, device.serialNumber());
    }

    /**
     * Verifies that Annotations created by merging {@code annotations} is
     * equal to actual Annotations.
     *
     * @param actual Annotations to check
     * @param annotations
     */
    private static void assertAnnotationsEquals(Annotations actual, SparseAnnotations... annotations) {
        SparseAnnotations expected = DefaultAnnotations.builder().build();
        for (SparseAnnotations a : annotations) {
            expected = DefaultAnnotations.union(expected, a);
        }
        assertEquals(expected.keys(), actual.keys());
        for (String key : expected.keys()) {
            assertEquals(expected.value(key), actual.value(key));
        }
    }

    private static void assertDeviceDescriptionEquals(DeviceDescription expected,
                                                DeviceDescription actual) {
        if (expected == actual) {
            return;
        }
        assertEquals(expected.deviceURI(), actual.deviceURI());
        assertEquals(expected.hwVersion(), actual.hwVersion());
        assertEquals(expected.manufacturer(), actual.manufacturer());
        assertEquals(expected.serialNumber(), actual.serialNumber());
        assertEquals(expected.swVersion(), actual.swVersion());

        assertAnnotationsEquals(actual.annotations(), expected.annotations());
    }

    private static void assertDeviceDescriptionEquals(DeviceDescription expected,
            List<SparseAnnotations> expectedAnnotations,
            DeviceDescription actual) {
        if (expected == actual) {
            return;
        }
        assertEquals(expected.deviceURI(), actual.deviceURI());
        assertEquals(expected.hwVersion(), actual.hwVersion());
        assertEquals(expected.manufacturer(), actual.manufacturer());
        assertEquals(expected.serialNumber(), actual.serialNumber());
        assertEquals(expected.swVersion(), actual.swVersion());

        assertAnnotationsEquals(actual.annotations(),
                expectedAnnotations.toArray(new SparseAnnotations[0]));
    }

    @Test
    public final void testGetDeviceCount() {
        assertEquals("initialy empty", 0, deviceStore.getDeviceCount());

        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        putDevice(DID2, SW2);
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);

        assertEquals("expect 2 uniq devices", 2, deviceStore.getDeviceCount());
    }

    @Test
    public final void testGetDevices() {
        assertEquals("initialy empty", 0, Iterables.size(deviceStore.getDevices()));

        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        putDevice(DID2, SW2);
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);

        assertEquals("expect 2 uniq devices",
                2, Iterables.size(deviceStore.getDevices()));

        Map<DeviceId, Device> devices = new HashMap<>();
        for (Device device : deviceStore.getDevices()) {
            devices.put(device.id(), device);
        }

        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, devices.get(DID1));
        assertDevice(DID2, SW2, devices.get(DID2));

        // add case for new node?
    }

    @Test
    public final void testGetDevice() {

        putDevice(DID1, SW1);

        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, deviceStore.getDevice(DID1));
        assertNull("DID2 shouldn't be there", deviceStore.getDevice(DID2));
    }

    private void assertInternalDeviceEvent(NodeId sender,
                                           DeviceId deviceId,
                                           ProviderId providerId,
                                           DeviceDescription expectedDesc,
                                           Capture<ClusterMessage> actualMsg) {
        assertTrue(actualMsg.hasCaptured());
        assertEquals(sender, actualMsg.getValue().sender());
        assertEquals(GossipDeviceStoreMessageSubjects.DEVICE_UPDATE,
                     actualMsg.getValue().subject());
        InternalDeviceEvent addEvent
            = testGossipDeviceStore.deserialize(actualMsg.getValue().payload());
        assertEquals(deviceId, addEvent.deviceId());
        assertEquals(providerId, addEvent.providerId());
        assertDeviceDescriptionEquals(expectedDesc, addEvent.deviceDescription().value());
    }

    private void assertInternalDeviceEvent(NodeId sender,
                                           DeviceId deviceId,
                                           ProviderId providerId,
                                           DeviceDescription expectedDesc,
                                           List<SparseAnnotations> expectedAnnotations,
                                           Capture<ClusterMessage> actualMsg) {
        assertTrue(actualMsg.hasCaptured());
        assertEquals(sender, actualMsg.getValue().sender());
        assertEquals(GossipDeviceStoreMessageSubjects.DEVICE_UPDATE,
                actualMsg.getValue().subject());
        InternalDeviceEvent addEvent
            = testGossipDeviceStore.deserialize(actualMsg.getValue().payload());
        assertEquals(deviceId, addEvent.deviceId());
        assertEquals(providerId, addEvent.providerId());
        assertDeviceDescriptionEquals(expectedDesc, expectedAnnotations, addEvent.deviceDescription().value());
    }

    @Test
    public final void testCreateOrUpdateDevice() throws IOException {
        DeviceDescription description =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW1, SN);
        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_ADDED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalDeviceEvent(NID1, DID1, PID, description, bcast);


        DeviceDescription description2 =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW2, SN);
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        DeviceEvent event2 = deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description2);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_UPDATED, event2.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW2, event2.subject());

        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalDeviceEvent(NID1, DID1, PID, description2, bcast);
        reset(clusterCommunicator);

        assertNull("No change expected", deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description2));
    }

    @Test
    public final void testCreateOrUpdateDeviceAncillary() throws IOException {
        // add
        DeviceDescription description =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW1, SN, A2);
        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PIDA, DID1, description);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_ADDED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
        assertEquals(PIDA, event.subject().providerId());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event.subject().annotations(), A2);
        assertFalse("Ancillary will not bring device up", deviceStore.isAvailable(DID1));
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalDeviceEvent(NID1, DID1, PIDA, description, bcast);

        // update from primary
        DeviceDescription description2 =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW2, SN, A1);
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);

        DeviceEvent event2 = deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description2);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_UPDATED, event2.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW2, event2.subject());
        assertEquals(PID, event2.subject().providerId());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event2.subject().annotations(), A1, A2);
        assertTrue(deviceStore.isAvailable(DID1));
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalDeviceEvent(NID1, DID1, PID, description2, bcast);

        // no-op update from primary
        resetCommunicatorExpectingNoBroadcast(bcast);
        assertNull("No change expected", deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description2));

        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertFalse("no broadcast expected", bcast.hasCaptured());

        // For now, Ancillary is ignored once primary appears
        resetCommunicatorExpectingNoBroadcast(bcast);

        assertNull("No change expected", deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PIDA, DID1, description));

        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertFalse("no broadcast expected", bcast.hasCaptured());

        // But, Ancillary annotations will be in effect
        DeviceDescription description3 =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW1, SN, A2_2);
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);

        DeviceEvent event3 = deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PIDA, DID1, description3);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_UPDATED, event3.type());
        // basic information will be the one from Primary
        assertDevice(DID1, SW2, event3.subject());
        assertEquals(PID, event3.subject().providerId());
        // but annotation from Ancillary will be merged
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event3.subject().annotations(), A1, A2, A2_2);
        assertTrue(deviceStore.isAvailable(DID1));
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // note: only annotation from PIDA is sent over the wire
        assertInternalDeviceEvent(NID1, DID1, PIDA, description3,
                                  asList(union(A2, A2_2)), bcast);

    }


    @Test
    public final void testMarkOffline() {

        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        assertTrue(deviceStore.isAvailable(DID1));

        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.markOffline(DID1);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_AVAILABILITY_CHANGED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
        assertFalse(deviceStore.isAvailable(DID1));
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());


        resetCommunicatorExpectingNoBroadcast(bcast);
        DeviceEvent event2 = deviceStore.markOffline(DID1);
        assertNull("No change, no event", event2);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertFalse(bcast.hasCaptured());
    }

    @Test
    public final void testUpdatePorts() {
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P2, true)
                );
        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        List<DeviceEvent> events = deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        Set<PortNumber> expectedPorts = Sets.newHashSet(P1, P2);
        for (DeviceEvent event : events) {
            assertEquals(PORT_ADDED, event.type());
            assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
            assertTrue("PortNumber is one of expected",
                    expectedPorts.remove(event.port().number()));
            assertTrue("Port is enabled", event.port().isEnabled());
        }
        assertTrue("Event for all expectedport appeared", expectedPorts.isEmpty());


        List<PortDescription> pds2 = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, false),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P2, true),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P3, true)
                );

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        events = deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds2);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        assertFalse("event should be triggered", events.isEmpty());
        for (DeviceEvent event : events) {
            PortNumber num = event.port().number();
            if (P1.equals(num)) {
                assertEquals(PORT_UPDATED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
                assertFalse("Port is disabled", event.port().isEnabled());
            } else if (P2.equals(num)) {
                fail("P2 event not expected.");
            } else if (P3.equals(num)) {
                assertEquals(PORT_ADDED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
                assertTrue("Port is enabled", event.port().isEnabled());
            } else {
                fail("Unknown port number encountered: " + num);
            }
        }

        List<PortDescription> pds3 = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, false),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P2, true)
                );
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        events = deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds3);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        assertFalse("event should be triggered", events.isEmpty());
        for (DeviceEvent event : events) {
            PortNumber num = event.port().number();
            if (P1.equals(num)) {
                fail("P1 event not expected.");
            } else if (P2.equals(num)) {
                fail("P2 event not expected.");
            } else if (P3.equals(num)) {
                assertEquals(PORT_REMOVED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
                assertTrue("Port was enabled", event.port().isEnabled());
            } else {
                fail("Unknown port number encountered: " + num);
            }
        }
    }

    @Test
    public final void testUpdatePortStatus() {
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);

        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        final DefaultPortDescription desc = new DefaultPortDescription(P1, false);
        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.updatePortStatus(PID, DID1, desc);
        assertEquals(PORT_UPDATED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
        assertEquals(P1, event.port().number());
        assertFalse("Port is disabled", event.port().isEnabled());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalPortStatusEvent(NID1, DID1, PID, desc, NO_ANNOTATION, bcast);
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());
    }

    @Test
    public final void testUpdatePortStatusAncillary() throws IOException {
        putDeviceAncillary(DID1, SW1);
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true, A1)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);

        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();


        // update port from primary
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        final DefaultPortDescription desc1 = new DefaultPortDescription(P1, false, A1_2);
        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.updatePortStatus(PID, DID1, desc1);
        assertEquals(PORT_UPDATED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
        assertEquals(P1, event.port().number());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event.port().annotations(), A1, A1_2);
        assertFalse("Port is disabled", event.port().isEnabled());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalPortStatusEvent(NID1, DID1, PID, desc1, asList(A1, A1_2), bcast);
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        // update port from ancillary with no attributes
        resetCommunicatorExpectingNoBroadcast(bcast);
        final DefaultPortDescription desc2 = new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true);
        DeviceEvent event2 = deviceStore.updatePortStatus(PIDA, DID1, desc2);
        assertNull("Ancillary is ignored if primary exists", event2);
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertFalse(bcast.hasCaptured());

        // but, Ancillary annotation update will be notified
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        final DefaultPortDescription desc3 = new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true, A2);
        DeviceEvent event3 = deviceStore.updatePortStatus(PIDA, DID1, desc3);
        assertEquals(PORT_UPDATED, event3.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event3.subject());
        assertEquals(P1, event3.port().number());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event3.port().annotations(), A1, A1_2, A2);
        assertFalse("Port is disabled", event3.port().isEnabled());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        assertInternalPortStatusEvent(NID1, DID1, PIDA, desc3, asList(A2), bcast);
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        // port only reported from Ancillary will be notified as down
        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);
        final DefaultPortDescription desc4 = new DefaultPortDescription(P2, true);
        DeviceEvent event4 = deviceStore.updatePortStatus(PIDA, DID1, desc4);
        assertEquals(PORT_ADDED, event4.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event4.subject());
        assertEquals(P2, event4.port().number());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(event4.port().annotations());
        assertFalse("Port is disabled if not given from primary provider",
                        event4.port().isEnabled());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message content
        assertInternalPortStatusEvent(NID1, DID1, PIDA, desc4, NO_ANNOTATION, bcast);
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());
    }

    private void assertInternalPortStatusEvent(NodeId sender, DeviceId did,
            ProviderId pid, DefaultPortDescription expectedDesc,
            List<SparseAnnotations> expectedAnnotations, Capture<ClusterMessage> actualMsg) {

        assertTrue(actualMsg.hasCaptured());
        assertEquals(sender, actualMsg.getValue().sender());
        assertEquals(GossipDeviceStoreMessageSubjects.PORT_STATUS_UPDATE,
                actualMsg.getValue().subject());
        InternalPortStatusEvent addEvent
            = testGossipDeviceStore.deserialize(actualMsg.getValue().payload());
        assertEquals(did, addEvent.deviceId());
        assertEquals(pid, addEvent.providerId());
        assertPortDescriptionEquals(expectedDesc, expectedAnnotations,
                addEvent.portDescription().value());

    }

    private void assertPortDescriptionEquals(
                                    PortDescription expectedDesc,
                                    List<SparseAnnotations> expectedAnnotations,
                                    PortDescription actual) {

        assertEquals(expectedDesc.portNumber(), actual.portNumber());
        assertEquals(expectedDesc.isEnabled(), actual.isEnabled());

        assertAnnotationsEquals(actual.annotations(),
                         expectedAnnotations.toArray(new SparseAnnotations[0]));
    }

    private void resetCommunicatorExpectingNoBroadcast(
            Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast) {
        bcast.reset();
        reset(clusterCommunicator);
        replay(clusterCommunicator);
    }

    private void resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(
            Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast) {

        bcast.reset();
        reset(clusterCommunicator);
        try {
            expect(clusterCommunicator.broadcast(capture(bcast))).andReturn(true).once();
        } catch (IOException e) {
            fail("Should never reach here");
        }
        replay(clusterCommunicator);
    }

    @Test
    public final void testGetPorts() {
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        putDevice(DID2, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P2, true)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);

        Set<PortNumber> expectedPorts = Sets.newHashSet(P1, P2);
        List<Port> ports = deviceStore.getPorts(DID1);
        for (Port port : ports) {
            assertTrue("Port is enabled", port.isEnabled());
            assertTrue("PortNumber is one of expected",
                    expectedPorts.remove(port.number()));
        }
        assertTrue("Event for all expectedport appeared", expectedPorts.isEmpty());


        assertTrue("DID2 has no ports", deviceStore.getPorts(DID2).isEmpty());
    }

    @Test
    public final void testGetPort() {
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        putDevice(DID2, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true),
                new DefaultPortDescription(P2, false)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);

        Port port1 = deviceStore.getPort(DID1, P1);
        assertEquals(P1, port1.number());
        assertTrue("Port is enabled", port1.isEnabled());

        Port port2 = deviceStore.getPort(DID1, P2);
        assertEquals(P2, port2.number());
        assertFalse("Port is disabled", port2.isEnabled());

        Port port3 = deviceStore.getPort(DID1, P3);
        assertNull("P3 not expected", port3);
    }

    @Test
    public final void testRemoveDevice() {
        putDevice(DID1, SW1, A1);
        List<PortDescription> pds = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true, A2)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds);
        putDevice(DID2, SW1);

        assertEquals(2, deviceStore.getDeviceCount());
        assertEquals(1, deviceStore.getPorts(DID1).size());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(deviceStore.getDevice(DID1).annotations(), A1);
        assertAnnotationsEquals(deviceStore.getPort(DID1, P1).annotations(), A2);

        Capture<ClusterMessage> bcast = new Capture<>();

        resetCommunicatorExpectingSingleBroadcast(bcast);

        DeviceEvent event = deviceStore.removeDevice(DID1);
        assertEquals(DEVICE_REMOVED, event.type());
        assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());

        assertEquals(1, deviceStore.getDeviceCount());
        assertEquals(0, deviceStore.getPorts(DID1).size());
        verify(clusterCommunicator);
        // TODO: verify broadcast message
        assertTrue(bcast.hasCaptured());

        // putBack Device, Port w/o annotation
        putDevice(DID1, SW1);
        List<PortDescription> pds2 = Arrays.<PortDescription>asList(
                new DefaultPortDescription(P1, true)
                );
        deviceStore.updatePorts(PID, DID1, pds2);

        // annotations should not survive
        assertEquals(2, deviceStore.getDeviceCount());
        assertEquals(1, deviceStore.getPorts(DID1).size());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(deviceStore.getDevice(DID1).annotations());
        assertAnnotationsEquals(deviceStore.getPort(DID1, P1).annotations());
    }

    // If Delegates should be called only on remote events,
    // then Simple* should never call them, thus not test required.
    // TODO add test for Port events when we have them
    @Ignore("Ignore until Delegate spec. is clear.")
    @Test
    public final void testEvents() throws InterruptedException {
        final CountDownLatch addLatch = new CountDownLatch(1);
        DeviceStoreDelegate checkAdd = new DeviceStoreDelegate() {
            @Override
            public void notify(DeviceEvent event) {
                assertEquals(DEVICE_ADDED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW1, event.subject());
                addLatch.countDown();
            }
        };
        final CountDownLatch updateLatch = new CountDownLatch(1);
        DeviceStoreDelegate checkUpdate = new DeviceStoreDelegate() {
            @Override
            public void notify(DeviceEvent event) {
                assertEquals(DEVICE_UPDATED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW2, event.subject());
                updateLatch.countDown();
            }
        };
        final CountDownLatch removeLatch = new CountDownLatch(1);
        DeviceStoreDelegate checkRemove = new DeviceStoreDelegate() {
            @Override
            public void notify(DeviceEvent event) {
                assertEquals(DEVICE_REMOVED, event.type());
                assertDevice(DID1, SW2, event.subject());
                removeLatch.countDown();
            }
        };

        DeviceDescription description =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW1, SN);
        deviceStore.setDelegate(checkAdd);
        deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description);
        assertTrue("Add event fired", addLatch.await(1, TimeUnit.SECONDS));


        DeviceDescription description2 =
                new DefaultDeviceDescription(DID1.uri(), SWITCH, MFR,
                        HW, SW2, SN);
        deviceStore.unsetDelegate(checkAdd);
        deviceStore.setDelegate(checkUpdate);
        deviceStore.createOrUpdateDevice(PID, DID1, description2);
        assertTrue("Update event fired", updateLatch.await(1, TimeUnit.SECONDS));

        deviceStore.unsetDelegate(checkUpdate);
        deviceStore.setDelegate(checkRemove);
        deviceStore.removeDevice(DID1);
        assertTrue("Remove event fired", removeLatch.await(1, TimeUnit.SECONDS));
    }

    private static final class TestGossipDeviceStore extends GossipDeviceStore {

        public TestGossipDeviceStore(
                ClockService clockService,
                ClusterService clusterService,
                ClusterCommunicationService clusterCommunicator) {
            this.clockService = clockService;
            this.clusterService = clusterService;
            this.clusterCommunicator = clusterCommunicator;
        }

        public <T> T deserialize(byte[] bytes) {
            return SERIALIZER.decode(bytes);
        }
    }

    private static final class TestClusterService implements ClusterService {

        private final Map<NodeId, ControllerNode> nodes = new HashMap<>();
        private final Map<NodeId, ControllerNode.State> nodeStates = new HashMap<>();

        public TestClusterService() {
            nodes.put(NID1, ONOS1);
            nodeStates.put(NID1, ACTIVE);

            nodes.put(NID2, ONOS2);
            nodeStates.put(NID2, ACTIVE);
        }

        @Override
        public ControllerNode getLocalNode() {
            return GossipDeviceStoreTest.ONOS1;
        }

        @Override
        public Set<ControllerNode> getNodes() {
            return Sets.newHashSet(nodes.values());
        }

        @Override
        public ControllerNode getNode(NodeId nodeId) {
            return nodes.get(nodeId);
        }

        @Override
        public State getState(NodeId nodeId) {
            return nodeStates.get(nodeId);
        }

        @Override
        public void addListener(ClusterEventListener listener) {
        }

        @Override
        public void removeListener(ClusterEventListener listener) {
        }
    }
}