Add HA tests

If no OC vars are found, set onosdriver.maxNodes to None

Change-Id: I74ff5762a8399a93084e0d8a2acd11acb8a5f4e5
diff --git a/TestON/drivers/common/cli/onosdriver.py b/TestON/drivers/common/cli/onosdriver.py
index e602a71..7520f46 100644
--- a/TestON/drivers/common/cli/onosdriver.py
+++ b/TestON/drivers/common/cli/onosdriver.py
@@ -94,6 +94,7 @@
                         main.log.info( "Could not read any environment variable"
                                        + " please load a cell file with all" +
                                         " onos IP" )
+                        self.maxNodes = None
                     else:
                         main.log.info( self.name + ": Found " +
                                        str( self.onosIps.values() ) +
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.params b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.params
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..0435e0b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.params
@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
+<PARAMS>
+    <testcases>1,2,8,3,8,4,5,14,16,17,[6],8,3,7,4,15,17,9,8,4,10,8,4,11,8,4,12,8,4,13</testcases>
+    <ENV>
+        <cellName>HA</cellName>
+        <appString>drivers,openflow,proxyarp,mobility</appString>
+    </ENV>
+    <Git> False </Git>
+    <branch> master </branch>
+    <num_controllers> 7 </num_controllers>
+    <tcpdump> False </tcpdump>
+
+    <CTRL>
+        <port1>6633</port1>
+        <port2>6633</port2>
+        <port3>6633</port3>
+        <port4>6633</port4>
+        <port5>6633</port5>
+        <port6>6633</port6>
+        <port7>6633</port7>
+    </CTRL>
+    <BACKUP>
+        <ENABLED> False </ENABLED>
+        <TESTONUSER>admin</TESTONUSER>
+        <TESTONIP>10.128.30.9</TESTONIP>
+    </BACKUP>
+    <PING>
+        <source1>h8</source1>
+        <source2>h9</source2>
+        <source3>h10</source3>
+        <source4>h11</source4>
+        <source5>h12</source5>
+        <source6>h13</source6>
+        <source7>h14</source7>
+        <source8>h15</source8>
+        <source9>h16</source9>
+        <source10>h17</source10>
+        <target1>10.0.0.18</target1>
+        <target2>10.0.0.19</target2>
+        <target3>10.0.0.20</target3>
+        <target4>10.0.0.21</target4>
+        <target5>10.0.0.22</target5>
+        <target6>10.0.0.23</target6>
+        <target7>10.0.0.24</target7>
+        <target8>10.0.0.25</target8>
+        <target9>10.0.0.26</target9>
+        <target10>10.0.0.27</target10>
+    </PING>
+    <timers>
+        <LinkDiscovery>.2</LinkDiscovery>
+        <SwitchDiscovery>.2</SwitchDiscovery>
+    </timers>
+    <kill>
+        <switch> s5 </switch>
+        <dpid> 0000000000005000 </dpid>
+        <links> h5 s2 s1 s6 </links>
+    </kill>
+    <MNtcpdump>
+        <intf>eth0</intf>
+        <port> </port>
+        <folder>~/packet_captures/</folder>
+    </MNtcpdump>
+</PARAMS>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.py b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..755a89c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.py
@@ -0,0 +1,4037 @@
+"""
+Description: This test is to determine if ONOS can handle
+    all of it's nodes restarting
+
+List of test cases:
+CASE1: Compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+CASE2: Assign devices to controllers
+CASE21: Assign mastership to controllers
+CASE3: Assign intents
+CASE4: Ping across added host intents
+CASE5: Reading state of ONOS
+CASE6: The Failure case.
+CASE7: Check state after control plane failure
+CASE8: Compare topo
+CASE9: Link s3-s28 down
+CASE10: Link s3-s28 up
+CASE11: Switch down
+CASE12: Switch up
+CASE13: Clean up
+CASE14: start election app on all onos nodes
+CASE15: Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+CASE16: Install Distributed Primitives app
+CASE17: Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+"""
+
+
+class HAclusterRestart:
+
+    def __init__( self ):
+        self.default = ''
+
+    def CASE1( self, main ):
+        """
+        CASE1 is to compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+
+        Startup sequence:
+        cell <name>
+        onos-verify-cell
+        NOTE: temporary - onos-remove-raft-logs
+        onos-uninstall
+        start mininet
+        git pull
+        mvn clean install
+        onos-package
+        onos-install -f
+        onos-wait-for-start
+        start cli sessions
+        start tcpdump
+        """
+        main.log.info( "ONOS HA test: Restart all ONOS nodes - " +
+                         "initialization" )
+        main.case( "Setting up test environment" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Setup the test environment including " +\
+                                "installing ONOS, starting Mininet and ONOS" +\
+                                "cli sessions."
+        # TODO: save all the timers and output them for plotting
+
+        # load some variables from the params file
+        PULLCODE = False
+        if main.params[ 'Git' ] == 'True':
+            PULLCODE = True
+        gitBranch = main.params[ 'branch' ]
+        cellName = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'cellName' ]
+
+        # set global variables
+        global numControllers
+        numControllers = int( main.params[ 'num_controllers' ] )
+        if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes:
+            if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes < numControllers:
+                numControllers = int( main.ONOSbench.maxNodes )
+        global ONOS1Port
+        global ONOS2Port
+        global ONOS3Port
+        global ONOS4Port
+        global ONOS5Port
+        global ONOS6Port
+        global ONOS7Port
+        # These are for csv plotting in jenkins
+        global labels
+        global data
+        labels = []
+        data = []
+
+        # FIXME: just get controller port from params?
+        # TODO: do we really need all these?
+        ONOS1Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port1' ]
+        ONOS2Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port2' ]
+        ONOS3Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port3' ]
+        ONOS4Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port4' ]
+        ONOS5Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port5' ]
+        ONOS6Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port6' ]
+        ONOS7Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port7' ]
+
+        global CLIs
+        CLIs = []
+        global nodes
+        nodes = []
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( 1, numControllers + 1 ):
+            CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
+            nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+            ipList.append( nodes[ -1 ].ip_address )
+
+        main.step( "Create cell file" )
+        cellAppString = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'appString' ]
+        main.ONOSbench.createCellFile( main.ONOSbench.ip_address, cellName,
+                                       main.Mininet1.ip_address,
+                                       cellAppString, ipList )
+        main.step( "Applying cell variable to environment" )
+        cellResult = main.ONOSbench.setCell( cellName )
+        verifyResult = main.ONOSbench.verifyCell()
+
+        # FIXME:this is short term fix
+        main.log.info( "Removing raft logs" )
+        main.ONOSbench.onosRemoveRaftLogs()
+
+        main.log.info( "Uninstalling ONOS" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            main.ONOSbench.onosUninstall( node.ip_address )
+
+        # Make sure ONOS is DEAD
+        main.log.info( "Killing any ONOS processes" )
+        killResults = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            killed = main.ONOSbench.onosKill( node.ip_address )
+            killResults = killResults and killed
+
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        gitPullResult = main.TRUE
+
+        main.step( "Starting Mininet" )
+        # scp topo file to mininet
+        # TODO: move to params?
+        topoName = "obelisk.py"
+        filePath = main.ONOSbench.home + "/tools/test/topos/"
+        main.ONOSbench.copyMininetFile( topoName, filePath,
+                                        main.Mininet1.user_name,
+                                        main.Mininet1.ip_address )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.startNet( )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet Started",
+                                 onfail="Error starting Mininet" )
+
+        main.step( "Git checkout and pull " + gitBranch )
+        if PULLCODE:
+            main.ONOSbench.gitCheckout( gitBranch )
+            gitPullResult = main.ONOSbench.gitPull()
+            # values of 1 or 3 are good
+            utilities.assert_lesser( expect=0, actual=gitPullResult,
+                                      onpass="Git pull successful",
+                                      onfail="Git pull failed" )
+        main.ONOSbench.getVersion( report=True )
+
+        main.step( "Using mvn clean install" )
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        if PULLCODE and gitPullResult == main.TRUE:
+            cleanInstallResult = main.ONOSbench.cleanInstall()
+        else:
+            main.log.warn( "Did not pull new code so skipping mvn " +
+                           "clean install" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=cleanInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="MCI successful",
+                                 onfail="MCI failed" )
+        # GRAPHS
+        # NOTE: important params here:
+        #       job = name of Jenkins job
+        #       Plot Name = Plot-HA, only can be used if multiple plots
+        #       index = The number of the graph under plot name
+        job = "HAclusterRestart"
+        plotName = "Plot-HA"
+        graphs = '<ac:structured-macro ac:name="html">\n'
+        graphs += '<ac:plain-text-body><![CDATA[\n'
+        graphs += '<iframe src="https://onos-jenkins.onlab.us/job/' + job +\
+                  '/plot/' + plotName + '/getPlot?index=0' +\
+                  '&width=500&height=300"' +\
+                  'noborder="0" width="500" height="300" scrolling="yes" ' +\
+                  'seamless="seamless"></iframe>\n'
+        graphs += ']]></ac:plain-text-body>\n'
+        graphs += '</ac:structured-macro>\n'
+        main.log.wiki(graphs)
+
+        main.step( "Creating ONOS package" )
+        packageResult = main.ONOSbench.onosPackage()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=packageResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS package successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS package failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Installing ONOS package" )
+        onosInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            tmpResult = main.ONOSbench.onosInstall( options="-f",
+                                                    node=node.ip_address )
+            onosInstallResult = onosInstallResult and tmpResult
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS install successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS install failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking if ONOS is up yet" )
+        for i in range( 2 ):
+            onosIsupResult = main.TRUE
+            for node in nodes:
+                started = main.ONOSbench.isup( node.ip_address )
+                if not started:
+                    main.log.error( node.name + " didn't start!" )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStop( node.ip_address )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStart( node.ip_address )
+                onosIsupResult = onosIsupResult and started
+            if onosIsupResult == main.TRUE:
+                break
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosIsupResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS startup failed" )
+
+        main.log.step( "Starting ONOS CLI sessions" )
+        cliResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].startOnosCli,
+                             name="startOnosCli-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[nodes[i].ip_address] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            cliResults = cliResults and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=cliResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS cli startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS cli startup failed" )
+
+        if main.params[ 'tcpdump' ].lower() == "true":
+            main.step( "Start Packet Capture MN" )
+            main.Mininet2.startTcpdump(
+                str( main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'folder' ] ) + str( main.TEST )
+                + "-MN.pcap",
+                intf=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'intf' ],
+                port=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'port' ] )
+
+        main.step( "App Ids check" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        if cliResults == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error( "Failed to start ONOS, stopping test" )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+
+    def CASE2( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign devices to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning devices to controllers" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Assign switches to ONOS using 'ovs-vsctl' " +\
+                                "and check that an ONOS node becomes the " +\
+                                "master of the device."
+        main.step( "Assign switches to controllers" )
+
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        swList = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            swList.append( "s" + str( i ) )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=swList, ip=ipList )
+
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            response = main.Mininet1.getSwController( "s" + str( i ) )
+            try:
+                main.log.info( str( response ) )
+            except Exception:
+                main.log.info( repr( response ) )
+            for node in nodes:
+                if re.search( "tcp:" + node.ip_address, response ):
+                    mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "Error, node " + node.ip_address + " is " +
+                                    "not in the list of controllers s" +
+                                    str( i ) + " is connecting to." )
+                    mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Switch mastership assigned correctly",
+            onfail="Switches not assigned correctly to controllers" )
+
+    def CASE21( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign mastership to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning Controller roles for switches" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Check that ONOS is connected to each " +\
+                                "device. Then manually assign" +\
+                                " mastership to specific ONOS nodes using" +\
+                                " 'device-role'"
+        main.step( "Assign mastership of switches to specific controllers" )
+        # Manually assign mastership to the controller we want
+        roleCall = main.TRUE
+
+        ipList = [ ]
+        deviceList = []
+        try:
+            # Assign mastership to specific controllers. This assignment was
+            # determined for a 7 node cluser, but will work with any sized
+            # cluster
+            for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # switches 1 through 28
+                # set up correct variables:
+                if i == 1:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "1000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 2:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 3:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 4:
+                    c = 3 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS4
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3004" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 5:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "5000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 6:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 7:
+                    c = 5 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS6
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6007" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                    c = 4 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS5
+                    dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                    c = 6 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS7
+                    dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 28:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2800" ).get( 'id' )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "You didn't write an else statement for " +
+                                    "switch s" + str( i ) )
+                    roleCall = main.FALSE
+                # Assign switch
+                assert deviceId, "No device id for s" + str( i ) + " in ONOS"
+                # TODO: make this controller dynamic
+                roleCall = roleCall and main.ONOScli1.deviceRole( deviceId,
+                                                                  ip )
+                ipList.append( ip )
+                deviceList.append( deviceId )
+        except ( AttributeError, AssertionError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with ONOS device view" )
+            main.log.info( main.ONOScli1.devices() )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCall,
+            onpass="Re-assigned switch mastership to designated controller",
+            onfail="Something wrong with deviceRole calls" )
+
+        main.step( "Check mastership was correctly assigned" )
+        roleCheck = main.TRUE
+        # NOTE: This is due to the fact that device mastership change is not
+        #       atomic and is actually a multi step process
+        time.sleep( 5 )
+        for i in range( len( ipList ) ):
+            ip = ipList[i]
+            deviceId = deviceList[i]
+            # Check assignment
+            master = main.ONOScli1.getRole( deviceId ).get( 'master' )
+            if ip in master:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "Error, controller " + ip + " is not" +
+                                " master " + "of device " +
+                                str( deviceId ) + ". Master is " +
+                                repr( master ) + "." )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCheck,
+            onpass="Switches were successfully reassigned to designated " +
+                   "controller",
+            onfail="Switches were not successfully reassigned" )
+
+    def CASE3( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign intents
+        """
+        import time
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        try:
+            labels
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "labels not defined, setting to []" )
+            labels = []
+        try:
+            data
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "data not defined, setting to []" )
+            data = []
+        # NOTE: we must reinstall intents until we have a persistant intent
+        #        datastore!
+        main.case( "Adding host Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Discover hosts by using pingall then " +\
+                                "assign predetermined host-to-host intents." +\
+                                " After installation, check that the intent" +\
+                                " is distributed to all nodes and the state" +\
+                                " is INSTALLED"
+
+        # install onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Install reactive forwarding app" )
+        installResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=installResults,
+                                 onpass="Install fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Install fwd failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Discovering Hosts( Via pingall for now )" )
+        # FIXME: Once we have a host discovery mechanism, use that instead
+        # REACTIVE FWD test
+        pingResult = main.FALSE
+        for i in range(2):  # Retry if pingall fails first time
+            time1 = time.time()
+            pingResult = main.Mininet1.pingall()
+            if i == 0:
+                utilities.assert_equals(
+                    expect=main.TRUE,
+                    actual=pingResult,
+                    onpass="Reactive Pingall test passed",
+                    onfail="Reactive Pingall failed, " +
+                           "one or more ping pairs failed" )
+            time2 = time.time()
+            main.log.info( "Time for pingall: %2f seconds" %
+                           ( time2 - time1 ) )
+        # timeout for fwd flows
+        time.sleep( 11 )
+        # uninstall onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Uninstall reactive forwarding app" )
+        uninstallResult = CLIs[0].deactivateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=uninstallResult,
+                                 onpass="Uninstall fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Uninstall fwd failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        threads = []
+        appCheck2 = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck2 = appCheck2 and t.result
+        if appCheck2 != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck2,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Add host intents via cli" )
+        intentIds = []
+        # TODO:  move the host numbers to params
+        #        Maybe look at all the paths we ping?
+        intentAddResult = True
+        hostResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info( "Adding host intent between h" + str( i ) +
+                           " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            host1 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            host2 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i + 10 )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            # NOTE: getHost can return None
+            host1Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host1 )
+            host2Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host2 )
+            host1Id = None
+            host2Id = None
+            if host1Dict and host2Dict:
+                host1Id = host1Dict.get( 'id', None )
+                host2Id = host2Dict.get( 'id', None )
+            if host1Id and host2Id:
+                nodeNum = ( i % numControllers )
+                tmpId = CLIs[ nodeNum ].addHostIntent( host1Id, host2Id )
+                if tmpId:
+                    main.log.info( "Added intent with id: " + tmpId )
+                    intentIds.append( tmpId )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "addHostIntent returned: " +
+                                     repr( tmpId ) )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error, getHost() failed for h" + str( i ) +
+                                " and/or h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+                hosts = CLIs[ 0 ].hosts()
+                main.log.warn( "Hosts output: " )
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( hosts ),
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts ) )
+                hostResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=hostResult,
+                                 onpass="Found a host id for each host",
+                                 onfail="Error looking up host ids" )
+
+        intentStart = time.time()
+        onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+        main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+        main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+        for intent in intentIds:
+            if intent in onosIds:
+                pass  # intent submitted is in onos
+            else:
+                intentAddResult = False
+        if intentAddResult:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        else:
+            intentStop = None
+        # Print the intent states
+        intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+        intentStates = []
+        installedCheck = True
+        main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+        count = 0
+        try:
+            for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                    installedCheck = False
+                intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+        # add submitted intents not in the store
+        tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+        missingIntents = False
+        for i in intentIds:
+            if i not in tmplist:
+                intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+                missingIntents = True
+        intentStates.sort()
+        for i, s in intentStates:
+            count += 1
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                           ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        try:
+            missing = False
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        missing = True
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+        # Check all nodes
+        if missing:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        intentAddResult = bool( intentAddResult and not missingIntents and
+                                installedCheck )
+        if not intentAddResult:
+            main.log.error( "Error in pushing host intents to ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Intent Anti-Entropy dispersion" )
+        for i in range(100):
+            correct = True
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( sorted( intentIds ) ) )
+            for cli in CLIs:
+                onosIds = []
+                ids = cli.getAllIntentsId()
+                onosIds.append( ids )
+                main.log.debug( "Intents in " + cli.name + ": " +
+                                str( sorted( onosIds ) ) )
+                if sorted( ids ) != sorted( intentIds ):
+                    main.log.warn( "Set of intent IDs doesn't match" )
+                    correct = False
+                    break
+                else:
+                    intents = json.loads( cli.intents() )
+                    for intent in intents:
+                        if intent[ 'state' ] != "INSTALLED":
+                            main.log.warn( "Intent " + intent[ 'id' ] +
+                                           " is " + intent[ 'state' ] )
+                            correct = False
+                            break
+            if correct:
+                break
+            else:
+                time.sleep(1)
+        if not intentStop:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        global gossipTime
+        gossipTime = intentStop - intentStart
+        main.log.info( "It took about " + str( gossipTime ) +
+                        " seconds for all intents to appear in each node" )
+        append = False
+        title = "Gossip Intents"
+        count = 1
+        while append is False:
+            curTitle = title + str( count )
+            if curTitle not in labels:
+                labels.append( curTitle )
+                data.append( str( gossipTime ) )
+                append = True
+            else:
+                count += 1
+        # FIXME: make this time configurable/calculate based off of number of
+        #        nodes and gossip rounds
+        utilities.assert_greater_equals(
+                expect=40, actual=gossipTime,
+                onpass="ECM anti-entropy for intents worked within " +
+                       "expected time",
+                onfail="Intent ECM anti-entropy took too long" )
+        if gossipTime <= 40:
+            intentAddResult = True
+
+        if not intentAddResult or "key" in pendingMap:
+            import time
+            installedCheck = True
+            main.log.info( "Sleeping 60 seconds to see if intents are found" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+            main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    # Iter through intents of a node
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+            # add submitted intents not in the store
+            tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+            for i in intentIds:
+                if i not in tmplist:
+                    intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # Check all nodes
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+    def CASE4( self, main ):
+        """
+        Ping across added host intents
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Verify connectivity by sendind traffic across Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Ping across added host intents to check " +\
+                                "functionality and check the state of " +\
+                                "the intent"
+        main.step( "Ping across added host intents" )
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+        main.step( "Check Intent state" )
+        installedCheck = False
+        loopCount = 0
+        while not installedCheck and loopCount < 40:
+            installedCheck = True
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            # Print states
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            if not installedCheck:
+                time.sleep( 1 )
+                loopCount += 1
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True, actual=installedCheck,
+                                 onpass="Intents are all INSTALLED",
+                                 onfail="Intents are not all in " +
+                                        "INSTALLED state" )
+
+        main.step( "Check leadership of topics" )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        topicCheck = main.TRUE
+        try:
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                # check for election
+                # TODO: Look at Devices as topics now that it uses this system
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                # FIXME: topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                # Print leaders output
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+                topicCheck = main.FALSE
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # TODO: Check for a leader of these topics
+        # Check all nodes
+        if topicCheck:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=topicCheck,
+                                 onpass="intent Partitions is in leaders",
+                                 onfail="Some topics were lost " )
+        # Print partitions
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        # Print Pending Map
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        if not installedCheck:
+            main.log.info( "Waiting 60 seconds to see if the state of " +
+                           "intents change" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+        # Print flowrules
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].flows( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.step( "Wait a minute then ping again" )
+        # the wait is above
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+    def CASE5( self, main ):
+        """
+        Reading state of ONOS
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Setting up and gathering data for current state" )
+        # The general idea for this test case is to pull the state of
+        # ( intents,flows, topology,... ) from each ONOS node
+        # We can then compare them with each other and also with past states
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        global mastershipState
+        mastershipState = '[]'
+
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Get the Mastership of each switch from each controller" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                        json.dumps(
+                            json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                            sort_keys=True,
+                            indent=4,
+                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( ONOSMastership[ i ] ) )
+        elif rolesResults and consistentMastership:
+            mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+            mastershipState = ONOSMastership[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents from each controller" )
+        global intentState
+        intentState = []
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+            main.log.error( "Intents not consistent" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+
+        if intentsResults:
+            # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+            #
+            # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+            #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            title = "   Id"
+            for n in range( numControllers ):
+                title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+            main.log.warn( title )
+            # get all intent keys in the cluster
+            keys = []
+            for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                for intent in node:
+                    keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+            keys = set( keys )
+            for key in keys:
+                row = "%-13s" % key
+                for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                    node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                    for intent in node:
+                        if intent.get( 'id', "Error" ) == key:
+                            row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+                main.log.warn( row )
+            # End table view
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            # print the json objects
+            n = len(ONOSIntents)
+            main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( n ) + " intents: " )
+            main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ -1 ] ),
+                                        sort_keys=True,
+                                        indent=4,
+                                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                if ONOSIntents[ i ] != ONOSIntents[ -1 ]:
+                    main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                    main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[i] ),
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                else:
+                    main.log.debug( nodes[ i ].name + " intents match ONOS" +
+                                    str( n ) + " intents" )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+            intentState = ONOSIntents[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the flows from each controller" )
+        global flowState
+        flowState = []
+        ONOSFlows = []
+        ONOSFlowsJson = []
+        flowCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentFlows = True
+        flowsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].flows,
+                             name="flows-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        # NOTE: Flows command can take some time to run
+        time.sleep(30)
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            result = t.result
+            ONOSFlows.append( result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            num = str( i + 1 )
+            if not ONOSFlows[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSFlows[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + num + " flows" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + num + " flows response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                flowsResults = False
+                ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+            else:
+                try:
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( json.loads( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    # FIXME: change this to log.error?
+                    main.log.exception( "Error in parsing ONOS" + num +
+                                        " response as json." )
+                    main.log.error( repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+                    flowsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=flowsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading flows output",
+            onfail="Error in reading flows from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Flows from each controller" )
+        tmp = [ len( i ) == len( ONOSFlowsJson[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSFlowsJson ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentFlows = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentFlows,
+            onpass="The flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different flow counts" )
+
+        if flowsResults and not consistentFlows:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSFlows[i] ), sort_keys=True,
+                                    indent=4, separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+        elif flowsResults and consistentFlows:
+            flowCheck = main.TRUE
+            flowState = ONOSFlows[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries" )
+        global flows
+        flows = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            flows.append( main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i ) ) )
+        if flowCheck == main.FALSE:
+            for table in flows:
+                main.log.warn( table )
+        # TODO: Compare switch flow tables with ONOS flow tables
+
+        main.step( "Start continuous pings" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source1' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target1' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source2' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target2' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source3' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target3' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source4' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target4' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source5' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target5' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source6' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target6' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source7' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target7' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source8' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target8' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source9' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target9' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source10' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target10' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        devices = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                             name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            devices.append( t.result )
+        hosts = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                             name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            try:
+                hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                # FIXME: better handling of this, print which node
+                #        Maybe use thread name?
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing json output of hosts" )
+                # FIXME: should this be an empty json object instead?
+                hosts.append( None )
+
+        ports = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                             name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ports.append( t.result )
+        links = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                             name="links-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            links.append( t.result )
+        clusters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                             name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clusters.append( t.result )
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Host view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Each host has an IP address" )
+        ipResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if not host.get( 'ipAddresses', [ ] ):
+                    main.log.error( "DEBUG:Error with host ips on controller" +
+                                    controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                    ipResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=ipResult,
+            onpass="The ips of the hosts aren't empty",
+            onfail="The ip of at least one host is missing" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Cluster view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        main.step( "Cluster view correct across ONOS nodes" )
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+        mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+        mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+        for controller in range( numControllers ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                        mnSwitches,
+                        json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                        json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is incorrect" )
+            if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                        mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                        json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is incorrect" )
+
+            if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                        mnHosts,
+                        hosts[ controller ] )
+            else:
+                currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+
+            devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+            linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+            hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correct",
+            onfail="Hosts are incorrect" )
+
+    def CASE6( self, main ):
+        """
+        The Failure case.
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        try:
+            labels
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "labels not defined, setting to []" )
+            global labels
+            labels = []
+        try:
+            data
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "data not defined, setting to []" )
+            global data
+            data = []
+        # Reset non-persistent variables
+        try:
+            iCounterValue = 0
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "iCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            iCounterValue = 0
+
+        main.case( "Restart entire ONOS cluster" )
+
+        main.step( "Killing ONOS nodes" )
+        killResults = main.TRUE
+        killTime = time.time()
+        for node in nodes:
+            killed = main.ONOSbench.onosKill( node.ip_address )
+            killResults = killResults and killed
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=killResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS nodes killed",
+                                 onfail="ONOS kill unsuccessful" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking if ONOS is up yet" )
+        for i in range( 2 ):
+            onosIsupResult = main.TRUE
+            for node in nodes:
+                started = main.ONOSbench.isup( node.ip_address )
+                if not started:
+                    main.log.error( node.name + " didn't start!" )
+                onosIsupResult = onosIsupResult and started
+            if onosIsupResult == main.TRUE:
+                break
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosIsupResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS restarted",
+                                 onfail="ONOS restart NOT successful" )
+
+        main.log.step( "Starting ONOS CLI sessions" )
+        cliResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].startOnosCli,
+                             name="startOnosCli-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[nodes[i].ip_address] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            cliResults = cliResults and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=cliResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS cli started",
+                                 onfail="ONOS clis did not restart" )
+
+        # Grab the time of restart so we chan check how long the gossip
+        # protocol has had time to work
+        main.restartTime = time.time() - killTime
+        main.log.debug( "Restart time: " + str( main.restartTime ) )
+        labels.append( "Restart" )
+        data.append( str( main.restartTime ) )
+
+        # FIXME: revisit test plan for election with madan
+        # Rerun for election on restarted nodes
+        runResults = main.TRUE
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            run = CLIs[0].electionTestRun()
+            if run != main.TRUE:
+                main.log.error( "Error running for election on " + cli.name )
+            runResults = runResults and run
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=runResults,
+                                 onpass="Reran for election",
+                                 onfail="Failed to rerun for election" )
+
+        # TODO: Make this configurable
+        time.sleep( 60 )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].nodes( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].leaders( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].partitions( jsonFormat=False ) )
+
+    def CASE7( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check state after ONOS failure
+        """
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Running ONOS Constant State Tests" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Read device roles from ONOS" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                    json.dumps(
+                        json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                        sort_keys=True,
+                        indent=4,
+                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+        elif rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+
+        '''
+        description2 = "Compare switch roles from before failure"
+        main.step( description2 )
+        try:
+            currentJson = json.loads( ONOSMastership[0] )
+            oldJson = json.loads( mastershipState )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with parsing " +
+                                "ONOSMastership[0] or mastershipState" )
+            main.log.error( "ONOSMastership[0]: " + repr( ONOSMastership[0] ) )
+            main.log.error( "mastershipState" + repr( mastershipState ) )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            switchDPID = str(
+                main.Mininet1.getSwitchDPID( switch="s" + str( i ) ) )
+            current = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in currentJson
+                        if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            old = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in oldJson
+                    if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            if current == old:
+                mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                main.log.warn( "Mastership of switch %s changed" % switchDPID )
+                mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Mastership of Switches was not changed",
+            onfail="Mastership of some switches changed" )
+        '''
+        # NOTE: we expect mastership to change on controller failure
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents and compare across all nodes" )
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+
+        # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+        #
+        # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+        #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        title = "   ID"
+        for n in range( numControllers ):
+            title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+        main.log.warn( title )
+        # get all intent keys in the cluster
+        keys = []
+        for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+            node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+            for intent in node:
+                keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+        keys = set( keys )
+        for key in keys:
+            row = "%-13s" % key
+            for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                for intent in node:
+                    if intent.get( 'id' ) == key:
+                        row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+            main.log.warn( row )
+        # End table view
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+        intentStates = []
+        for node in ONOSIntents:  # Iter through ONOS nodes
+            nodeStates = []
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( node ):
+                    nodeStates.append( intent[ 'state' ] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error in parsing intents" )
+                main.log.error( repr( node ) )
+            intentStates.append( nodeStates )
+            out = [ (i, nodeStates.count( i ) ) for i in set( nodeStates ) ]
+            main.log.info( dict( out ) )
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps(
+                    json.loads( ONOSIntents[ i ] ),
+                    sort_keys=True,
+                    indent=4,
+                    separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+
+        # NOTE: Store has no durability, so intents are lost across system
+        #       restarts
+        """
+        main.step( "Compare current intents with intents before the failure" )
+        # NOTE: this requires case 5 to pass for intentState to be set.
+        #      maybe we should stop the test if that fails?
+        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+        if intentState and intentState == ONOSIntents[ 0 ]:
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent with before failure" )
+        # TODO: possibly the states have changed? we may need to figure out
+        #       what the acceptable states are
+        elif len( intentState ) == len( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ):
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            try:
+                before = json.loads( intentState )
+                after = json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] )
+                for intent in before:
+                    if intent not in after:
+                        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+                        main.log.debug( "Intent is not currently in ONOS " +
+                                        "(at least in the same form):" )
+                        main.log.debug( json.dumps( intent ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        if sameIntents == main.FALSE:
+            try:
+                main.log.debug( "ONOS intents before: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( intentState ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                main.log.debug( "Current ONOS intents: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent with before failure",
+            onfail="The Intents changed during failure" )
+        intentCheck = intentCheck and sameIntents
+        """
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries and compare to before " +
+                   "component failure" )
+        FlowTables = main.TRUE
+        flows2 = []
+        for i in range( 28 ):
+            main.log.info( "Checking flow table on s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            tmpFlows = main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            flows2.append( tmpFlows )
+            tempResult = main.Mininet2.flowComp(
+                flow1=flows[ i ],
+                flow2=tmpFlows )
+            FlowTables = FlowTables and tempResult
+            if FlowTables == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.info( "Differences in flow table for switch: s" +
+                               str( i + 1 ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=FlowTables,
+            onpass="No changes were found in the flow tables",
+            onfail="Changes were found in the flow tables" )
+
+        main.Mininet2.pingLongKill()
+        '''
+        # main.step( "Check the continuous pings to ensure that no packets " +
+        #            "were dropped during component failure" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingKill( main.params[ 'TESTONUSER' ],
+                                main.params[ 'TESTONIP' ] )
+        LossInPings = main.FALSE
+        # NOTE: checkForLoss returns main.FALSE with 0% packet loss
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Checking for a loss in pings along flow from s" +
+                str( i ) )
+            LossInPings = main.Mininet2.checkForLoss(
+                "/tmp/ping.h" +
+                str( i ) ) or LossInPings
+        if LossInPings == main.TRUE:
+            main.log.info( "Loss in ping detected" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.ERROR:
+            main.log.info( "There are multiple mininet process running" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.info( "No Loss in the pings" )
+            main.log.info( "No loss of dataplane connectivity" )
+        # utilities.assert_equals(
+        #     expect=main.FALSE,
+        #     actual=LossInPings,
+        #     onpass="No Loss of connectivity",
+        #     onfail="Loss of dataplane connectivity detected" )
+
+        # NOTE: Since intents are not persisted with IntnentStore,
+        #       we expect loss in dataplane connectivity
+        LossInPings = main.FALSE
+        '''
+
+        main.step( "Leadership Election is still functional" )
+        # Test of LeadershipElection
+        leaderList = []
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaderList.append( leaderN )
+            if leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in response
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, check the" +
+                                 " error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN is None:
+                main.log.error( cli.name +
+                                 " shows no leader for the election-app." )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+        if len( set( leaderList ) ) != 1:
+            leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error(
+                "Inconsistent view of leader for the election test app" )
+            # TODO: print the list
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+    def CASE8( self, main ):
+        """
+        Compare topo
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Compare ONOS Topology view to Mininet topology" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Compare topology objects between Mininet" +\
+                                " and ONOS"
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        hostAttachmentResults = True
+        topoResult = main.FALSE
+        elapsed = 0
+        count = 0
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        startTime = time.time()
+        # Give time for Gossip to work
+        while topoResult == main.FALSE and elapsed < 60:
+            count += 1
+            cliStart = time.time()
+            devices = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                                 name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                devices.append( t.result )
+            hosts = []
+            ipResult = main.TRUE
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                                 name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                try:
+                    hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.exception( "Error parsing hosts results" )
+                    main.log.error( repr( t.result ) )
+            for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if host is None or host.get( 'ipAddresses', [] ) == []:
+                        main.log.error(
+                            "DEBUG:Error with host ipAddresses on controller" +
+                            controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                        ipResult = main.FALSE
+            ports = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                                 name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                ports.append( t.result )
+            links = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                                 name="links-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                links.append( t.result )
+            clusters = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                                 name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                clusters.append( t.result )
+
+            elapsed = time.time() - startTime
+            cliTime = time.time() - cliStart
+            print "Elapsed time: " + str( elapsed )
+            print "CLI time: " + str( cliTime )
+
+            mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+            mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+            mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+            for controller in range( numControllers ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                            mnSwitches,
+                            json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                            json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is incorrect" )
+
+                if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                            mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                            json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is incorrect" )
+
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                            mnHosts,
+                            hosts[ controller ] )
+                else:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+                # CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                hostAttachment = True
+                noHosts = False
+                # FIXME: topo-HA/obelisk specific mappings:
+                # key is mac and value is dpid
+                mappings = {}
+                for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # hosts 1 through 28
+                    # set up correct variables:
+                    macId = "00:" * 5 + hex( i ).split( "0x" )[1].upper().zfill(2)
+                    if i == 1:
+                        deviceId = "1000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 2:
+                        deviceId = "2000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 3:
+                        deviceId = "3000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 4:
+                        deviceId = "3004".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 5:
+                        deviceId = "5000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 6:
+                        deviceId = "6000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 7:
+                        deviceId = "6007".zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                        dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                        dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 28:
+                        deviceId = "2800".zfill(16)
+                    mappings[ macId ] = deviceId
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if hosts[ controller ] == []:
+                        main.log.warn( "There are no hosts discovered" )
+                        noHosts = True
+                    else:
+                        for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                            mac = None
+                            location = None
+                            device = None
+                            port = None
+                            try:
+                                mac = host.get( 'mac' )
+                                assert mac, "mac field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                location = host.get( 'location' )
+                                assert location, "location field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                # Trim the protocol identifier off deviceId
+                                device = str( location.get( 'elementId' ) ).split(':')[1]
+                                assert device, "elementId field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                port = location.get( 'port' )
+                                assert port, "port field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                # Now check if this matches where they should be
+                                if mac and device and port:
+                                    if str( port ) != "1":
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment port is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: 1 Actual: " + str( port) )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                    if device != mappings[ str( mac ) ]:
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment device is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: " + mappings[ str( mac ) ] +
+                                                        " Actual: " + device )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                else:
+                                    hostAttachment = False
+                            except AssertionError:
+                                main.log.exception( "Json object not as expected" )
+                                main.log.error( repr( host ) )
+                                hostAttachment = False
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "No hosts json output or \"Error\"" +
+                                    " in output. hosts = " +
+                                    repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                if noHosts is False:
+                    # TODO: Find a way to know if there should be hosts in a
+                    #       given point of the test
+                    hostAttachment = True
+
+                # END CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+                linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+                hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+                hostAttachmentResults = hostAttachmentResults and\
+                                        hostAttachment
+                topoResult = ( devicesResults and linksResults
+                               and hostsResults and ipResult and
+                               hostAttachmentResults )
+
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts information is correct" )
+        hostsResults = hostsResults and ipResult
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Host information is correct",
+            onfail="Host information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Host attachment points to the network" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=hostAttachmentResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correctly attached to the network",
+            onfail="ONOS did not correctly attach hosts to the network" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+
+        main.step( "There is only one SCC" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[0] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        topoResult = ( devicesResults and linksResults
+                       and hostsResults and consistentHostsResult
+                       and consistentClustersResult and clusterResults
+                       and ipResult and hostAttachmentResults )
+
+        topoResult = topoResult and int( count <= 2 )
+        note = "note it takes about " + str( int( cliTime ) ) + \
+            " seconds for the test to make all the cli calls to fetch " +\
+            "the topology from each ONOS instance"
+        main.log.info(
+            "Very crass estimate for topology discovery/convergence( " +
+            str( note ) + " ): " + str( elapsed ) + " seconds, " +
+            str( count ) + " tries" )
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        # FIXME: move this to an ONOS state case
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS nodes" )
+        nodesOutput = []
+        nodeResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].nodes,
+                             name="nodes-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            nodesOutput.append( t.result )
+        ips = [ node.ip_address for node in nodes ]
+        for i in nodesOutput:
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( i )
+                for node in current:
+                    currentResult = main.FALSE
+                    if node['ip'] in ips:  # node in nodes() output is in cell
+                        if node['state'] == 'ACTIVE':
+                            currentResult = main.TRUE
+                        else:
+                            main.log.error( "Error in ONOS node availability" )
+                            main.log.error(
+                                    json.dumps( current,
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                            break
+                    nodeResults = nodeResults and currentResult
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Error parsing nodes output" )
+                main.log.warn( repr( i ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=nodeResults,
+                                 onpass="Nodes check successful",
+                                 onfail="Nodes check NOT successful" )
+
+    def CASE9( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 down
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Turn off a link to ensure that Link Discovery " +\
+                      "is working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Kill Link between s3 and s28" )
+        LinkDown = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="down" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkDown,
+                                 onpass="Link down successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link down" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE10( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 up
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Restore a link to ensure that Link Discovery is " + \
+                      "working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Bring link between s3 and s28 back up" )
+        LinkUp = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="up" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkUp,
+                                 onpass="Link up successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link up" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE11( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Down
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Killing a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+
+        # TODO: Make this switch parameterizable
+        main.step( "Kill " + switch )
+        main.log.info( "Deleting " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.delSwitch( switch )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ] is False:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="Kill switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to kill switch?" )
+
+    def CASE12( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Up
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+        links = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'links' ].split()
+        description = "Adding a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Add back " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.addSwitch( switch, dpid=switchDPID )
+        for peer in links:
+            main.Mininet1.addLink( switch, peer )
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=switch, ip=ipList )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ]:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="add switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to add switch?" )
+
+    def CASE13( self, main ):
+        """
+        Clean up
+        """
+        import os
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # printing colors to terminal
+        colors = { 'cyan': '\033[96m', 'purple': '\033[95m',
+                   'blue': '\033[94m', 'green': '\033[92m',
+                   'yellow': '\033[93m', 'red': '\033[91m', 'end': '\033[0m' }
+        main.case( "Test Cleanup" )
+        main.step( "Killing tcpdumps" )
+        main.Mininet2.stopTcpdump()
+
+        testname = main.TEST
+        if main.params[ 'BACKUP' ] == "True":
+            main.step( "Copying MN pcap and ONOS log files to test station" )
+            teststationUser = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONUSER' ]
+            teststationIP = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONIP' ]
+            # NOTE: MN Pcap file is being saved to ~/packet_captures
+            #       scp this file as MN and TestON aren't necessarily the same vm
+            # FIXME: scp
+            # mn files
+            # TODO: Load these from params
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/log/"
+            logFiles = [ "karaf.log", "karaf.log.1" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+
+            # std*.log's
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/var/"
+            logFiles = [ "stderr.log", "stdout.log" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+            # sleep so scp can finish
+            time.sleep( 10 )
+            main.step( "Packing and rotating pcap archives" )
+            os.system( "~/TestON/dependencies/rotate.sh " + str( testname ) )
+
+        main.step( "Stopping Mininet" )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.stopNet()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet stopped",
+                                 onfail="MN cleanup NOT successful" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS Logs for errors" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            print colors[ 'purple' ] + "Checking logs for errors on " + \
+                node.name + ":" + colors[ 'end' ]
+            print main.ONOSbench.checkLogs( node.ip_address, restart=True )
+
+        try:
+            timerLog = open( main.logdir + "/Timers.csv", 'w')
+            main.log.error( ", ".join( labels ) + "\n" + ", ".join( data ) )
+            timerLog.write( ", ".join( labels ) + "\n" + ", ".join( data ) )
+            timerLog.close()
+        except NameError, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+    def CASE14( self, main ):
+        """
+        start election app on all onos nodes
+        """
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case("Start Leadership Election app")
+        main.step( "Install leadership election app" )
+        appResult = main.ONOScli1.activateApp( "org.onosproject.election" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=appResult,
+            onpass="Election app installed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with installing Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on each node" )
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            cli.electionTestRun()
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.error( cli.name + ": Leader for the election app " +
+                                 "should be an ONOS node, instead got '" +
+                                 str( leader ) + "'" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Successfully ran for leadership",
+            onfail="Failed to run for leadership" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+    def CASE15( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        description = "Check that Leadership Election is still functional"
+        main.case( description )
+        # NOTE: Need to re-run since being a canidate is not persistant
+        main.step( "Run for election on each node" )
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            cli.electionTestRun()
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.error( cli.name + ": Leader for the election app " +
+                                 "should be an ONOS node, instead got '" +
+                                 str( leader ) + "'" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Successfully ran for leadership",
+            onfail="Failed to run for leadership" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+        main.step( "Find current leader and withdraw" )
+        leader = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # do some sanity checking on leader before using it
+        withdrawResult = main.FALSE
+        if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Leader for the election app should be an ONOS node," +
+                "instead got '" + str( leader ) + "'" )
+            leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            oldLeader = None
+        for i in range( len( CLIs ) ):
+            if leader == nodes[ i ].ip_address:
+                oldLeader = CLIs[ i ]
+                break
+        else:  # FOR/ELSE statement
+            main.log.error( "Leader election, could not find current leader" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            withdrawResult = oldLeader.electionTestWithdraw()
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=withdrawResult,
+            onpass="Node was withdrawn from election",
+            onfail="Node was not withdrawn from election" )
+
+        main.step( "Make sure new leader is elected" )
+        # FIXME: use threads
+        leaderList = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaderList.append( leaderN )
+            if leaderN == leader:
+                main.log.error(  cli.name + " still sees " + str( leader ) +
+                                  " as leader after they withdrew" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in  response
+                # TODO: add check for "Command not found:" in the driver, this
+                #       means the app isn't loaded
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, " +
+                                 "check the error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN is None:
+                # node may not have recieved the event yet
+                time.sleep(7)
+                leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+                leaderList.pop()
+                leaderList.append( leaderN )
+        consistentLeader = main.FALSE
+        if len( set( leaderList ) ) == 1:
+            main.log.info( "Each Election-app sees '" +
+                           str( leaderList[ 0 ] ) +
+                           "' as the leader" )
+            consistentLeader = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Inconsistent responses for leader of Election-app:" )
+            for n in range( len( leaderList ) ):
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( n + 1 ) + " response: " +
+                                 str( leaderList[ n ] ) )
+        leaderResult = leaderResult and consistentLeader
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on old leader( just so everyone " +
+                   "is in the hat )" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            runResult = oldLeader.electionTestRun()
+        else:
+            runResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=runResult,
+            onpass="App re-ran for election",
+            onfail="App failed to run for election" )
+
+        main.step( "Leader did not change when old leader re-ran" )
+        afterRun = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # verify leader didn't just change
+        if afterRun == leaderList[ 0 ]:
+            afterResult = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            afterResult = main.FALSE
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=afterResult,
+            onpass="Old leader successfully re-ran for election",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election after " +
+                   "the old leader re-ran for election" )
+
+    def CASE16( self, main ):
+        """
+        Install Distributed Primitives app
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests
+        global pCounterName
+        global iCounterName
+        global pCounterValue
+        global iCounterValue
+        global onosSet
+        global onosSetName
+        pCounterName = "TestON-Partitions"
+        iCounterName = "TestON-inMemory"
+        pCounterValue = 0
+        iCounterValue = 0
+        onosSet = set([])
+        onosSetName = "TestON-set"
+
+        description = "Install Primitives app"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.step( "Install Primitives app" )
+        appName = "org.onosproject.distributedprimitives"
+        appResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( appName )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=appResults,
+                                 onpass="Primitives app activated",
+                                 onfail="Primitives app not activated" )
+        time.sleep( 5 )  # To allow all nodes to activate
+
+    def CASE17( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+        """
+        import json
+        # Make sure variables are defined/set
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert pCounterName, "pCounterName not defined"
+        assert iCounterName, "iCounterName not defined"
+        assert onosSetName, "onosSetName not defined"
+        # NOTE: assert fails if value is 0/None/Empty/False
+        try:
+            pCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "pCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            pCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            iCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "iCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            iCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            onosSet
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "onosSet not defined, setting to empty Set" )
+            onosSet = set([])
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests. These are local only
+        addValue = "a"
+        addAllValue = "a b c d e f"
+        retainValue = "c d e f"
+
+        description = "Check for basic functionality with distributed " +\
+                      "primitives"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Test the methods of the distributed primitives (counters and sets) throught the cli"
+        # DISTRIBUTED ATOMIC COUNTERS
+        main.step( "Increment and get a default counter on each node" )
+        pCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        addedPValues = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="counterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ pCounterName ] )
+            pCounterValue += 1
+            addedPValues.append( pCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            pCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        pCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedPValues:
+            tmpResult = i in pCounters
+            pCounterResults = pCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in partitioned "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=pCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="Default counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing default" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Increment and get an in memory counter on each node" )
+        iCounters = []
+        addedIValues = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="icounterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ iCounterName ],
+                             kwargs={ "inMemory": True } )
+            iCounterValue += 1
+            addedIValues.append( iCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            iCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        iCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedIValues:
+            tmpResult = i in iCounters
+            iCounterResults = iCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in the in-memory "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=iCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="In memory counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing in memory" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Check counters are consistant across nodes" )
+        onosCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counters,
+                             name="counters-" + str( i ) )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            onosCounters.append( t.result )
+        tmp = [ i == onosCounters[ 0 ] for i in onosCounters ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Counters are consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error( "Counters are not consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=consistentCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS counters are consistent " +
+                                        "across nodes",
+                                 onfail="ONOS Counters are inconsistent " +
+                                        "across nodes" )
+
+        main.step( "Counters we added have the correct values" )
+        correctResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( onosCounters[i] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Could not parse counters response from ONOS" +
+                                str( i + 1 ) )
+                main.log.warn( repr( onosCounters[ i ] ) )
+            pValue = None
+            iValue = None
+            try:
+                for database in current:
+                    partitioned = database.get( 'partitionedDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if partitioned:
+                        for value in partitioned:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == pCounterName:
+                                pValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+                    inMemory = database.get( 'inMemoryDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if inMemory:
+                        for value in inMemory:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == iCounterName:
+                                iValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+            except AttributeError, e:
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " counters result " +
+                                "is not as expected" )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if pValue == pCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "Partitioned counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Partitioned counter value is incorrect," +
+                                " expected value: " + str( pCounterValue )
+                                + " current value: " + str( pValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if iValue == iCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "In memory counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "In memory counter value is incorrect, " +
+                                "expected value: " + str( iCounterValue ) +
+                                " current value: " + str( iValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=correctResults,
+                                 onpass="Added counters are correct",
+                                 onfail="Added counters are incorrect" )
+        # DISTRIBUTED SETS
+        main.step( "Distributed Set get" )
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=getResults,
+                                 onpass="Set elements are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set elements are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set size" )
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=sizeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set sizes are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set sizes are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set add()" )
+        onosSet.add( addValue )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAdd-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+        if addResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set add" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addResults = addResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addResults,
+                                 onpass="Set add correct",
+                                 onfail="Set add was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set contains()" )
+        containsResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContains-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsResults,
+                                 onpass="Set contains is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set contains failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set containsAll()" )
+        containsAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContainsAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addAllValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsAllResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set containsAll is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set containsAll failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set remove()" )
+        onosSet.remove( addValue )
+        removeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRemove-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            removeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set remove" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeResults = removeResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set remove correct",
+                                 onfail="Set remove was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set removeAll()" )
+        onosSet.difference_update( addAllValue.split() )
+        removeAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        try:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                                 name="setTestRemoveAll-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                removeAllResponses.append( t.result )
+        except Exception, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set removeAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeAllResults = removeAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set removeAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set removeAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set clear()" )
+        onosSet.clear()
+        clearResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestClear-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, " "],  # Values doesn't matter
+                             kwargs={ "clear": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clearResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        clearResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if clearResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Nothing set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+        if clearResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set clear" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        clearResults = clearResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=clearResults,
+                                 onpass="Set clear correct",
+                                 onfail="Set clear was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set retain()" )
+        onosSet.intersection_update( retainValue.split() )
+        retainResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRetain-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, retainValue ],
+                             kwargs={ "retain": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            retainResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        retainResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if retainResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+        if retainResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set retain" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " +
+                                str( size ) + " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        retainResults = retainResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=retainResults,
+                                 onpass="Set retain correct",
+                                 onfail="Set retain was incorrect" )
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.topo b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.topo
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5f87b9d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/HAclusterRestart.topo
@@ -0,0 +1,170 @@
+<TOPOLOGY>
+    <COMPONENT>
+
+        <ONOSbench>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>1</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOSbench>
+
+        <ONOScli1>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>2</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli1>
+
+        <ONOScli2>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>3</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli2>
+
+        <ONOScli3>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>4</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli3>
+
+
+        <ONOScli4>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>5</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli4>
+
+
+        <ONOScli5>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>6</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli5>
+
+
+        <ONOScli6>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>7</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli6>
+
+
+        <ONOScli7>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>8</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli7>
+
+        <ONOS1>
+            <host>OC1</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>9</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS1>
+
+        <ONOS2>
+            <host>OC2</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>10</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS2>
+
+        <ONOS3>
+            <host>OC3</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>11</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS3>
+
+        <ONOS4>
+            <host>OC4</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>12</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS4>
+
+        <ONOS5>
+            <host>OC5</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>13</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS5>
+
+        <ONOS6>
+            <host>OC6</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>14</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS6>
+
+        <ONOS7>
+            <host>OC7</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>15</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS7>
+
+        <Mininet1>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>MininetCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>16</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+                #Specify the Option for mininet
+                <arg1> --custom ~/mininet/custom/obelisk.py </arg1>
+                <arg2> --topo obelisk </arg2>
+                <arg3> </arg3>
+                <controller> none </controller>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet1>
+
+        <Mininet2>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>RemoteMininetDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>17</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet2>
+
+    </COMPONENT>
+</TOPOLOGY>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/__init__.py b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/__init__.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..e69de29
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/__init__.py
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py
new file mode 100755
index 0000000..fb6ccdb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAclusterRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py
@@ -0,0 +1,70 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python
+
+from mininet.topo import Topo
+
+class ObeliskTopo( Topo ):
+    def __init__( self ):
+        Topo.__init__( self )
+        topSwitch = self.addSwitch('s1',dpid='1000'.zfill(16))
+        leftTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s2',dpid='2000'.zfill(16))
+        rightTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s5',dpid='5000'.zfill(16))
+        leftBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s3',dpid='3000'.zfill(16))
+        rightBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s6',dpid='6000'.zfill(16))	
+        midBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s28',dpid='2800'.zfill(16))
+        
+        topHost = self.addHost( 'h1' )
+        leftTopHost = self.addHost('h2')
+        rightTopHost = self.addHost('h5')
+        leftBotHost = self.addHost('h3')
+        rightBotHost = self.addHost('h6')
+        midBotHost = self.addHost('h28')
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,topHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftTopHost)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightTopHost)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,leftBotHost)
+        self.addLink(rightBotSwitch,rightBotHost)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,midBotHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,leftTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,midBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+
+        agg1Switch = self.addSwitch('s4',dpid = '3004'.zfill(16))
+        agg2Switch = self.addSwitch('s7',dpid = '6007'.zfill(16))
+        agg1Host = self.addHost('h4')
+        agg2Host = self.addHost('h7')
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch,agg1Host)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch,agg2Host)
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch, leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch, rightBotSwitch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+8)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('30'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg1Switch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+18)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('60'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg2Switch)
+
+topos = { 'obelisk': (lambda: ObeliskTopo() ) }
+
+def run():
+    topo = ObeliskTopo()
+    net = Mininet( topo=topo, controller=RemoteController, autoSetMacs=True )
+    net.start()
+    CLI( net )
+    net.stop()
+
+if __name__ == '__main__':
+    setLogLevel( 'info' )
+    run()
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.params b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.params
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..f983129
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.params
@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
+<PARAMS>
+    <testcases>1,2,8,3,4,5,14,16,17,[6],8,7,4,15,17,9,8,4,10,8,4,11,8,4,12,8,4,13</testcases>
+    <ENV>
+        <cellName>HA</cellName>
+        <appString>drivers,openflow,proxyarp,mobility</appString>
+    </ENV>
+    <Git> False </Git>
+    <branch> master </branch>
+    <num_controllers> 7 </num_controllers>
+    <tcpdump> False </tcpdump>
+
+    <CTRL>
+        <port1>6633</port1>
+        <port2>6633</port2>
+        <port3>6633</port3>
+        <port4>6633</port4>
+        <port5>6633</port5>
+        <port6>6633</port6>
+        <port7>6633</port7>
+    </CTRL>
+    <BACKUP>
+        <ENABLED> False </ENABLED>
+        <TESTONUSER>admin</TESTONUSER>
+        <TESTONIP>10.128.30.9</TESTONIP>
+    </BACKUP>
+    <PING>
+        <source1>h8</source1>
+        <source2>h9</source2>
+        <source3>h10</source3>
+        <source4>h11</source4>
+        <source5>h12</source5>
+        <source6>h13</source6>
+        <source7>h14</source7>
+        <source8>h15</source8>
+        <source9>h16</source9>
+        <source10>h17</source10>
+        <target1>10.0.0.18</target1>
+        <target2>10.0.0.19</target2>
+        <target3>10.0.0.20</target3>
+        <target4>10.0.0.21</target4>
+        <target5>10.0.0.22</target5>
+        <target6>10.0.0.23</target6>
+        <target7>10.0.0.24</target7>
+        <target8>10.0.0.25</target8>
+        <target9>10.0.0.26</target9>
+        <target10>10.0.0.27</target10>
+    </PING>
+    <timers>
+        <LinkDiscovery>.2</LinkDiscovery>
+        <SwitchDiscovery>.2</SwitchDiscovery>
+    </timers>
+    <kill>
+        <switch> s5 </switch>
+        <dpid> 0000000000005000 </dpid>
+        <links> h5 s2 s1 s6 </links>
+    </kill>
+    <MNtcpdump>
+        <intf>eth0</intf>
+        <port> </port>
+        <folder>~/packet_captures/</folder>
+    </MNtcpdump>
+</PARAMS>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.py b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..a7f7303
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.py
@@ -0,0 +1,3967 @@
+"""
+Description: This test is to determine if ONOS can handle
+    a minority of it's nodes restarting
+
+List of test cases:
+CASE1: Compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+CASE2: Assign devices to controllers
+CASE21: Assign mastership to controllers
+CASE3: Assign intents
+CASE4: Ping across added host intents
+CASE5: Reading state of ONOS
+CASE6: The Failure case.
+CASE7: Check state after control plane failure
+CASE8: Compare topo
+CASE9: Link s3-s28 down
+CASE10: Link s3-s28 up
+CASE11: Switch down
+CASE12: Switch up
+CASE13: Clean up
+CASE14: start election app on all onos nodes
+CASE15: Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+CASE16: Install Distributed Primitives app
+CASE17: Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+"""
+
+
+class HAminorityRestart:
+
+    def __init__( self ):
+        self.default = ''
+
+    def CASE1( self, main ):
+        """
+        CASE1 is to compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+
+        Startup sequence:
+        cell <name>
+        onos-verify-cell
+        NOTE: temporary - onos-remove-raft-logs
+        onos-uninstall
+        start mininet
+        git pull
+        mvn clean install
+        onos-package
+        onos-install -f
+        onos-wait-for-start
+        start cli sessions
+        start tcpdump
+        """
+        main.log.info( "ONOS HA test: Restart minority of ONOS nodes - " +
+                         "initialization" )
+        main.case( "Setting up test environment" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Setup the test environment including " +\
+                                "installing ONOS, starting Mininet and ONOS" +\
+                                "cli sessions."
+        # TODO: save all the timers and output them for plotting
+
+        # load some variables from the params file
+        PULLCODE = False
+        if main.params[ 'Git' ] == 'True':
+            PULLCODE = True
+        gitBranch = main.params[ 'branch' ]
+        cellName = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'cellName' ]
+
+        # set global variables
+        global numControllers
+        numControllers = int( main.params[ 'num_controllers' ] )
+        if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes:
+            if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes < numControllers:
+                numControllers = int( main.ONOSbench.maxNodes )
+        global ONOS1Port
+        global ONOS2Port
+        global ONOS3Port
+        global ONOS4Port
+        global ONOS5Port
+        global ONOS6Port
+        global ONOS7Port
+
+        # FIXME: just get controller port from params?
+        # TODO: do we really need all these?
+        ONOS1Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port1' ]
+        ONOS2Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port2' ]
+        ONOS3Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port3' ]
+        ONOS4Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port4' ]
+        ONOS5Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port5' ]
+        ONOS6Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port6' ]
+        ONOS7Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port7' ]
+
+        global CLIs
+        CLIs = []
+        global nodes
+        nodes = []
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( 1, numControllers + 1 ):
+            CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
+            nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+            ipList.append( nodes[ -1 ].ip_address )
+
+        main.step( "Create cell file" )
+        cellAppString = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'appString' ]
+        main.ONOSbench.createCellFile( main.ONOSbench.ip_address, cellName,
+                                       main.Mininet1.ip_address,
+                                       cellAppString, ipList )
+        main.step( "Applying cell variable to environment" )
+        cellResult = main.ONOSbench.setCell( cellName )
+        verifyResult = main.ONOSbench.verifyCell()
+
+        # FIXME:this is short term fix
+        main.log.info( "Removing raft logs" )
+        main.ONOSbench.onosRemoveRaftLogs()
+
+        main.log.info( "Uninstalling ONOS" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            main.ONOSbench.onosUninstall( node.ip_address )
+
+        # Make sure ONOS is DEAD
+        main.log.info( "Killing any ONOS processes" )
+        killResults = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            killed = main.ONOSbench.onosKill( node.ip_address )
+            killResults = killResults and killed
+
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        gitPullResult = main.TRUE
+
+        main.step( "Starting Mininet" )
+        # scp topo file to mininet
+        # TODO: move to params?
+        topoName = "obelisk.py"
+        filePath = main.ONOSbench.home + "/tools/test/topos/"
+        main.ONOSbench.copyMininetFile( topoName, filePath,
+                                        main.Mininet1.user_name,
+                                        main.Mininet1.ip_address )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.startNet( )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet Started",
+                                 onfail="Error starting Mininet" )
+
+        main.step( "Git checkout and pull " + gitBranch )
+        if PULLCODE:
+            main.ONOSbench.gitCheckout( gitBranch )
+            gitPullResult = main.ONOSbench.gitPull()
+            # values of 1 or 3 are good
+            utilities.assert_lesser( expect=0, actual=gitPullResult,
+                                      onpass="Git pull successful",
+                                      onfail="Git pull failed" )
+        main.ONOSbench.getVersion( report=True )
+
+        main.step( "Using mvn clean install" )
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        if PULLCODE and gitPullResult == main.TRUE:
+            cleanInstallResult = main.ONOSbench.cleanInstall()
+        else:
+            main.log.warn( "Did not pull new code so skipping mvn " +
+                           "clean install" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=cleanInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="MCI successful",
+                                 onfail="MCI failed" )
+        # GRAPHS
+        # NOTE: important params here:
+        #       job = name of Jenkins job
+        #       Plot Name = Plot-HA, only can be used if multiple plots
+        #       index = The number of the graph under plot name
+        job = "HAminorityRestart"
+        plotName = "Plot-HA"
+        graphs = '<ac:structured-macro ac:name="html">\n'
+        graphs += '<ac:plain-text-body><![CDATA[\n'
+        graphs += '<iframe src="https://onos-jenkins.onlab.us/job/' + job +\
+                  '/plot/' + plotName + '/getPlot?index=0' +\
+                  '&width=500&height=300"' +\
+                  'noborder="0" width="500" height="300" scrolling="yes" ' +\
+                  'seamless="seamless"></iframe>\n'
+        graphs += ']]></ac:plain-text-body>\n'
+        graphs += '</ac:structured-macro>\n'
+        main.log.wiki(graphs)
+
+        main.step( "Creating ONOS package" )
+        packageResult = main.ONOSbench.onosPackage()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=packageResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS package successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS package failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Installing ONOS package" )
+        onosInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            tmpResult = main.ONOSbench.onosInstall( options="-f",
+                                                    node=node.ip_address )
+            onosInstallResult = onosInstallResult and tmpResult
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS install successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS install failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking if ONOS is up yet" )
+        for i in range( 2 ):
+            onosIsupResult = main.TRUE
+            for node in nodes:
+                started = main.ONOSbench.isup( node.ip_address )
+                if not started:
+                    main.log.error( node.name + " didn't start!" )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStop( node.ip_address )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStart( node.ip_address )
+                onosIsupResult = onosIsupResult and started
+            if onosIsupResult == main.TRUE:
+                break
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosIsupResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS startup failed" )
+
+        main.log.step( "Starting ONOS CLI sessions" )
+        cliResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].startOnosCli,
+                             name="startOnosCli-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[nodes[i].ip_address] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            cliResults = cliResults and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=cliResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS cli startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS cli startup failed" )
+
+        if main.params[ 'tcpdump' ].lower() == "true":
+            main.step( "Start Packet Capture MN" )
+            main.Mininet2.startTcpdump(
+                str( main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'folder' ] ) + str( main.TEST )
+                + "-MN.pcap",
+                intf=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'intf' ],
+                port=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'port' ] )
+
+        main.step( "App Ids check" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        if cliResults == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error( "Failed to start ONOS, stopping test" )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+
+    def CASE2( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign devices to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning devices to controllers" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Assign switches to ONOS using 'ovs-vsctl' " +\
+                                "and check that an ONOS node becomes the " +\
+                                "master of the device."
+        main.step( "Assign switches to controllers" )
+
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        swList = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            swList.append( "s" + str( i ) )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=swList, ip=ipList )
+
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            response = main.Mininet1.getSwController( "s" + str( i ) )
+            try:
+                main.log.info( str( response ) )
+            except Exception:
+                main.log.info( repr( response ) )
+            for node in nodes:
+                if re.search( "tcp:" + node.ip_address, response ):
+                    mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "Error, node " + node.ip_address + " is " +
+                                    "not in the list of controllers s" +
+                                    str( i ) + " is connecting to." )
+                    mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Switch mastership assigned correctly",
+            onfail="Switches not assigned correctly to controllers" )
+
+    def CASE21( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign mastership to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning Controller roles for switches" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Check that ONOS is connected to each " +\
+                                "device. Then manually assign" +\
+                                " mastership to specific ONOS nodes using" +\
+                                " 'device-role'"
+        main.step( "Assign mastership of switches to specific controllers" )
+        # Manually assign mastership to the controller we want
+        roleCall = main.TRUE
+
+        ipList = [ ]
+        deviceList = []
+        try:
+            # Assign mastership to specific controllers. This assignment was
+            # determined for a 7 node cluser, but will work with any sized
+            # cluster
+            for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # switches 1 through 28
+                # set up correct variables:
+                if i == 1:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "1000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 2:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 3:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 4:
+                    c = 3 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS4
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3004" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 5:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "5000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 6:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 7:
+                    c = 5 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS6
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6007" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                    c = 4 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS5
+                    dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                    c = 6 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS7
+                    dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 28:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2800" ).get( 'id' )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "You didn't write an else statement for " +
+                                    "switch s" + str( i ) )
+                    roleCall = main.FALSE
+                # Assign switch
+                assert deviceId, "No device id for s" + str( i ) + " in ONOS"
+                # TODO: make this controller dynamic
+                roleCall = roleCall and main.ONOScli1.deviceRole( deviceId,
+                                                                  ip )
+                ipList.append( ip )
+                deviceList.append( deviceId )
+        except ( AttributeError, AssertionError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with ONOS device view" )
+            main.log.info( main.ONOScli1.devices() )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCall,
+            onpass="Re-assigned switch mastership to designated controller",
+            onfail="Something wrong with deviceRole calls" )
+
+        main.step( "Check mastership was correctly assigned" )
+        roleCheck = main.TRUE
+        # NOTE: This is due to the fact that device mastership change is not
+        #       atomic and is actually a multi step process
+        time.sleep( 5 )
+        for i in range( len( ipList ) ):
+            ip = ipList[i]
+            deviceId = deviceList[i]
+            # Check assignment
+            master = main.ONOScli1.getRole( deviceId ).get( 'master' )
+            if ip in master:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "Error, controller " + ip + " is not" +
+                                " master " + "of device " +
+                                str( deviceId ) + ". Master is " +
+                                repr( master ) + "." )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCheck,
+            onpass="Switches were successfully reassigned to designated " +
+                   "controller",
+            onfail="Switches were not successfully reassigned" )
+
+    def CASE3( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign intents
+        """
+        import time
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Adding host Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Discover hosts by using pingall then " +\
+                                "assign predetermined host-to-host intents." +\
+                                " After installation, check that the intent" +\
+                                " is distributed to all nodes and the state" +\
+                                " is INSTALLED"
+
+        # install onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Install reactive forwarding app" )
+        installResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=installResults,
+                                 onpass="Install fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Install fwd failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Discovering Hosts( Via pingall for now )" )
+        # FIXME: Once we have a host discovery mechanism, use that instead
+        # REACTIVE FWD test
+        pingResult = main.FALSE
+        for i in range(2):  # Retry if pingall fails first time
+            time1 = time.time()
+            pingResult = main.Mininet1.pingall()
+            if i == 0:
+                utilities.assert_equals(
+                    expect=main.TRUE,
+                    actual=pingResult,
+                    onpass="Reactive Pingall test passed",
+                    onfail="Reactive Pingall failed, " +
+                           "one or more ping pairs failed" )
+            time2 = time.time()
+            main.log.info( "Time for pingall: %2f seconds" %
+                           ( time2 - time1 ) )
+        # timeout for fwd flows
+        time.sleep( 11 )
+        # uninstall onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Uninstall reactive forwarding app" )
+        uninstallResult = CLIs[0].deactivateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=uninstallResult,
+                                 onpass="Uninstall fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Uninstall fwd failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        threads = []
+        appCheck2 = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck2 = appCheck2 and t.result
+        if appCheck2 != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck2,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Add host intents via cli" )
+        intentIds = []
+        # TODO:  move the host numbers to params
+        #        Maybe look at all the paths we ping?
+        intentAddResult = True
+        hostResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info( "Adding host intent between h" + str( i ) +
+                           " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            host1 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            host2 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i + 10 )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            # NOTE: getHost can return None
+            host1Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host1 )
+            host2Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host2 )
+            host1Id = None
+            host2Id = None
+            if host1Dict and host2Dict:
+                host1Id = host1Dict.get( 'id', None )
+                host2Id = host2Dict.get( 'id', None )
+            if host1Id and host2Id:
+                nodeNum = ( i % numControllers )
+                tmpId = CLIs[ nodeNum ].addHostIntent( host1Id, host2Id )
+                if tmpId:
+                    main.log.info( "Added intent with id: " + tmpId )
+                    intentIds.append( tmpId )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "addHostIntent returned: " +
+                                     repr( tmpId ) )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error, getHost() failed for h" + str( i ) +
+                                " and/or h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+                hosts = CLIs[ 0 ].hosts()
+                main.log.warn( "Hosts output: " )
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( hosts ),
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts ) )
+                hostResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=hostResult,
+                                 onpass="Found a host id for each host",
+                                 onfail="Error looking up host ids" )
+
+        intentStart = time.time()
+        onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+        main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+        main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+        for intent in intentIds:
+            if intent in onosIds:
+                pass  # intent submitted is in onos
+            else:
+                intentAddResult = False
+        if intentAddResult:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        else:
+            intentStop = None
+        # Print the intent states
+        intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+        intentStates = []
+        installedCheck = True
+        main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+        count = 0
+        try:
+            for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                    installedCheck = False
+                intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+        # add submitted intents not in the store
+        tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+        missingIntents = False
+        for i in intentIds:
+            if i not in tmplist:
+                intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+                missingIntents = True
+        intentStates.sort()
+        for i, s in intentStates:
+            count += 1
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                           ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        try:
+            missing = False
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        missing = True
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+        # Check all nodes
+        if missing:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        intentAddResult = bool( intentAddResult and not missingIntents and
+                                installedCheck )
+        if not intentAddResult:
+            main.log.error( "Error in pushing host intents to ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Intent Anti-Entropy dispersion" )
+        for i in range(100):
+            correct = True
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( sorted( intentIds ) ) )
+            for cli in CLIs:
+                onosIds = []
+                ids = cli.getAllIntentsId()
+                onosIds.append( ids )
+                main.log.debug( "Intents in " + cli.name + ": " +
+                                str( sorted( onosIds ) ) )
+                if sorted( ids ) != sorted( intentIds ):
+                    main.log.warn( "Set of intent IDs doesn't match" )
+                    correct = False
+                    break
+                else:
+                    intents = json.loads( cli.intents() )
+                    for intent in intents:
+                        if intent[ 'state' ] != "INSTALLED":
+                            main.log.warn( "Intent " + intent[ 'id' ] +
+                                           " is " + intent[ 'state' ] )
+                            correct = False
+                            break
+            if correct:
+                break
+            else:
+                time.sleep(1)
+        if not intentStop:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        global gossipTime
+        gossipTime = intentStop - intentStart
+        main.log.info( "It took about " + str( gossipTime ) +
+                        " seconds for all intents to appear in each node" )
+        # FIXME: make this time configurable/calculate based off of number of
+        #        nodes and gossip rounds
+        utilities.assert_greater_equals(
+                expect=40, actual=gossipTime,
+                onpass="ECM anti-entropy for intents worked within " +
+                       "expected time",
+                onfail="Intent ECM anti-entropy took too long" )
+        if gossipTime <= 40:
+            intentAddResult = True
+
+        if not intentAddResult or "key" in pendingMap:
+            import time
+            installedCheck = True
+            main.log.info( "Sleeping 60 seconds to see if intents are found" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+            main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    # Iter through intents of a node
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+            # add submitted intents not in the store
+            tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+            for i in intentIds:
+                if i not in tmplist:
+                    intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # Check all nodes
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+    def CASE4( self, main ):
+        """
+        Ping across added host intents
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Verify connectivity by sendind traffic across Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Ping across added host intents to check " +\
+                                "functionality and check the state of " +\
+                                "the intent"
+        main.step( "Ping across added host intents" )
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+        main.step( "Check Intent state" )
+        installedCheck = False
+        loopCount = 0
+        while not installedCheck and loopCount < 40:
+            installedCheck = True
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            # Print states
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            if not installedCheck:
+                time.sleep( 1 )
+                loopCount += 1
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True, actual=installedCheck,
+                                 onpass="Intents are all INSTALLED",
+                                 onfail="Intents are not all in " +
+                                        "INSTALLED state" )
+
+        main.step( "Check leadership of topics" )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        topicCheck = main.TRUE
+        try:
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                # check for election
+                # TODO: Look at Devices as topics now that it uses this system
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                # FIXME: topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                # Print leaders output
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+                topicCheck = main.FALSE
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # TODO: Check for a leader of these topics
+        # Check all nodes
+        if topicCheck:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=topicCheck,
+                                 onpass="intent Partitions is in leaders",
+                                 onfail="Some topics were lost " )
+        # Print partitions
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        # Print Pending Map
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        if not installedCheck:
+            main.log.info( "Waiting 60 seconds to see if the state of " +
+                           "intents change" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+        # Print flowrules
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].flows( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.step( "Wait a minute then ping again" )
+        # the wait is above
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+    def CASE5( self, main ):
+        """
+        Reading state of ONOS
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Setting up and gathering data for current state" )
+        # The general idea for this test case is to pull the state of
+        # ( intents,flows, topology,... ) from each ONOS node
+        # We can then compare them with each other and also with past states
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        global mastershipState
+        mastershipState = '[]'
+
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Get the Mastership of each switch from each controller" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                        json.dumps(
+                            json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                            sort_keys=True,
+                            indent=4,
+                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( ONOSMastership[ i ] ) )
+        elif rolesResults and consistentMastership:
+            mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+            mastershipState = ONOSMastership[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents from each controller" )
+        global intentState
+        intentState = []
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+            main.log.error( "Intents not consistent" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+
+        if intentsResults:
+            # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+            #
+            # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+            #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            title = "   Id"
+            for n in range( numControllers ):
+                title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+            main.log.warn( title )
+            # get all intent keys in the cluster
+            keys = []
+            for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                for intent in node:
+                    keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+            keys = set( keys )
+            for key in keys:
+                row = "%-13s" % key
+                for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                    node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                    for intent in node:
+                        if intent.get( 'id', "Error" ) == key:
+                            row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+                main.log.warn( row )
+            # End table view
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            # print the json objects
+            n = len(ONOSIntents)
+            main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( n ) + " intents: " )
+            main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ -1 ] ),
+                                        sort_keys=True,
+                                        indent=4,
+                                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                if ONOSIntents[ i ] != ONOSIntents[ -1 ]:
+                    main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                    main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[i] ),
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                else:
+                    main.log.debug( nodes[ i ].name + " intents match ONOS" +
+                                    str( n ) + " intents" )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+            intentState = ONOSIntents[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the flows from each controller" )
+        global flowState
+        flowState = []
+        ONOSFlows = []
+        ONOSFlowsJson = []
+        flowCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentFlows = True
+        flowsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].flows,
+                             name="flows-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        # NOTE: Flows command can take some time to run
+        time.sleep(30)
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            result = t.result
+            ONOSFlows.append( result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            num = str( i + 1 )
+            if not ONOSFlows[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSFlows[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + num + " flows" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + num + " flows response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                flowsResults = False
+                ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+            else:
+                try:
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( json.loads( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    # FIXME: change this to log.error?
+                    main.log.exception( "Error in parsing ONOS" + num +
+                                        " response as json." )
+                    main.log.error( repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+                    flowsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=flowsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading flows output",
+            onfail="Error in reading flows from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Flows from each controller" )
+        tmp = [ len( i ) == len( ONOSFlowsJson[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSFlowsJson ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentFlows = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentFlows,
+            onpass="The flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different flow counts" )
+
+        if flowsResults and not consistentFlows:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSFlows[i] ), sort_keys=True,
+                                    indent=4, separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+        elif flowsResults and consistentFlows:
+            flowCheck = main.TRUE
+            flowState = ONOSFlows[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries" )
+        global flows
+        flows = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            flows.append( main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i ) ) )
+        if flowCheck == main.FALSE:
+            for table in flows:
+                main.log.warn( table )
+        # TODO: Compare switch flow tables with ONOS flow tables
+
+        main.step( "Start continuous pings" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source1' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target1' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source2' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target2' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source3' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target3' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source4' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target4' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source5' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target5' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source6' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target6' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source7' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target7' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source8' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target8' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source9' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target9' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source10' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target10' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        devices = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                             name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            devices.append( t.result )
+        hosts = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                             name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            try:
+                hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                # FIXME: better handling of this, print which node
+                #        Maybe use thread name?
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing json output of hosts" )
+                # FIXME: should this be an empty json object instead?
+                hosts.append( None )
+
+        ports = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                             name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ports.append( t.result )
+        links = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                             name="links-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            links.append( t.result )
+        clusters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                             name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clusters.append( t.result )
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Host view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Each host has an IP address" )
+        ipResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if not host.get( 'ipAddresses', [ ] ):
+                    main.log.error( "DEBUG:Error with host ips on controller" +
+                                    controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                    ipResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=ipResult,
+            onpass="The ips of the hosts aren't empty",
+            onfail="The ip of at least one host is missing" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Cluster view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        main.step( "Cluster view correct across ONOS nodes" )
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+        mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+        mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+        for controller in range( numControllers ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                        mnSwitches,
+                        json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                        json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is incorrect" )
+            if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                        mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                        json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is incorrect" )
+
+            if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                        mnHosts,
+                        hosts[ controller ] )
+            else:
+                currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+
+            devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+            linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+            hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correct",
+            onfail="Hosts are incorrect" )
+
+    def CASE6( self, main ):
+        """
+        The Failure case.
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Restart minority of ONOS nodes" )
+        main.step( "Killing 3 ONOS nodes" )
+        killTime = time.time()
+        # TODO: Randomize these nodes or base this on partitions
+        # TODO: use threads in this case
+        killResults = main.ONOSbench.onosKill( nodes[0].ip_address )
+        time.sleep( 10 )
+        killResults = killResults and\
+                      main.ONOSbench.onosKill( nodes[1].ip_address )
+        time.sleep( 10 )
+        killResults = killResults and\
+                      main.ONOSbench.onosKill( nodes[2].ip_address )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=killResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS Killed successfully",
+                                 onfail="ONOS kill NOT successful" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking if ONOS is up yet" )
+        count = 0
+        onosIsupResult = main.FALSE
+        while onosIsupResult == main.FALSE and count < 10:
+            onos1Isup = main.ONOSbench.isup( nodes[0].ip_address )
+            onos2Isup = main.ONOSbench.isup( nodes[1].ip_address )
+            onos3Isup = main.ONOSbench.isup( nodes[2].ip_address )
+            onosIsupResult = onos1Isup and onos2Isup and onos3Isup
+            count = count + 1
+        # TODO: if it becomes an issue, we can retry this step  a few times
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosIsupResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS restarted successfully",
+                                 onfail="ONOS restart NOT successful" )
+
+        main.step( "Restarting ONOS CLIs" )
+        cliResult1 = main.ONOScli1.startOnosCli( nodes[0].ip_address )
+        cliResult2 = main.ONOScli2.startOnosCli( nodes[1].ip_address )
+        cliResult3 = main.ONOScli3.startOnosCli( nodes[2].ip_address )
+        cliResults = cliResult1 and cliResult2 and cliResult3
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=cliResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS cli restarted",
+                                 onfail="ONOS cli did not restart" )
+
+        # Grab the time of restart so we chan check how long the gossip
+        # protocol has had time to work
+        main.restartTime = time.time() - killTime
+        main.log.debug( "Restart time: " + str( main.restartTime ) )
+        '''
+        # FIXME: revisit test plan for election with madan
+        # Rerun for election on restarted nodes
+        run1 = CLIs[0].electionTestRun()
+        run2 = CLIs[1].electionTestRun()
+        run3 = CLIs[2].electionTestRun()
+        runResults = run1 and run2 and run3
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=runResults,
+                                 onpass="Reran for election",
+                                 onfail="Failed to rerun for election" )
+        '''
+        # TODO: MAke this configurable. Also, we are breaking the above timer
+        time.sleep( 60 )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].nodes( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].leaders( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].partitions( jsonFormat=False ) )
+
+    def CASE7( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check state after ONOS failure
+        """
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Running ONOS Constant State Tests" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Read device roles from ONOS" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                    json.dumps(
+                        json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                        sort_keys=True,
+                        indent=4,
+                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+
+        # NOTE: we expect mastership to change on controller failure
+        '''
+        description2 = "Compare switch roles from before failure"
+        main.step( description2 )
+        try:
+            currentJson = json.loads( ONOSMastership[0] )
+            oldJson = json.loads( mastershipState )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with parsing " +
+                                "ONOSMastership[0] or mastershipState" )
+            main.log.error( "ONOSMastership[0]: " + repr( ONOSMastership[0] ) )
+            main.log.error( "mastershipState" + repr( mastershipState ) )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            switchDPID = str(
+                main.Mininet1.getSwitchDPID( switch="s" + str( i ) ) )
+            current = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in currentJson
+                        if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            old = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in oldJson
+                    if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            if current == old:
+                mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                main.log.warn( "Mastership of switch %s changed" % switchDPID )
+                mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Mastership of Switches was not changed",
+            onfail="Mastership of some switches changed" )
+        '''
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents and compare across all nodes" )
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+
+        # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+        #
+        # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+        #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        title = "   ID"
+        for n in range( numControllers ):
+            title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+        main.log.warn( title )
+        # get all intent keys in the cluster
+        keys = []
+        for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+            node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+            for intent in node:
+                keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+        keys = set( keys )
+        for key in keys:
+            row = "%-13s" % key
+            for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                for intent in node:
+                    if intent.get( 'id' ) == key:
+                        row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+            main.log.warn( row )
+        # End table view
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+        intentStates = []
+        for node in ONOSIntents:  # Iter through ONOS nodes
+            nodeStates = []
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( node ):
+                    nodeStates.append( intent[ 'state' ] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error in parsing intents" )
+                main.log.error( repr( node ) )
+            intentStates.append( nodeStates )
+            out = [ (i, nodeStates.count( i ) ) for i in set( nodeStates ) ]
+            main.log.info( dict( out ) )
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps(
+                    json.loads( ONOSIntents[ i ] ),
+                    sort_keys=True,
+                    indent=4,
+                    separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+
+        # NOTE: Store has no durability, so intents are lost across system
+        #       restarts
+        main.step( "Compare current intents with intents before the failure" )
+        # NOTE: this requires case 5 to pass for intentState to be set.
+        #      maybe we should stop the test if that fails?
+        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+        if intentState and intentState == ONOSIntents[ 0 ]:
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent with before failure" )
+        # TODO: possibly the states have changed? we may need to figure out
+        #       what the acceptable states are
+        elif len( intentState ) == len( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ):
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            try:
+                before = json.loads( intentState )
+                after = json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] )
+                for intent in before:
+                    if intent not in after:
+                        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+                        main.log.debug( "Intent is not currently in ONOS " +
+                                        "(at least in the same form):" )
+                        main.log.debug( json.dumps( intent ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        if sameIntents == main.FALSE:
+            try:
+                main.log.debug( "ONOS intents before: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( intentState ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                main.log.debug( "Current ONOS intents: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent with before failure",
+            onfail="The Intents changed during failure" )
+        intentCheck = intentCheck and sameIntents
+
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries and compare to before " +
+                   "component failure" )
+        FlowTables = main.TRUE
+        flows2 = []
+        for i in range( 28 ):
+            main.log.info( "Checking flow table on s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            tmpFlows = main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            flows2.append( tmpFlows )
+            tempResult = main.Mininet2.flowComp(
+                flow1=flows[ i ],
+                flow2=tmpFlows )
+            FlowTables = FlowTables and tempResult
+            if FlowTables == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.info( "Differences in flow table for switch: s" +
+                               str( i + 1 ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=FlowTables,
+            onpass="No changes were found in the flow tables",
+            onfail="Changes were found in the flow tables" )
+
+        main.Mininet2.pingLongKill()
+        '''
+        main.step( "Check the continuous pings to ensure that no packets " +
+                   "were dropped during component failure" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingKill( main.params[ 'TESTONUSER' ],
+                                main.params[ 'TESTONIP' ] )
+        LossInPings = main.FALSE
+        # NOTE: checkForLoss returns main.FALSE with 0% packet loss
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Checking for a loss in pings along flow from s" +
+                str( i ) )
+            LossInPings = main.Mininet2.checkForLoss(
+                "/tmp/ping.h" +
+                str( i ) ) or LossInPings
+        if LossInPings == main.TRUE:
+            main.log.info( "Loss in ping detected" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.ERROR:
+            main.log.info( "There are multiple mininet process running" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.info( "No Loss in the pings" )
+            main.log.info( "No loss of dataplane connectivity" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.FALSE,
+            actual=LossInPings,
+            onpass="No Loss of connectivity",
+            onfail="Loss of dataplane connectivity detected" )
+        '''
+
+        main.step( "Leadership Election is still functional" )
+        # Test of LeadershipElection
+        leaderList = []
+        # FIXME: make sure this matches nodes that were restarted
+        restarted = [ nodes[0].ip_address, nodes[1].ip_address,
+                      nodes[2].ip_address ]
+
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaderList.append( leaderN )
+            if leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in response
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, check the" +
+                                 " error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN is None:
+                main.log.error( cli.name +
+                                 " shows no leader for the election-app was" +
+                                 " elected after the old one died" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN in restarted:
+                main.log.error( cli.name + " shows " + str( leaderN ) +
+                                 " as leader for the election-app, but it " +
+                                 "was restarted" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+        if len( set( leaderList ) ) != 1:
+            leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error(
+                "Inconsistent view of leader for the election test app" )
+            # TODO: print the list
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+    def CASE8( self, main ):
+        """
+        Compare topo
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Compare ONOS Topology view to Mininet topology" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Compare topology objects between Mininet" +\
+                                " and ONOS"
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        hostAttachmentResults = True
+        topoResult = main.FALSE
+        elapsed = 0
+        count = 0
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        startTime = time.time()
+        # Give time for Gossip to work
+        while topoResult == main.FALSE and elapsed < 60:
+            count += 1
+            cliStart = time.time()
+            devices = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                                 name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                devices.append( t.result )
+            hosts = []
+            ipResult = main.TRUE
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                                 name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                try:
+                    hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.exception( "Error parsing hosts results" )
+                    main.log.error( repr( t.result ) )
+            for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if host is None or host.get( 'ipAddresses', [] ) == []:
+                        main.log.error(
+                            "DEBUG:Error with host ipAddresses on controller" +
+                            controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                        ipResult = main.FALSE
+            ports = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                                 name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                ports.append( t.result )
+            links = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                                 name="links-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                links.append( t.result )
+            clusters = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                                 name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                clusters.append( t.result )
+
+            elapsed = time.time() - startTime
+            cliTime = time.time() - cliStart
+            print "Elapsed time: " + str( elapsed )
+            print "CLI time: " + str( cliTime )
+
+            mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+            mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+            mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+            for controller in range( numControllers ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                            mnSwitches,
+                            json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                            json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is incorrect" )
+
+                if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                            mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                            json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is incorrect" )
+
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                            mnHosts,
+                            hosts[ controller ] )
+                else:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+                # CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                hostAttachment = True
+                zeroHosts = False
+                # FIXME: topo-HA/obelisk specific mappings:
+                # key is mac and value is dpid
+                mappings = {}
+                for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # hosts 1 through 28
+                    # set up correct variables:
+                    macId = "00:" * 5 + hex( i ).split( "0x" )[1].upper().zfill(2)
+                    if i == 1:
+                        deviceId = "1000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 2:
+                        deviceId = "2000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 3:
+                        deviceId = "3000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 4:
+                        deviceId = "3004".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 5:
+                        deviceId = "5000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 6:
+                        deviceId = "6000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 7:
+                        deviceId = "6007".zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                        dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                        dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 28:
+                        deviceId = "2800".zfill(16)
+                    mappings[ macId ] = deviceId
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if hosts[ controller ] == []:
+                        main.log.warn( "There are no hosts discovered" )
+                        zeroHosts = True
+                    else:
+                        for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                            mac = None
+                            location = None
+                            device = None
+                            port = None
+                            try:
+                                mac = host.get( 'mac' )
+                                assert mac, "mac field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                location = host.get( 'location' )
+                                assert location, "location field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                # Trim the protocol identifier off deviceId
+                                device = str( location.get( 'elementId' ) ).split(':')[1]
+                                assert device, "elementId field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                port = location.get( 'port' )
+                                assert port, "port field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                # Now check if this matches where they should be
+                                if mac and device and port:
+                                    if str( port ) != "1":
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment port is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: 1 Actual: " + str( port) )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                    if device != mappings[ str( mac ) ]:
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment device is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: " + mappings[ str( mac ) ] +
+                                                        " Actual: " + device )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                else:
+                                    hostAttachment = False
+                            except AssertionError:
+                                main.log.exception( "Json object not as expected" )
+                                main.log.error( repr( host ) )
+                                hostAttachment = False
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "No hosts json output or \"Error\"" +
+                                    " in output. hosts = " +
+                                    repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                if zeroHosts is False:
+                    hostAttachment = True
+
+                # END CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+                linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+                hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+                hostAttachmentResults = hostAttachmentResults and\
+                                        hostAttachment
+
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts information is correct" )
+        hostsResults = hostsResults and ipResult
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Host information is correct",
+            onfail="Host information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Host attachment points to the network" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=hostAttachmentResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correctly attached to the network",
+            onfail="ONOS did not correctly attach hosts to the network" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+
+        main.step( "There is only one SCC" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[0] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        topoResult = ( devicesResults and linksResults
+                       and hostsResults and consistentHostsResult
+                       and consistentClustersResult and clusterResults
+                       and ipResult and hostAttachmentResults )
+
+        topoResult = topoResult and int( count <= 2 )
+        note = "note it takes about " + str( int( cliTime ) ) + \
+            " seconds for the test to make all the cli calls to fetch " +\
+            "the topology from each ONOS instance"
+        main.log.info(
+            "Very crass estimate for topology discovery/convergence( " +
+            str( note ) + " ): " + str( elapsed ) + " seconds, " +
+            str( count ) + " tries" )
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        # FIXME: move this to an ONOS state case
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS nodes" )
+        nodesOutput = []
+        nodeResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].nodes,
+                             name="nodes-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            nodesOutput.append( t.result )
+        ips = [ node.ip_address for node in nodes ]
+        for i in nodesOutput:
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( i )
+                for node in current:
+                    currentResult = main.FALSE
+                    if node['ip'] in ips:  # node in nodes() output is in cell
+                        if node['state'] == 'ACTIVE':
+                            currentResult = main.TRUE
+                        else:
+                            main.log.error( "Error in ONOS node availability" )
+                            main.log.error(
+                                    json.dumps( current,
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                            break
+                    nodeResults = nodeResults and currentResult
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Error parsing nodes output" )
+                main.log.warn( repr( i ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=nodeResults,
+                                 onpass="Nodes check successful",
+                                 onfail="Nodes check NOT successful" )
+
+    def CASE9( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 down
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Turn off a link to ensure that Link Discovery " +\
+                      "is working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Kill Link between s3 and s28" )
+        LinkDown = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="down" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkDown,
+                                 onpass="Link down successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link down" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE10( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 up
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Restore a link to ensure that Link Discovery is " + \
+                      "working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Bring link between s3 and s28 back up" )
+        LinkUp = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="up" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkUp,
+                                 onpass="Link up successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link up" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE11( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Down
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Killing a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+
+        # TODO: Make this switch parameterizable
+        main.step( "Kill " + switch )
+        main.log.info( "Deleting " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.delSwitch( switch )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ] is False:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="Kill switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to kill switch?" )
+
+    def CASE12( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Up
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+        links = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'links' ].split()
+        description = "Adding a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Add back " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.addSwitch( switch, dpid=switchDPID )
+        for peer in links:
+            main.Mininet1.addLink( switch, peer )
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=switch, ip=ipList )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ]:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="add switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to add switch?" )
+
+    def CASE13( self, main ):
+        """
+        Clean up
+        """
+        import os
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # printing colors to terminal
+        colors = { 'cyan': '\033[96m', 'purple': '\033[95m',
+                   'blue': '\033[94m', 'green': '\033[92m',
+                   'yellow': '\033[93m', 'red': '\033[91m', 'end': '\033[0m' }
+        main.case( "Test Cleanup" )
+        main.step( "Killing tcpdumps" )
+        main.Mininet2.stopTcpdump()
+
+        testname = main.TEST
+        if main.params[ 'BACKUP' ] == "True":
+            main.step( "Copying MN pcap and ONOS log files to test station" )
+            teststationUser = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONUSER' ]
+            teststationIP = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONIP' ]
+            # NOTE: MN Pcap file is being saved to ~/packet_captures
+            #       scp this file as MN and TestON aren't necessarily the same vm
+            # FIXME: scp
+            # mn files
+            # TODO: Load these from params
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/log/"
+            logFiles = [ "karaf.log", "karaf.log.1" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+
+            # std*.log's
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/var/"
+            logFiles = [ "stderr.log", "stdout.log" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+            # sleep so scp can finish
+            time.sleep( 10 )
+            main.step( "Packing and rotating pcap archives" )
+            os.system( "~/TestON/dependencies/rotate.sh " + str( testname ) )
+
+        main.step( "Stopping Mininet" )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.stopNet()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet stopped",
+                                 onfail="MN cleanup NOT successful" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS Logs for errors" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            print colors[ 'purple' ] + "Checking logs for errors on " + \
+                node.name + ":" + colors[ 'end' ]
+            print main.ONOSbench.checkLogs( node.ip_address, restart=True )
+
+        try:
+            timerLog = open( main.logdir + "/Timers.csv", 'w')
+            # Overwrite with empty line and close
+            labels = "Gossip Intents, Restart"
+            data = str( gossipTime ) + ", " + str( main.restartTime )
+            timerLog.write( labels + "\n" + data )
+            timerLog.close()
+        except NameError, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+    def CASE14( self, main ):
+        """
+        start election app on all onos nodes
+        """
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case("Start Leadership Election app")
+        main.step( "Install leadership election app" )
+        appResult = main.ONOScli1.activateApp( "org.onosproject.election" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=appResult,
+            onpass="Election app installed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with installing Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on each node" )
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            cli.electionTestRun()
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.error( cli.name + ": Leader for the election app " +
+                                 "should be an ONOS node, instead got '" +
+                                 str( leader ) + "'" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Successfully ran for leadership",
+            onfail="Failed to run for leadership" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+    def CASE15( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        description = "Check that Leadership Election is still functional"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+        main.step( "Find current leader and withdraw" )
+        leader = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # do some sanity checking on leader before using it
+        withdrawResult = main.FALSE
+        if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Leader for the election app should be an ONOS node," +
+                "instead got '" + str( leader ) + "'" )
+            leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            oldLeader = None
+        for i in range( len( CLIs ) ):
+            if leader == nodes[ i ].ip_address:
+                oldLeader = CLIs[ i ]
+                break
+        else:  # FOR/ELSE statement
+            main.log.error( "Leader election, could not find current leader" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            withdrawResult = oldLeader.electionTestWithdraw()
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=withdrawResult,
+            onpass="Node was withdrawn from election",
+            onfail="Node was not withdrawn from election" )
+
+        main.step( "Make sure new leader is elected" )
+        # FIXME: use threads
+        leaderList = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaderList.append( leaderN )
+            if leaderN == leader:
+                main.log.error(  cli.name + " still sees " + str( leader ) +
+                                  " as leader after they withdrew" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in  response
+                # TODO: add check for "Command not found:" in the driver, this
+                #       means the app isn't loaded
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, " +
+                                 "check the error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN is None:
+                # node may not have recieved the event yet
+                time.sleep(7)
+                leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+                leaderList.pop()
+                leaderList.append( leaderN )
+        consistentLeader = main.FALSE
+        if len( set( leaderList ) ) == 1:
+            main.log.info( "Each Election-app sees '" +
+                           str( leaderList[ 0 ] ) +
+                           "' as the leader" )
+            consistentLeader = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Inconsistent responses for leader of Election-app:" )
+            for n in range( len( leaderList ) ):
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( n + 1 ) + " response: " +
+                                 str( leaderList[ n ] ) )
+        leaderResult = leaderResult and consistentLeader
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on old leader( just so everyone " +
+                   "is in the hat )" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            runResult = oldLeader.electionTestRun()
+        else:
+            runResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=runResult,
+            onpass="App re-ran for election",
+            onfail="App failed to run for election" )
+
+        main.step( "Leader did not change when old leader re-ran" )
+        afterRun = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # verify leader didn't just change
+        if afterRun == leaderList[ 0 ]:
+            afterResult = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            afterResult = main.FALSE
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=afterResult,
+            onpass="Old leader successfully re-ran for election",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election after " +
+                   "the old leader re-ran for election" )
+
+    def CASE16( self, main ):
+        """
+        Install Distributed Primitives app
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests
+        global pCounterName
+        global iCounterName
+        global pCounterValue
+        global iCounterValue
+        global onosSet
+        global onosSetName
+        pCounterName = "TestON-Partitions"
+        iCounterName = "TestON-inMemory"
+        pCounterValue = 0
+        iCounterValue = 0
+        onosSet = set([])
+        onosSetName = "TestON-set"
+
+        description = "Install Primitives app"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.step( "Install Primitives app" )
+        appName = "org.onosproject.distributedprimitives"
+        appResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( appName )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=appResults,
+                                 onpass="Primitives app activated",
+                                 onfail="Primitives app not activated" )
+        time.sleep( 5 )  # To allow all nodes to activate
+
+    def CASE17( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+        """
+        import json
+        # Make sure variables are defined/set
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert pCounterName, "pCounterName not defined"
+        assert iCounterName, "iCounterName not defined"
+        assert onosSetName, "onosSetName not defined"
+        # NOTE: assert fails if value is 0/None/Empty/False
+        try:
+            pCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "pCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            pCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            iCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "iCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            iCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            onosSet
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "onosSet not defined, setting to empty Set" )
+            onosSet = set([])
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests. These are local only
+        addValue = "a"
+        addAllValue = "a b c d e f"
+        retainValue = "c d e f"
+
+        description = "Check for basic functionality with distributed " +\
+                      "primitives"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Test the methods of the distributed primitives (counters and sets) throught the cli"
+        # DISTRIBUTED ATOMIC COUNTERS
+        main.step( "Increment and get a default counter on each node" )
+        pCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        addedPValues = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="counterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ pCounterName ] )
+            pCounterValue += 1
+            addedPValues.append( pCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            pCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        pCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedPValues:
+            tmpResult = i in pCounters
+            pCounterResults = pCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in partitioned "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=pCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="Default counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing default" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Increment and get an in memory counter on each node" )
+        iCounters = []
+        addedIValues = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="icounterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ iCounterName ],
+                             kwargs={ "inMemory": True } )
+            iCounterValue += 1
+            addedIValues.append( iCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            iCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        iCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedIValues:
+            tmpResult = i in iCounters
+            iCounterResults = iCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in the in-memory "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=iCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="In memory counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing in memory" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Check counters are consistant across nodes" )
+        onosCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counters,
+                             name="counters-" + str( i ) )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            onosCounters.append( t.result )
+        tmp = [ i == onosCounters[ 0 ] for i in onosCounters ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Counters are consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error( "Counters are not consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=consistentCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS counters are consistent " +
+                                        "across nodes",
+                                 onfail="ONOS Counters are inconsistent " +
+                                        "across nodes" )
+
+        main.step( "Counters we added have the correct values" )
+        correctResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( onosCounters[i] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Could not parse counters response from ONOS" +
+                                str( i + 1 ) )
+                main.log.warn( repr( onosCounters[ i ] ) )
+            pValue = None
+            iValue = None
+            try:
+                for database in current:
+                    partitioned = database.get( 'partitionedDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if partitioned:
+                        for value in partitioned:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == pCounterName:
+                                pValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+                    inMemory = database.get( 'inMemoryDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if inMemory:
+                        for value in inMemory:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == iCounterName:
+                                iValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+            except AttributeError, e:
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " counters result " +
+                                "is not as expected" )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if pValue == pCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "Partitioned counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Partitioned counter value is incorrect," +
+                                " expected value: " + str( pCounterValue )
+                                + " current value: " + str( pValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if iValue == iCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "In memory counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "In memory counter value is incorrect, " +
+                                "expected value: " + str( iCounterValue ) +
+                                " current value: " + str( iValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=correctResults,
+                                 onpass="Added counters are correct",
+                                 onfail="Added counters are incorrect" )
+        # DISTRIBUTED SETS
+        main.step( "Distributed Set get" )
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=getResults,
+                                 onpass="Set elements are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set elements are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set size" )
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=sizeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set sizes are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set sizes are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set add()" )
+        onosSet.add( addValue )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAdd-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+        if addResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set add" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addResults = addResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addResults,
+                                 onpass="Set add correct",
+                                 onfail="Set add was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set contains()" )
+        containsResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContains-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsResults,
+                                 onpass="Set contains is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set contains failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set containsAll()" )
+        containsAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContainsAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addAllValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsAllResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set containsAll is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set containsAll failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set remove()" )
+        onosSet.remove( addValue )
+        removeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRemove-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            removeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set remove" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeResults = removeResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set remove correct",
+                                 onfail="Set remove was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set removeAll()" )
+        onosSet.difference_update( addAllValue.split() )
+        removeAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        try:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                                 name="setTestRemoveAll-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                removeAllResponses.append( t.result )
+        except Exception, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set removeAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeAllResults = removeAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set removeAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set removeAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set clear()" )
+        onosSet.clear()
+        clearResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestClear-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, " "],  # Values doesn't matter
+                             kwargs={ "clear": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clearResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        clearResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if clearResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Nothing set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+        if clearResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set clear" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        clearResults = clearResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=clearResults,
+                                 onpass="Set clear correct",
+                                 onfail="Set clear was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set retain()" )
+        onosSet.intersection_update( retainValue.split() )
+        retainResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRetain-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, retainValue ],
+                             kwargs={ "retain": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            retainResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        retainResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if retainResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+        if retainResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set retain" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " +
+                                str( size ) + " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        retainResults = retainResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=retainResults,
+                                 onpass="Set retain correct",
+                                 onfail="Set retain was incorrect" )
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.topo b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.topo
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5f87b9d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/HAminorityRestart.topo
@@ -0,0 +1,170 @@
+<TOPOLOGY>
+    <COMPONENT>
+
+        <ONOSbench>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>1</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOSbench>
+
+        <ONOScli1>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>2</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli1>
+
+        <ONOScli2>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>3</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli2>
+
+        <ONOScli3>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>4</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli3>
+
+
+        <ONOScli4>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>5</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli4>
+
+
+        <ONOScli5>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>6</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli5>
+
+
+        <ONOScli6>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>7</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli6>
+
+
+        <ONOScli7>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>8</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli7>
+
+        <ONOS1>
+            <host>OC1</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>9</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS1>
+
+        <ONOS2>
+            <host>OC2</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>10</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS2>
+
+        <ONOS3>
+            <host>OC3</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>11</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS3>
+
+        <ONOS4>
+            <host>OC4</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>12</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS4>
+
+        <ONOS5>
+            <host>OC5</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>13</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS5>
+
+        <ONOS6>
+            <host>OC6</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>14</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS6>
+
+        <ONOS7>
+            <host>OC7</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>15</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS7>
+
+        <Mininet1>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>MininetCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>16</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+                #Specify the Option for mininet
+                <arg1> --custom ~/mininet/custom/obelisk.py </arg1>
+                <arg2> --topo obelisk </arg2>
+                <arg3> </arg3>
+                <controller> none </controller>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet1>
+
+        <Mininet2>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>RemoteMininetDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>17</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet2>
+
+    </COMPONENT>
+</TOPOLOGY>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/__init__.py b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/__init__.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..e69de29
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/__init__.py
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py
new file mode 100755
index 0000000..fb6ccdb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAminorityRestart/dependencies/obelisk.py
@@ -0,0 +1,70 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python
+
+from mininet.topo import Topo
+
+class ObeliskTopo( Topo ):
+    def __init__( self ):
+        Topo.__init__( self )
+        topSwitch = self.addSwitch('s1',dpid='1000'.zfill(16))
+        leftTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s2',dpid='2000'.zfill(16))
+        rightTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s5',dpid='5000'.zfill(16))
+        leftBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s3',dpid='3000'.zfill(16))
+        rightBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s6',dpid='6000'.zfill(16))	
+        midBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s28',dpid='2800'.zfill(16))
+        
+        topHost = self.addHost( 'h1' )
+        leftTopHost = self.addHost('h2')
+        rightTopHost = self.addHost('h5')
+        leftBotHost = self.addHost('h3')
+        rightBotHost = self.addHost('h6')
+        midBotHost = self.addHost('h28')
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,topHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftTopHost)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightTopHost)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,leftBotHost)
+        self.addLink(rightBotSwitch,rightBotHost)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,midBotHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,leftTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,midBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+
+        agg1Switch = self.addSwitch('s4',dpid = '3004'.zfill(16))
+        agg2Switch = self.addSwitch('s7',dpid = '6007'.zfill(16))
+        agg1Host = self.addHost('h4')
+        agg2Host = self.addHost('h7')
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch,agg1Host)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch,agg2Host)
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch, leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch, rightBotSwitch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+8)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('30'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg1Switch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+18)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('60'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg2Switch)
+
+topos = { 'obelisk': (lambda: ObeliskTopo() ) }
+
+def run():
+    topo = ObeliskTopo()
+    net = Mininet( topo=topo, controller=RemoteController, autoSetMacs=True )
+    net.start()
+    CLI( net )
+    net.stop()
+
+if __name__ == '__main__':
+    setLogLevel( 'info' )
+    run()
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.params b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.params
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..4ec3ad4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.params
@@ -0,0 +1,81 @@
+<PARAMS>
+    #List of test cases:
+    #CASE1: Compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+    #CASE2: Assign mastership to controllers
+    #CASE3: Assign intents
+    #CASE4: Ping across added host intents
+    #CASE5: Reading state of ONOS
+    #CASE6: The Failure case. Since this is the Sanity test, we do nothing.
+    #CASE7: Check state after control plane failure
+    #CASE8: Compare topo
+    #CASE9: Link s3-s28 down
+    #CASE10: Link s3-s28 up
+    #CASE11: Switch down
+    #CASE12: Switch up
+    #CASE13: Clean up
+    #CASE14: start election app on all onos nodes
+    #CASE15: Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+    #CASE16: Install Distributed Primitives app
+    #CASE17: Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+    #1,2,8,3,4,5,14,16,17,[6],8,7,4,15,17,9,8,4,10,8,4,11,8,4,12,8,4,13
+    <testcases>1,2,8,21,8,3,4,5,14,16,17,[6],8,7,4,15,17,9,8,4,10,8,4,11,8,4,12,8,4,13</testcases>
+    <ENV>
+        <cellName>HA</cellName>
+        <appString>drivers,openflow,proxyarp,mobility</appString>
+    </ENV>
+    <Git> False </Git>
+    <branch> master </branch>
+    <num_controllers> 7 </num_controllers>
+    <tcpdump> False </tcpdump>
+
+    <CTRL>
+        <port1>6633</port1>
+        <port2>6633</port2>
+        <port3>6633</port3>
+        <port4>6633</port4>
+        <port5>6633</port5>
+        <port6>6633</port6>
+        <port7>6633</port7>
+    </CTRL>
+    <BACKUP>
+        <ENABLED> False </ENABLED>
+        <TESTONUSER>admin</TESTONUSER>
+        <TESTONIP>10.128.30.9</TESTONIP>
+    </BACKUP>
+    <PING>
+        <source1>h8</source1>
+        <source2>h9</source2>
+        <source3>h10</source3>
+        <source4>h11</source4>
+        <source5>h12</source5>
+        <source6>h13</source6>
+        <source7>h14</source7>
+        <source8>h15</source8>
+        <source9>h16</source9>
+        <source10>h17</source10>
+        <target1>10.0.0.18</target1>
+        <target2>10.0.0.19</target2>
+        <target3>10.0.0.20</target3>
+        <target4>10.0.0.21</target4>
+        <target5>10.0.0.22</target5>
+        <target6>10.0.0.23</target6>
+        <target7>10.0.0.24</target7>
+        <target8>10.0.0.25</target8>
+        <target9>10.0.0.26</target9>
+        <target10>10.0.0.27</target10>
+    </PING>
+    <timers>
+        <LinkDiscovery>.2</LinkDiscovery>
+        <SwitchDiscovery>.2</SwitchDiscovery>
+    </timers>
+    <kill>
+        <switch> s5 </switch>
+        <dpid> 0000000000005000 </dpid>
+        <links> h5 s2 s1 s6 </links>
+    </kill>
+    <MNtcpdump>
+        <intf>eth0</intf>
+        <port> </port>
+        <folder>~/packet_captures/</folder>
+    </MNtcpdump>
+</PARAMS>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.py b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..c223c3f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.py
@@ -0,0 +1,3930 @@
+"""
+Description: This test is to determine if the HA test setup is
+    working correctly. There are no failures so this test should
+    have a 100% pass rate
+
+List of test cases:
+CASE1: Compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+CASE2: Assign devices to controllers
+CASE21: Assign mastership to controllers
+CASE3: Assign intents
+CASE4: Ping across added host intents
+CASE5: Reading state of ONOS
+CASE6: The Failure case. Since this is the Sanity test, we do nothing.
+CASE7: Check state after control plane failure
+CASE8: Compare topo
+CASE9: Link s3-s28 down
+CASE10: Link s3-s28 up
+CASE11: Switch down
+CASE12: Switch up
+CASE13: Clean up
+CASE14: start election app on all onos nodes
+CASE15: Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+CASE16: Install Distributed Primitives app
+CASE17: Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+"""
+
+
+class HAsanity:
+
+    def __init__( self ):
+        self.default = ''
+
+    def CASE1( self, main ):
+        """
+        CASE1 is to compile ONOS and push it to the test machines
+
+        Startup sequence:
+        cell <name>
+        onos-verify-cell
+        NOTE: temporary - onos-remove-raft-logs
+        onos-uninstall
+        start mininet
+        git pull
+        mvn clean install
+        onos-package
+        onos-install -f
+        onos-wait-for-start
+        start cli sessions
+        start tcpdump
+        """
+        main.log.info( "ONOS HA Sanity test - initialization" )
+        main.case( "Setting up test environment" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Setup the test environment including " +\
+                                "installing ONOS, starting Mininet and ONOS" +\
+                                "cli sessions."
+        # TODO: save all the timers and output them for plotting
+
+        # load some variables from the params file
+        PULLCODE = False
+        if main.params[ 'Git' ] == 'True':
+            PULLCODE = True
+        gitBranch = main.params[ 'branch' ]
+        cellName = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'cellName' ]
+
+        # set global variables
+        global numControllers
+        numControllers = int( main.params[ 'num_controllers' ] )
+        if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes:
+            if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes < numControllers:
+                numControllers = int( main.ONOSbench.maxNodes )
+        # TODO: refactor how to get onos port, maybe put into component tag?
+        global ONOS1Port
+        global ONOS2Port
+        global ONOS3Port
+        global ONOS4Port
+        global ONOS5Port
+        global ONOS6Port
+        global ONOS7Port
+
+        # FIXME: just get controller port from params?
+        # TODO: do we really need all these?
+        ONOS1Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port1' ]
+        ONOS2Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port2' ]
+        ONOS3Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port3' ]
+        ONOS4Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port4' ]
+        ONOS5Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port5' ]
+        ONOS6Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port6' ]
+        ONOS7Port = main.params[ 'CTRL' ][ 'port7' ]
+
+        global CLIs
+        CLIs = []
+        global nodes
+        nodes = []
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( 1, numControllers + 1 ):
+            CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
+            nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+            ipList.append( nodes[ -1 ].ip_address )
+
+        main.step( "Create cell file" )
+        cellAppString = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'appString' ]
+        main.ONOSbench.createCellFile( main.ONOSbench.ip_address, cellName,
+                                       main.Mininet1.ip_address,
+                                       cellAppString, ipList )
+        main.step( "Applying cell variable to environment" )
+        cellResult = main.ONOSbench.setCell( cellName )
+        verifyResult = main.ONOSbench.verifyCell()
+
+        # FIXME:this is short term fix
+        main.log.info( "Removing raft logs" )
+        main.ONOSbench.onosRemoveRaftLogs()
+
+        main.log.info( "Uninstalling ONOS" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            main.ONOSbench.onosUninstall( node.ip_address )
+
+        # Make sure ONOS is DEAD
+        main.log.info( "Killing any ONOS processes" )
+        killResults = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            killed = main.ONOSbench.onosKill( node.ip_address )
+            killResults = killResults and killed
+
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        gitPullResult = main.TRUE
+
+        main.step( "Starting Mininet" )
+        # scp topo file to mininet
+        # TODO: move to params?
+        topoName = "obelisk.py"
+        filePath = main.ONOSbench.home + "/tools/test/topos/"
+        main.ONOSbench.copyMininetFile( topoName, filePath,
+                                        main.Mininet1.user_name,
+                                        main.Mininet1.ip_address )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.startNet( )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet Started",
+                                 onfail="Error starting Mininet" )
+
+        main.step( "Git checkout and pull " + gitBranch )
+        if PULLCODE:
+            main.ONOSbench.gitCheckout( gitBranch )
+            gitPullResult = main.ONOSbench.gitPull()
+            # values of 1 or 3 are good
+            utilities.assert_lesser( expect=0, actual=gitPullResult,
+                                      onpass="Git pull successful",
+                                      onfail="Git pull failed" )
+        main.ONOSbench.getVersion( report=True )
+
+        main.step( "Using mvn clean install" )
+        cleanInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        if PULLCODE and gitPullResult == main.TRUE:
+            cleanInstallResult = main.ONOSbench.cleanInstall()
+        else:
+            main.log.warn( "Did not pull new code so skipping mvn " +
+                           "clean install" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=cleanInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="MCI successful",
+                                 onfail="MCI failed" )
+        # GRAPHS
+        # NOTE: important params here:
+        #       job = name of Jenkins job
+        #       Plot Name = Plot-HA, only can be used if multiple plots
+        #       index = The number of the graph under plot name
+        job = "HAsanity"
+        plotName = "Plot-HA"
+        graphs = '<ac:structured-macro ac:name="html">\n'
+        graphs += '<ac:plain-text-body><![CDATA[\n'
+        graphs += '<iframe src="https://onos-jenkins.onlab.us/job/' + job +\
+                  '/plot/' + plotName + '/getPlot?index=0' +\
+                  '&width=500&height=300"' +\
+                  'noborder="0" width="500" height="300" scrolling="yes" ' +\
+                  'seamless="seamless"></iframe>\n'
+        graphs += ']]></ac:plain-text-body>\n'
+        graphs += '</ac:structured-macro>\n'
+        main.log.wiki(graphs)
+
+        main.step( "Creating ONOS package" )
+        packageResult = main.ONOSbench.onosPackage()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=packageResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS package successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS package failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Installing ONOS package" )
+        onosInstallResult = main.TRUE
+        for node in nodes:
+            tmpResult = main.ONOSbench.onosInstall( options="-f",
+                                                    node=node.ip_address )
+            onosInstallResult = onosInstallResult and tmpResult
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosInstallResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS install successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS install failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking if ONOS is up yet" )
+        for i in range( 2 ):
+            onosIsupResult = main.TRUE
+            for node in nodes:
+                started = main.ONOSbench.isup( node.ip_address )
+                if not started:
+                    main.log.error( node.name + " didn't start!" )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStop( node.ip_address )
+                    main.ONOSbench.onosStart( node.ip_address )
+                onosIsupResult = onosIsupResult and started
+            if onosIsupResult == main.TRUE:
+                break
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=onosIsupResult,
+                                 onpass="ONOS startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS startup failed" )
+
+        main.log.step( "Starting ONOS CLI sessions" )
+        cliResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].startOnosCli,
+                             name="startOnosCli-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[nodes[i].ip_address] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            cliResults = cliResults and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=cliResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS cli startup successful",
+                                 onfail="ONOS cli startup failed" )
+
+        if main.params[ 'tcpdump' ].lower() == "true":
+            main.step( "Start Packet Capture MN" )
+            main.Mininet2.startTcpdump(
+                str( main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'folder' ] ) + str( main.TEST )
+                + "-MN.pcap",
+                intf=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'intf' ],
+                port=main.params[ 'MNtcpdump' ][ 'port' ] )
+
+        main.step( "App Ids check" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        if cliResults == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error( "Failed to start ONOS, stopping test" )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+
+    def CASE2( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign devices to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning devices to controllers" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Assign switches to ONOS using 'ovs-vsctl' " +\
+                                "and check that an ONOS node becomes the " +\
+                                "master of the device."
+        main.step( "Assign switches to controllers" )
+
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        swList = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            swList.append( "s" + str( i ) )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=swList, ip=ipList )
+
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            response = main.Mininet1.getSwController( "s" + str( i ) )
+            try:
+                main.log.info( str( response ) )
+            except Exception:
+                main.log.info( repr( response ) )
+            for node in nodes:
+                if re.search( "tcp:" + node.ip_address, response ):
+                    mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "Error, node " + node.ip_address + " is " +
+                                    "not in the list of controllers s" +
+                                    str( i ) + " is connecting to." )
+                    mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Switch mastership assigned correctly",
+            onfail="Switches not assigned correctly to controllers" )
+
+    def CASE21( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign mastership to controllers
+        """
+        import re
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Assigning Controller roles for switches" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Check that ONOS is connected to each " +\
+                                "device. Then manually assign" +\
+                                " mastership to specific ONOS nodes using" +\
+                                " 'device-role'"
+        main.step( "Assign mastership of switches to specific controllers" )
+        # Manually assign mastership to the controller we want
+        roleCall = main.TRUE
+
+        ipList = [ ]
+        deviceList = []
+        try:
+            # Assign mastership to specific controllers. This assignment was
+            # determined for a 7 node cluser, but will work with any sized
+            # cluster
+            for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # switches 1 through 28
+                # set up correct variables:
+                if i == 1:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "1000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 2:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 3:
+                    c = 1 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS2
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 4:
+                    c = 3 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS4
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "3004" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 5:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "5000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 6:
+                    c = 2 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS3
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6000" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 7:
+                    c = 5 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS6
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "6007" ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                    c = 4 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS5
+                    dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                    c = 6 % numControllers
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS7
+                    dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid ).get( 'id' )
+                elif i == 28:
+                    c = 0
+                    ip = nodes[ c ].ip_address  # ONOS1
+                    deviceId = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( "2800" ).get( 'id' )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "You didn't write an else statement for " +
+                                    "switch s" + str( i ) )
+                    roleCall = main.FALSE
+                # Assign switch
+                assert deviceId, "No device id for s" + str( i ) + " in ONOS"
+                # TODO: make this controller dynamic
+                roleCall = roleCall and main.ONOScli1.deviceRole( deviceId,
+                                                                  ip )
+                ipList.append( ip )
+                deviceList.append( deviceId )
+        except ( AttributeError, AssertionError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with ONOS device view" )
+            main.log.info( main.ONOScli1.devices() )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCall,
+            onpass="Re-assigned switch mastership to designated controller",
+            onfail="Something wrong with deviceRole calls" )
+
+        main.step( "Check mastership was correctly assigned" )
+        roleCheck = main.TRUE
+        # NOTE: This is due to the fact that device mastership change is not
+        #       atomic and is actually a multi step process
+        time.sleep( 5 )
+        for i in range( len( ipList ) ):
+            ip = ipList[i]
+            deviceId = deviceList[i]
+            # Check assignment
+            master = main.ONOScli1.getRole( deviceId ).get( 'master' )
+            if ip in master:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                roleCheck = roleCheck and main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "Error, controller " + ip + " is not" +
+                                " master " + "of device " +
+                                str( deviceId ) + ". Master is " +
+                                repr( master ) + "." )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=roleCheck,
+            onpass="Switches were successfully reassigned to designated " +
+                   "controller",
+            onfail="Switches were not successfully reassigned" )
+
+    def CASE3( self, main ):
+        """
+        Assign intents
+        """
+        import time
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Adding host Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Discover hosts by using pingall then " +\
+                                "assign predetermined host-to-host intents." +\
+                                " After installation, check that the intent" +\
+                                " is distributed to all nodes and the state" +\
+                                " is INSTALLED"
+
+        # install onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Install reactive forwarding app" )
+        installResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=installResults,
+                                 onpass="Install fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Install fwd failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        appCheck = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck = appCheck and t.result
+        if appCheck != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Discovering Hosts( Via pingall for now )" )
+        # FIXME: Once we have a host discovery mechanism, use that instead
+        # REACTIVE FWD test
+        pingResult = main.FALSE
+        for i in range(2):  # Retry if pingall fails first time
+            time1 = time.time()
+            pingResult = main.Mininet1.pingall()
+            if i == 0:
+                utilities.assert_equals(
+                    expect=main.TRUE,
+                    actual=pingResult,
+                    onpass="Reactive Pingall test passed",
+                    onfail="Reactive Pingall failed, " +
+                           "one or more ping pairs failed" )
+            time2 = time.time()
+            main.log.info( "Time for pingall: %2f seconds" %
+                           ( time2 - time1 ) )
+        # timeout for fwd flows
+        time.sleep( 11 )
+        # uninstall onos-app-fwd
+        main.step( "Uninstall reactive forwarding app" )
+        uninstallResult = CLIs[0].deactivateApp( "org.onosproject.fwd" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=uninstallResult,
+                                 onpass="Uninstall fwd successful",
+                                 onfail="Uninstall fwd failed" )
+        '''
+        main.Mininet1.handle.sendline( "py [ h.cmd( \"arping -c 1 10.1.1.1 \" ) for h in net.hosts ] ")
+        import time
+        time.sleep(60)
+        '''
+
+        main.step( "Check app ids" )
+        threads = []
+        appCheck2 = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].appToIDCheck,
+                             name="appToIDCheck-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            appCheck2 = appCheck2 and t.result
+        if appCheck2 != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].apps() )
+            main.log.warn( CLIs[0].appIDs() )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=appCheck2,
+                                 onpass="App Ids seem to be correct",
+                                 onfail="Something is wrong with app Ids" )
+
+        main.step( "Add host intents via cli" )
+        intentIds = []
+        # TODO:  move the host numbers to params
+        #        Maybe look at all the paths we ping?
+        intentAddResult = True
+        hostResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info( "Adding host intent between h" + str( i ) +
+                           " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            host1 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            host2 = "00:00:00:00:00:" + \
+                str( hex( i + 10 )[ 2: ] ).zfill( 2 ).upper()
+            # NOTE: getHost can return None
+            host1Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host1 )
+            host2Dict = main.ONOScli1.getHost( host2 )
+            host1Id = None
+            host2Id = None
+            if host1Dict and host2Dict:
+                host1Id = host1Dict.get( 'id', None )
+                host2Id = host2Dict.get( 'id', None )
+            if host1Id and host2Id:
+                nodeNum = ( i % numControllers )
+                tmpId = CLIs[ nodeNum ].addHostIntent( host1Id, host2Id )
+                if tmpId:
+                    main.log.info( "Added intent with id: " + tmpId )
+                    intentIds.append( tmpId )
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "addHostIntent returned: " +
+                                     repr( tmpId ) )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error, getHost() failed for h" + str( i ) +
+                                " and/or h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+                hosts = CLIs[ 0 ].hosts()
+                main.log.warn( "Hosts output: " )
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( hosts ),
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts ) )
+                hostResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=hostResult,
+                                 onpass="Found a host id for each host",
+                                 onfail="Error looking up host ids" )
+
+        intentStart = time.time()
+        onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+        main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+        main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+        for intent in intentIds:
+            if intent in onosIds:
+                pass  # intent submitted is in onos
+            else:
+                intentAddResult = False
+        if intentAddResult:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        else:
+            intentStop = None
+        # Print the intent states
+        intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+        intentStates = []
+        installedCheck = True
+        main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+        count = 0
+        try:
+            for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                    installedCheck = False
+                intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+        # add submitted intents not in the store
+        tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+        missingIntents = False
+        for i in intentIds:
+            if i not in tmplist:
+                intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+                missingIntents = True
+        intentStates.sort()
+        for i, s in intentStates:
+            count += 1
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                           ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        try:
+            missing = False
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        missing = True
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+        # Check all nodes
+        if missing:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        intentAddResult = bool( intentAddResult and not missingIntents and
+                                installedCheck )
+        if not intentAddResult:
+            main.log.error( "Error in pushing host intents to ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Intent Anti-Entropy dispersion" )
+        for i in range(100):
+            correct = True
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( sorted( intentIds ) ) )
+            for cli in CLIs:
+                onosIds = []
+                ids = cli.getAllIntentsId()
+                onosIds.append( ids )
+                main.log.debug( "Intents in " + cli.name + ": " +
+                                str( sorted( onosIds ) ) )
+                if sorted( ids ) != sorted( intentIds ):
+                    main.log.warn( "Set of intent IDs doesn't match" )
+                    correct = False
+                    break
+                else:
+                    intents = json.loads( cli.intents() )
+                    for intent in intents:
+                        if intent[ 'state' ] != "INSTALLED":
+                            main.log.warn( "Intent " + intent[ 'id' ] +
+                                           " is " + intent[ 'state' ] )
+                            correct = False
+                            break
+            if correct:
+                break
+            else:
+                time.sleep(1)
+        if not intentStop:
+            intentStop = time.time()
+        global gossipTime
+        gossipTime = intentStop - intentStart
+        main.log.info( "It took about " + str( gossipTime ) +
+                        " seconds for all intents to appear in each node" )
+        # FIXME: make this time configurable/calculate based off of number of
+        #        nodes and gossip rounds
+        utilities.assert_greater_equals(
+                expect=40, actual=gossipTime,
+                onpass="ECM anti-entropy for intents worked within " +
+                       "expected time",
+                onfail="Intent ECM anti-entropy took too long" )
+        if gossipTime <= 40:
+            intentAddResult = True
+
+        if not intentAddResult or "key" in pendingMap:
+            import time
+            installedCheck = True
+            main.log.info( "Sleeping 60 seconds to see if intents are found" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            onosIds = main.ONOScli1.getAllIntentsId()
+            main.log.info( "Submitted intents: " + str( intentIds ) )
+            main.log.info( "Intents in ONOS: " + str( onosIds ) )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    # Iter through intents of a node
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents" )
+            # add submitted intents not in the store
+            tmplist = [ i for i, s in intentStates ]
+            for i in intentIds:
+                if i not in tmplist:
+                    intentStates.append( ( i, " - " ) )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # Check all nodes
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+    def CASE4( self, main ):
+        """
+        Ping across added host intents
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Verify connectivity by sendind traffic across Intents" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Ping across added host intents to check " +\
+                                "functionality and check the state of " +\
+                                "the intent"
+        main.step( "Ping across added host intents" )
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+        main.step( "Check Intent state" )
+        installedCheck = False
+        loopCount = 0
+        while not installedCheck and loopCount < 40:
+            installedCheck = True
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            # Print states
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            if not installedCheck:
+                time.sleep( 1 )
+                loopCount += 1
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True, actual=installedCheck,
+                                 onpass="Intents are all INSTALLED",
+                                 onfail="Intents are not all in " +
+                                        "INSTALLED state" )
+
+        main.step( "Check leadership of topics" )
+        leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+        topicCheck = main.TRUE
+        try:
+            if leaders:
+                parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # check for all intent partitions
+                # check for election
+                # TODO: Look at Devices as topics now that it uses this system
+                topics = []
+                for i in range( 14 ):
+                    topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                # FIXME: topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                # Print leaders output
+                main.log.debug( topics )
+                ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                for topic in topics:
+                    if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                        main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                        " not in leaders" )
+                        topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+                topicCheck = main.FALSE
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            topicCheck = main.FALSE
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+            main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            # TODO: Check for a leader of these topics
+        # Check all nodes
+        if topicCheck:
+            for node in CLIs:
+                response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                               str( response ) )
+
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=topicCheck,
+                                 onpass="intent Partitions is in leaders",
+                                 onfail="Some topics were lost " )
+        # Print partitions
+        partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+        try:
+            if partitions :
+                parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+            main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+        # Print Pending Map
+        pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+        try:
+            if pendingMap :
+                parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                # TODO check something here?
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+            main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+
+        if not installedCheck:
+            main.log.info( "Waiting 60 seconds to see if the state of " +
+                           "intents change" )
+            time.sleep( 60 )
+            # Print the intent states
+            intents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+            intentStates = []
+            main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" % ( 'Count', 'ID', 'State' ) )
+            count = 0
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( intents ):
+                    state = intent.get( 'state', None )
+                    if "INSTALLED" not in state:
+                        installedCheck = False
+                    intentId = intent.get( 'id', None )
+                    intentStates.append( ( intentId, state ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing intents." )
+            intentStates.sort()
+            for i, s in intentStates:
+                count += 1
+                main.log.info( "%-6s%-15s%-15s" %
+                               ( str( count ), str( i ), str( s ) ) )
+            leaders = main.ONOScli1.leaders()
+            try:
+                missing = False
+                if leaders:
+                    parsedLeaders = json.loads( leaders )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedLeaders,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # check for all intent partitions
+                    # check for election
+                    topics = []
+                    for i in range( 14 ):
+                        topics.append( "intent-partition-" + str( i ) )
+                    # FIXME: this should only be after we start the app
+                    topics.append( "org.onosproject.election" )
+                    main.log.debug( topics )
+                    ONOStopics = [ j['topic'] for j in parsedLeaders ]
+                    for topic in topics:
+                        if topic not in ONOStopics:
+                            main.log.error( "Error: " + topic +
+                                            " not in leaders" )
+                            missing = True
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "leaders() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing leaders" )
+                main.log.error( repr( leaders ) )
+            if missing:
+                for node in CLIs:
+                    response = node.leaders( jsonFormat=False)
+                    main.log.warn( str( node.name ) + " leaders output: \n" +
+                                   str( response ) )
+
+            partitions = main.ONOScli1.partitions()
+            try:
+                if partitions :
+                    parsedPartitions = json.loads( partitions )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPartitions,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check for a leader in all paritions
+                    # TODO check for consistency among nodes
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "partitions() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing partitions" )
+                main.log.error( repr( partitions ) )
+            pendingMap = main.ONOScli1.pendingMap()
+            try:
+                if pendingMap :
+                    parsedPending = json.loads( pendingMap )
+                    main.log.warn( json.dumps( parsedPending,
+                                               sort_keys=True,
+                                               indent=4,
+                                               separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                    # TODO check something here?
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "pendingMap() returned None" )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing pending map" )
+                main.log.error( repr( pendingMap ) )
+        # Print flowrules
+        main.log.debug( CLIs[0].flows( jsonFormat=False ) )
+        main.step( "Wait a minute then ping again" )
+        # the wait is above
+        PingResult = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            ping = main.Mininet1.pingHost( src="h" + str( i ),
+                                           target="h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            PingResult = PingResult and ping
+            if ping == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.warn( "Ping failed between h" + str( i ) +
+                               " and h" + str( i + 10 ) )
+            elif ping == main.TRUE:
+                main.log.info( "Ping test passed!" )
+                # Don't set PingResult or you'd override failures
+        if PingResult == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+            # TODO: pretty print
+            main.log.warn( "ONOS1 intents: " )
+            try:
+                tmpIntents = main.ONOScli1.intents()
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps( json.loads( tmpIntents ),
+                                           sort_keys=True,
+                                           indent=4,
+                                           separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.warn( repr( tmpIntents ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=PingResult,
+            onpass="Intents have been installed correctly and pings work",
+            onfail="Intents have not been installed correctly, pings failed." )
+
+    def CASE5( self, main ):
+        """
+        Reading state of ONOS
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Setting up and gathering data for current state" )
+        # The general idea for this test case is to pull the state of
+        # ( intents,flows, topology,... ) from each ONOS node
+        # We can then compare them with each other and also with past states
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        global mastershipState
+        mastershipState = '[]'
+
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Get the Mastership of each switch from each controller" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                        json.dumps(
+                            json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                            sort_keys=True,
+                            indent=4,
+                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn( repr( ONOSMastership[ i ] ) )
+        elif rolesResults and consistentMastership:
+            mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+            mastershipState = ONOSMastership[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents from each controller" )
+        global intentState
+        intentState = []
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+            main.log.error( "Intents not consistent" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+
+        if intentsResults:
+            # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+            #
+            # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+            #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            #  ...        ...         ...
+            title = "   Id"
+            for n in range( numControllers ):
+                title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+            main.log.warn( title )
+            keys = []
+            try:
+                # Get the set of all intent keys
+                for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                    node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                    for intent in node:
+                        keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+                keys = set( keys )
+                # For each intent key, print the state on each node
+                for key in keys:
+                    row = "%-13s" % key
+                    for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                        node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                        for intent in node:
+                            if intent.get( 'id', "Error" ) == key:
+                                row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+                    main.log.warn( row )
+                # End of intent state table
+            except ValueError as e:
+                main.log.exception( e )
+                main.log.debug( "nodeStr was: " + repr( nodeStr ) )
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            # print the json objects
+            n = len(ONOSIntents)
+            main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( n ) + " intents: " )
+            main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ -1 ] ),
+                                        sort_keys=True,
+                                        indent=4,
+                                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                if ONOSIntents[ i ] != ONOSIntents[ -1 ]:
+                    main.log.debug( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                    main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[i] ),
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                else:
+                    main.log.debug( nodes[ i ].name + " intents match ONOS" +
+                                    str( n ) + " intents" )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+            intentState = ONOSIntents[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the flows from each controller" )
+        global flowState
+        flowState = []
+        ONOSFlows = []
+        ONOSFlowsJson = []
+        flowCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentFlows = True
+        flowsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].flows,
+                             name="flows-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        # NOTE: Flows command can take some time to run
+        time.sleep(30)
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            result = t.result
+            ONOSFlows.append( result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            num = str( i + 1 )
+            if not ONOSFlows[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSFlows[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + num + " flows" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + num + " flows response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                flowsResults = False
+                ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+            else:
+                try:
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( json.loads( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    # FIXME: change this to log.error?
+                    main.log.exception( "Error in parsing ONOS" + num +
+                                        " response as json." )
+                    main.log.error( repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+                    ONOSFlowsJson.append( None )
+                    flowsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=flowsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading flows output",
+            onfail="Error in reading flows from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Flows from each controller" )
+        tmp = [ len( i ) == len( ONOSFlowsJson[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSFlowsJson ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentFlows = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentFlows,
+            onpass="The flow count is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different flow counts" )
+
+        if flowsResults and not consistentFlows:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                try:
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSFlows[i] ), sort_keys=True,
+                                    indent=4, separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.warn(
+                        "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " flows: " +
+                        repr( ONOSFlows[ i ] ) )
+        elif flowsResults and consistentFlows:
+            flowCheck = main.TRUE
+            flowState = ONOSFlows[ 0 ]
+
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries" )
+        global flows
+        flows = []
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            flows.append( main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i ) ) )
+        if flowCheck == main.FALSE:
+            for table in flows:
+                main.log.warn( table )
+        # TODO: Compare switch flow tables with ONOS flow tables
+
+        main.step( "Start continuous pings" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source1' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target1' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source2' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target2' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source3' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target3' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source4' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target4' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source5' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target5' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source6' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target6' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source7' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target7' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source8' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target8' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source9' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target9' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+        main.Mininet2.pingLong(
+            src=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'source10' ],
+            target=main.params[ 'PING' ][ 'target10' ],
+            pingTime=500 )
+
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        devices = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                             name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            devices.append( t.result )
+        hosts = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                             name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            try:
+                hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                # FIXME: better handling of this, print which node
+                #        Maybe use thread name?
+                main.log.exception( "Error parsing json output of hosts" )
+                # FIXME: should this be an empty json object instead?
+                hosts.append( None )
+
+        ports = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                             name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ports.append( t.result )
+        links = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                             name="links-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            links.append( t.result )
+        clusters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                             name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clusters.append( t.result )
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Host view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Each host has an IP address" )
+        ipResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if not host.get( 'ipAddresses', [ ] ):
+                    main.log.error( "DEBUG:Error with host ips on controller" +
+                                    controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                    ipResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=ipResult,
+            onpass="The ips of the hosts aren't empty",
+            onfail="The ip of at least one host is missing" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Cluster view is consistent across ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        main.step( "Cluster view correct across ONOS nodes" )
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+        mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+        mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+        for controller in range( numControllers ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                        mnSwitches,
+                        json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                        json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " Switches view is incorrect" )
+            if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                        mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                        json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+            else:
+                currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is correct",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " links view is incorrect" )
+
+            if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                        mnHosts,
+                        hosts[ controller ] )
+            else:
+                currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+            utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                     actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                     onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                     onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+
+            devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+            linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+            hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correct",
+            onfail="Hosts are incorrect" )
+
+    def CASE6( self, main ):
+        """
+        The Failure case. Since this is the Sanity test, we do nothing.
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Wait 60 seconds instead of inducing a failure" )
+        time.sleep( 60 )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=main.TRUE,
+            onpass="Sleeping 60 seconds",
+            onfail="Something is terribly wrong with my math" )
+
+    def CASE7( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check state after ONOS failure
+        """
+        import json
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        main.case( "Running ONOS Constant State Tests" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each switch has a master" )
+        # Assert that each device has a master
+        rolesNotNull = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].rolesNotNull,
+                             name="rolesNotNull-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            rolesNotNull = rolesNotNull and t.result
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=rolesNotNull,
+            onpass="Each device has a master",
+            onfail="Some devices don't have a master assigned" )
+
+        main.step( "Read device roles from ONOS" )
+        ONOSMastership = []
+        mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentMastership = True
+        rolesResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].roles,
+                             name="roles-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSMastership.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSMastership[i] or "Error" in ONOSMastership[i]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " roles" )
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " mastership response: " +
+                    repr( ONOSMastership[i] ) )
+                rolesResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=rolesResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading roles output",
+            onfail="Error in reading roles from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in roles from each controller" )
+        if all([ i == ONOSMastership[ 0 ] for i in ONOSMastership ] ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentMastership = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentMastership,
+            onpass="Switch roles are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of switch roles" )
+
+        if rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn(
+                    "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " roles: ",
+                    json.dumps(
+                        json.loads( ONOSMastership[ i ] ),
+                        sort_keys=True,
+                        indent=4,
+                        separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+        elif rolesResults and not consistentMastership:
+            mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+
+        description2 = "Compare switch roles from before failure"
+        main.step( description2 )
+        try:
+            currentJson = json.loads( ONOSMastership[0] )
+            oldJson = json.loads( mastershipState )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Something is wrong with parsing " +
+                                "ONOSMastership[0] or mastershipState" )
+            main.log.error( "ONOSMastership[0]: " + repr( ONOSMastership[0] ) )
+            main.log.error( "mastershipState" + repr( mastershipState ) )
+            main.cleanup()
+            main.exit()
+        mastershipCheck = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( 1, 29 ):
+            switchDPID = str(
+                main.Mininet1.getSwitchDPID( switch="s" + str( i ) ) )
+            current = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in currentJson
+                        if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            old = [ switch[ 'master' ] for switch in oldJson
+                    if switchDPID in switch[ 'id' ] ]
+            if current == old:
+                mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and main.TRUE
+            else:
+                main.log.warn( "Mastership of switch %s changed" % switchDPID )
+                mastershipCheck = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=mastershipCheck,
+            onpass="Mastership of Switches was not changed",
+            onfail="Mastership of some switches changed" )
+        mastershipCheck = mastershipCheck and consistentMastership
+
+        main.step( "Get the intents and compare across all nodes" )
+        ONOSIntents = []
+        intentCheck = main.FALSE
+        consistentIntents = True
+        intentsResults = True
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].intents,
+                             name="intents-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[],
+                             kwargs={ 'jsonFormat': True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            ONOSIntents.append( t.result )
+
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if not ONOSIntents[ i ] or "Error" in ONOSIntents[ i ]:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                 " intents" )
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents response: " +
+                               repr( ONOSIntents[ i ] ) )
+                intentsResults = False
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=intentsResults,
+            onpass="No error in reading intents output",
+            onfail="Error in reading intents from ONOS" )
+
+        main.step( "Check for consistency in Intents from each controller" )
+        if all([ sorted( i ) == sorted( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ) for i in ONOSIntents ] ):
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent across all ONOS " +
+                             "nodes" )
+        else:
+            consistentIntents = False
+
+        # Try to make it easy to figure out what is happening
+        #
+        # Intent      ONOS1      ONOS2    ...
+        #  0x01     INSTALLED  INSTALLING
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        #  ...        ...         ...
+        title = "   ID"
+        for n in range( numControllers ):
+            title += " " * 10 + "ONOS" + str( n + 1 )
+        main.log.warn( title )
+        # get all intent keys in the cluster
+        keys = []
+        for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+            node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+            for intent in node:
+                keys.append( intent.get( 'id' ) )
+        keys = set( keys )
+        for key in keys:
+            row = "%-13s" % key
+            for nodeStr in ONOSIntents:
+                node = json.loads( nodeStr )
+                for intent in node:
+                    if intent.get( 'id' ) == key:
+                        row += "%-15s" % intent.get( 'state' )
+            main.log.warn( row )
+        # End table view
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=consistentIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of intents" )
+        intentStates = []
+        for node in ONOSIntents:  # Iter through ONOS nodes
+            nodeStates = []
+            # Iter through intents of a node
+            try:
+                for intent in json.loads( node ):
+                    nodeStates.append( intent[ 'state' ] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Error in parsing intents" )
+                main.log.error( repr( node ) )
+            intentStates.append( nodeStates )
+            out = [ (i, nodeStates.count( i ) ) for i in set( nodeStates ) ]
+            main.log.info( dict( out ) )
+
+        if intentsResults and not consistentIntents:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " intents: " )
+                main.log.warn( json.dumps(
+                    json.loads( ONOSIntents[ i ] ),
+                    sort_keys=True,
+                    indent=4,
+                    separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+        elif intentsResults and consistentIntents:
+            intentCheck = main.TRUE
+
+        # NOTE: Store has no durability, so intents are lost across system
+        #       restarts
+        main.step( "Compare current intents with intents before the failure" )
+        # NOTE: this requires case 5 to pass for intentState to be set.
+        #      maybe we should stop the test if that fails?
+        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+        if intentState and intentState == ONOSIntents[ 0 ]:
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            main.log.info( "Intents are consistent with before failure" )
+        # TODO: possibly the states have changed? we may need to figure out
+        #       what the acceptable states are
+        elif len( intentState ) == len( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ):
+            sameIntents = main.TRUE
+            try:
+                before = json.loads( intentState )
+                after = json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] )
+                for intent in before:
+                    if intent not in after:
+                        sameIntents = main.FALSE
+                        main.log.debug( "Intent is not currently in ONOS " +
+                                        "(at least in the same form):" )
+                        main.log.debug( json.dumps( intent ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        if sameIntents == main.FALSE:
+            try:
+                main.log.debug( "ONOS intents before: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( intentState ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                main.log.debug( "Current ONOS intents: " )
+                main.log.debug( json.dumps( json.loads( ONOSIntents[ 0 ] ),
+                                            sort_keys=True, indent=4,
+                                            separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.exception( "Exception printing intents" )
+                main.log.debug( repr( ONOSIntents[0] ) )
+                main.log.debug( repr( intentState ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameIntents,
+            onpass="Intents are consistent with before failure",
+            onfail="The Intents changed during failure" )
+        intentCheck = intentCheck and sameIntents
+
+        main.step( "Get the OF Table entries and compare to before " +
+                   "component failure" )
+        FlowTables = main.TRUE
+        flows2 = []
+        for i in range( 28 ):
+            main.log.info( "Checking flow table on s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            tmpFlows = main.Mininet2.getFlowTable( 1.3, "s" + str( i + 1 ) )
+            flows2.append( tmpFlows )
+            tempResult = main.Mininet2.flowComp(
+                flow1=flows[ i ],
+                flow2=tmpFlows )
+            FlowTables = FlowTables and tempResult
+            if FlowTables == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.info( "Differences in flow table for switch: s" +
+                               str( i + 1 ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=FlowTables,
+            onpass="No changes were found in the flow tables",
+            onfail="Changes were found in the flow tables" )
+
+        main.Mininet2.pingLongKill()
+        '''
+        main.step( "Check the continuous pings to ensure that no packets " +
+                   "were dropped during component failure" )
+        main.Mininet2.pingKill( main.params[ 'TESTONUSER' ],
+                                main.params[ 'TESTONIP' ] )
+        LossInPings = main.FALSE
+        # NOTE: checkForLoss returns main.FALSE with 0% packet loss
+        for i in range( 8, 18 ):
+            main.log.info(
+                "Checking for a loss in pings along flow from s" +
+                str( i ) )
+            LossInPings = main.Mininet2.checkForLoss(
+                "/tmp/ping.h" +
+                str( i ) ) or LossInPings
+        if LossInPings == main.TRUE:
+            main.log.info( "Loss in ping detected" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.ERROR:
+            main.log.info( "There are multiple mininet process running" )
+        elif LossInPings == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.info( "No Loss in the pings" )
+            main.log.info( "No loss of dataplane connectivity" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.FALSE,
+            actual=LossInPings,
+            onpass="No Loss of connectivity",
+            onfail="Loss of dataplane connectivity detected" )
+        '''
+
+        main.step( "Leadership Election is still functional" )
+        # Test of LeadershipElection
+        # NOTE: this only works for the sanity test. In case of failures,
+        #       leader will likely change
+        leader = nodes[ 0 ].ip_address
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            # verify leader is ONOS1
+            if leaderN == leader:
+                # all is well
+                # NOTE: In failure scenario, this could be a new node, maybe
+                # check != ONOS1
+                pass
+            elif leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in response
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, check the" +
+                                 " error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leader != leaderN:
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( cli.name + " sees " + str( leaderN ) +
+                                 " as the leader of the election app. " +
+                                 "Leader should be " + str( leader ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+    def CASE8( self, main ):
+        """
+        Compare topo
+        """
+        import json
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case( "Compare ONOS Topology view to Mininet topology" )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Compare topology objects between Mininet" +\
+                                " and ONOS"
+
+        main.step( "Comparing ONOS topology to MN" )
+        devicesResults = main.TRUE
+        linksResults = main.TRUE
+        hostsResults = main.TRUE
+        hostAttachmentResults = True
+        topoResult = main.FALSE
+        elapsed = 0
+        count = 0
+        main.step( "Collecting topology information from ONOS" )
+        startTime = time.time()
+        # Give time for Gossip to work
+        while topoResult == main.FALSE and elapsed < 60:
+            count += 1
+            cliStart = time.time()
+            devices = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].devices,
+                                 name="devices-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                devices.append( t.result )
+            hosts = []
+            ipResult = main.TRUE
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].hosts,
+                                 name="hosts-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                try:
+                    hosts.append( json.loads( t.result ) )
+                except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                    main.log.exception( "Error parsing hosts results" )
+                    main.log.error( repr( t.result ) )
+            for controller in range( 0, len( hosts ) ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if host is None or host.get( 'ipAddresses', [] ) == []:
+                        main.log.error(
+                            "DEBUG:Error with host ipAddresses on controller" +
+                            controllerStr + ": " + str( host ) )
+                        ipResult = main.FALSE
+            ports = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].ports,
+                                 name="ports-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                ports.append( t.result )
+            links = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].links,
+                                 name="links-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                links.append( t.result )
+            clusters = []
+            threads = []
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].clusters,
+                                 name="clusters-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                clusters.append( t.result )
+
+            elapsed = time.time() - startTime
+            cliTime = time.time() - cliStart
+            print "Elapsed time: " + str( elapsed )
+            print "CLI time: " + str( cliTime )
+
+            mnSwitches = main.Mininet1.getSwitches()
+            mnLinks = main.Mininet1.getLinks()
+            mnHosts = main.Mininet1.getHosts()
+            for controller in range( numControllers ):
+                controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+                if devices[ controller ] and ports[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in devices[ controller ] and\
+                    "Error" not in ports[ controller ]:
+
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.Mininet1.compareSwitches(
+                            mnSwitches,
+                            json.loads( devices[ controller ] ),
+                            json.loads( ports[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentDevicesResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentDevicesResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " Switches view is incorrect" )
+
+                if links[ controller ] and "Error" not in links[ controller ]:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.Mininet1.compareLinks(
+                            mnSwitches, mnLinks,
+                            json.loads( links[ controller ] ) )
+                else:
+                    currentLinksResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentLinksResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is correct",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " links view is incorrect" )
+
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.Mininet1.compareHosts(
+                            mnHosts,
+                            hosts[ controller ] )
+                else:
+                    currentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                         actual=currentHostsResult,
+                                         onpass="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts exist in Mininet",
+                                         onfail="ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                         " hosts don't match Mininet" )
+                # CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                hostAttachment = True
+                zeroHosts = False
+                # FIXME: topo-HA/obelisk specific mappings:
+                # key is mac and value is dpid
+                mappings = {}
+                for i in range( 1, 29 ):  # hosts 1 through 28
+                    # set up correct variables:
+                    macId = "00:" * 5 + hex( i ).split( "0x" )[1].upper().zfill(2)
+                    if i == 1:
+                        deviceId = "1000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 2:
+                        deviceId = "2000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 3:
+                        deviceId = "3000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 4:
+                        deviceId = "3004".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 5:
+                        deviceId = "5000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 6:
+                        deviceId = "6000".zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 7:
+                        deviceId = "6007".zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 8 and i <= 17:
+                        dpid = '3' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i >= 18 and i <= 27:
+                        dpid = '6' + str( i ).zfill( 3 )
+                        deviceId = dpid.zfill(16)
+                    elif i == 28:
+                        deviceId = "2800".zfill(16)
+                    mappings[ macId ] = deviceId
+                if hosts[ controller ] or "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                    if hosts[ controller ] == []:
+                        main.log.warn( "There are no hosts discovered" )
+                        zeroHosts = True
+                    else:
+                        for host in hosts[ controller ]:
+                            mac = None
+                            location = None
+                            device = None
+                            port = None
+                            try:
+                                mac = host.get( 'mac' )
+                                assert mac, "mac field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                location = host.get( 'location' )
+                                assert location, "location field could not be found for this host object"
+
+                                # Trim the protocol identifier off deviceId
+                                device = str( location.get( 'elementId' ) ).split(':')[1]
+                                assert device, "elementId field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                port = location.get( 'port' )
+                                assert port, "port field could not be found for this host location object"
+
+                                # Now check if this matches where they should be
+                                if mac and device and port:
+                                    if str( port ) != "1":
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment port is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: 1 Actual: " + str( port) )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                    if device != mappings[ str( mac ) ]:
+                                        main.log.error( "The attachment device is incorrect for " +
+                                                        "host " + str( mac ) +
+                                                        ". Expected: " + mappings[ str( mac ) ] +
+                                                        " Actual: " + device )
+                                        hostAttachment = False
+                                else:
+                                    hostAttachment = False
+                            except AssertionError:
+                                main.log.exception( "Json object not as expected" )
+                                main.log.error( repr( host ) )
+                                hostAttachment = False
+                else:
+                    main.log.error( "No hosts json output or \"Error\"" +
+                                    " in output. hosts = " +
+                                    repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                if zeroHosts is False:
+                    hostAttachment = True
+
+                # END CHECKING HOST ATTACHMENT POINTS
+                devicesResults = devicesResults and currentDevicesResult
+                linksResults = linksResults and currentLinksResult
+                hostsResults = hostsResults and currentHostsResult
+                hostAttachmentResults = hostAttachmentResults and\
+                                        hostAttachment
+                topoResult = ( devicesResults and linksResults
+                               and hostsResults and ipResult and
+                               hostAttachmentResults )
+
+        # Compare json objects for hosts and dataplane clusters
+
+        # hosts
+        main.step( "Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentHostsResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( hosts ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in hosts[ controller ]:
+                if hosts[ controller ] == hosts[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # hosts not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "hosts from ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    main.log.warn( repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+                    consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting ONOS hosts from ONOS" +
+                                 controllerStr )
+                consistentHostsResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " hosts response: " +
+                               repr( hosts[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentHostsResult,
+            onpass="Hosts view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of hosts" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts information is correct" )
+        hostsResults = hostsResults and ipResult
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Host information is correct",
+            onfail="Host information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Host attachment points to the network" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=True,
+            actual=hostAttachmentResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correctly attached to the network",
+            onfail="ONOS did not correctly attach hosts to the network" )
+
+        # Strongly connected clusters of devices
+        main.step( "Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes" )
+        consistentClustersResult = main.TRUE
+        for controller in range( len( clusters ) ):
+            controllerStr = str( controller + 1 )
+            if "Error" not in clusters[ controller ]:
+                if clusters[ controller ] == clusters[ 0 ]:
+                    continue
+                else:  # clusters not consistent
+                    main.log.error( "clusters from ONOS" +
+                                     controllerStr +
+                                     " is inconsistent with ONOS1" )
+                    consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Error in getting dataplane clusters " +
+                                 "from ONOS" + controllerStr )
+                consistentClustersResult = main.FALSE
+                main.log.warn( "ONOS" + controllerStr +
+                               " clusters response: " +
+                               repr( clusters[ controller ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=consistentClustersResult,
+            onpass="Clusters view is consistent across all ONOS nodes",
+            onfail="ONOS nodes have different views of clusters" )
+
+        main.step( "There is only one SCC" )
+        # there should always only be one cluster
+        try:
+            numClusters = len( json.loads( clusters[ 0 ] ) )
+        except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+            main.log.exception( "Error parsing clusters[0]: " +
+                                repr( clusters[0] ) )
+        clusterResults = main.FALSE
+        if numClusters == 1:
+            clusterResults = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=1,
+            actual=numClusters,
+            onpass="ONOS shows 1 SCC",
+            onfail="ONOS shows " + str( numClusters ) + " SCCs" )
+
+        topoResult = ( devicesResults and linksResults
+                       and hostsResults and consistentHostsResult
+                       and consistentClustersResult and clusterResults
+                       and ipResult and hostAttachmentResults )
+
+        topoResult = topoResult and int( count <= 2 )
+        note = "note it takes about " + str( int( cliTime ) ) + \
+            " seconds for the test to make all the cli calls to fetch " +\
+            "the topology from each ONOS instance"
+        main.log.info(
+            "Very crass estimate for topology discovery/convergence( " +
+            str( note ) + " ): " + str( elapsed ) + " seconds, " +
+            str( count ) + " tries" )
+
+        main.step( "Device information is correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=devicesResults,
+            onpass="Device information is correct",
+            onfail="Device information is incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Links are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=linksResults,
+            onpass="Link are correct",
+            onfail="Links are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Hosts are correct" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=hostsResults,
+            onpass="Hosts are correct",
+            onfail="Hosts are incorrect" )
+
+        # FIXME: move this to an ONOS state case
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS nodes" )
+        nodesOutput = []
+        nodeResults = main.TRUE
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].nodes,
+                             name="nodes-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            nodesOutput.append( t.result )
+        ips = [ node.ip_address for node in nodes ]
+        for i in nodesOutput:
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( i )
+                for node in current:
+                    currentResult = main.FALSE
+                    if node['ip'] in ips:  # node in nodes() output is in cell
+                        if node['state'] == 'ACTIVE':
+                            currentResult = main.TRUE
+                        else:
+                            main.log.error( "Error in ONOS node availability" )
+                            main.log.error(
+                                    json.dumps( current,
+                                                sort_keys=True,
+                                                indent=4,
+                                                separators=( ',', ': ' ) ) )
+                            break
+                    nodeResults = nodeResults and currentResult
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Error parsing nodes output" )
+                main.log.warn( repr( i ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=nodeResults,
+                                 onpass="Nodes check successful",
+                                 onfail="Nodes check NOT successful" )
+
+    def CASE9( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 down
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Turn off a link to ensure that Link Discovery " +\
+                      "is working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Kill Link between s3 and s28" )
+        LinkDown = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="down" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkDown,
+                                 onpass="Link down successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link down" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE10( self, main ):
+        """
+        Link s3-s28 up
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+
+        linkSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'LinkDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Restore a link to ensure that Link Discovery is " + \
+                      "working properly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Bring link between s3 and s28 back up" )
+        LinkUp = main.Mininet1.link( END1="s3", END2="s28", OPTION="up" )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( linkSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for link up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( linkSleep )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=LinkUp,
+                                 onpass="Link up successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to bring link up" )
+        # TODO do some sort of check here
+
+    def CASE11( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Down
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+
+        description = "Killing a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+
+        # TODO: Make this switch parameterizable
+        main.step( "Kill " + switch )
+        main.log.info( "Deleting " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.delSwitch( switch )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch down to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ] is False:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="Kill switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to kill switch?" )
+
+    def CASE12( self, main ):
+        """
+        Switch Up
+        """
+        # NOTE: You should probably run a topology check after this
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert ONOS1Port, "ONOS1Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS2Port, "ONOS2Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS3Port, "ONOS3Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS4Port, "ONOS4Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS5Port, "ONOS5Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS6Port, "ONOS6Port not defined"
+        assert ONOS7Port, "ONOS7Port not defined"
+
+        switchSleep = float( main.params[ 'timers' ][ 'SwitchDiscovery' ] )
+        switch = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'switch' ]
+        switchDPID = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'dpid' ]
+        links = main.params[ 'kill' ][ 'links' ].split()
+        description = "Adding a switch to ensure it is discovered correctly"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Add back " + switch )
+        main.Mininet1.addSwitch( switch, dpid=switchDPID )
+        for peer in links:
+            main.Mininet1.addLink( switch, peer )
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            ipList.append( nodes[ i ].ip_address )
+        main.Mininet1.assignSwController( sw=switch, ip=ipList )
+        main.log.info( "Waiting " + str( switchSleep ) +
+                       " seconds for switch up to be discovered" )
+        time.sleep( switchSleep )
+        device = main.ONOScli1.getDevice( dpid=switchDPID )
+        # Peek at the deleted switch
+        main.log.warn( str( device ) )
+        result = main.FALSE
+        if device and device[ 'available' ]:
+            result = main.TRUE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=result,
+                                 onpass="add switch successful",
+                                 onfail="Failed to add switch?" )
+
+    def CASE13( self, main ):
+        """
+        Clean up
+        """
+        import os
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # printing colors to terminal
+        colors = { 'cyan': '\033[96m', 'purple': '\033[95m',
+                   'blue': '\033[94m', 'green': '\033[92m',
+                   'yellow': '\033[93m', 'red': '\033[91m', 'end': '\033[0m' }
+        main.case( "Test Cleanup" )
+        main.step( "Killing tcpdumps" )
+        main.Mininet2.stopTcpdump()
+
+        testname = main.TEST
+        if main.params[ 'BACKUP' ] == "True":
+            main.step( "Copying MN pcap and ONOS log files to test station" )
+            teststationUser = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONUSER' ]
+            teststationIP = main.params[ 'BACKUP' ][ 'TESTONIP' ]
+            # NOTE: MN Pcap file is being saved to ~/packet_captures
+            #       scp this file as MN and TestON aren't necessarily the same vm
+            # FIXME: scp
+            # mn files
+            # TODO: Load these from params
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/log/"
+            logFiles = [ "karaf.log", "karaf.log.1" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+
+            # std*.log's
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            logFolder = "/opt/onos/var/"
+            logFiles = [ "stderr.log", "stdout.log" ]
+            # NOTE: must end in /
+            dstDir = "~/packet_captures/"
+            for f in logFiles:
+                for node in nodes:
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.sendline( "scp sdn@" + node.ip_address +
+                                                    ":" + logFolder + f + " " +
+                                                    teststationUser + "@" +
+                                                    teststationIP + ":" +
+                                                    dstDir + str( testname ) +
+                                                    "-" + node.name + "-" + f )
+                    main.ONOSbench.handle.expect( "\$" )
+            # sleep so scp can finish
+            time.sleep( 10 )
+            main.step( "Packing and rotating pcap archives" )
+            os.system( "~/TestON/dependencies/rotate.sh " + str( testname ) )
+
+        main.step( "Stopping Mininet" )
+        mnResult = main.Mininet1.stopNet()
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
+                                 onpass="Mininet stopped",
+                                 onfail="MN cleanup NOT successful" )
+
+        main.step( "Checking ONOS Logs for errors" )
+        for node in nodes:
+            print colors[ 'purple' ] + "Checking logs for errors on " + \
+                node.name + ":" + colors[ 'end' ]
+            print main.ONOSbench.checkLogs( node.ip_address )
+
+        try:
+            timerLog = open( main.logdir + "/Timers.csv", 'w')
+            # Overwrite with empty line and close
+            labels = "Gossip Intents"
+            data = str( gossipTime )
+            timerLog.write( labels + "\n" + data )
+            timerLog.close()
+        except NameError, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+    def CASE14( self, main ):
+        """
+        start election app on all onos nodes
+        """
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        main.case("Start Leadership Election app")
+        main.step( "Install leadership election app" )
+        appResult = main.ONOScli1.activateApp( "org.onosproject.election" )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=appResult,
+            onpass="Election app installed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with installing Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on each node" )
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            cli.electionTestRun()
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+                main.log.error( cli.name + ": Leader for the election app " +
+                                 "should be an ONOS node, instead got '" +
+                                 str( leader ) + "'" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Successfully ran for leadership",
+            onfail="Failed to run for leadership" )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+    def CASE15( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check that Leadership Election is still functional
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        leaderResult = main.TRUE
+        description = "Check that Leadership Election is still functional"
+        main.case( description )
+
+        main.step( "Check that each node shows the same leader" )
+        sameLeader = main.TRUE
+        leaders = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leader = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaders.append( leader )
+        if len( set( leaders ) ) != 1:
+            sameLeader = main.FALSE
+            main.log.error( "Results of electionTestLeader is order of CLIs:" +
+                            str( leaders ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=sameLeader,
+            onpass="Leadership is consistent for the election topic",
+            onfail="Nodes have different leaders" )
+
+        main.step( "Find current leader and withdraw" )
+        leader = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # do some sanity checking on leader before using it
+        withdrawResult = main.FALSE
+        if leader is None or leader == main.FALSE:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Leader for the election app should be an ONOS node," +
+                "instead got '" + str( leader ) + "'" )
+            leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            oldLeader = None
+        for i in range( len( CLIs ) ):
+            if leader == nodes[ i ].ip_address:
+                oldLeader = CLIs[ i ]
+                break
+        else:  # FOR/ELSE statement
+            main.log.error( "Leader election, could not find current leader" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            withdrawResult = oldLeader.electionTestWithdraw()
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=withdrawResult,
+            onpass="Node was withdrawn from election",
+            onfail="Node was not withdrawn from election" )
+
+        main.step( "Make sure new leader is elected" )
+        # FIXME: use threads
+        leaderList = []
+        for cli in CLIs:
+            leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+            leaderList.append( leaderN )
+            if leaderN == leader:
+                main.log.error(  cli.name + " still sees " + str( leader ) +
+                                  " as leader after they withdrew" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN == main.FALSE:
+                # error in  response
+                # TODO: add check for "Command not found:" in the driver, this
+                #       means the app isn't loaded
+                main.log.error( "Something is wrong with " +
+                                 "electionTestLeader function, " +
+                                 "check the error logs" )
+                leaderResult = main.FALSE
+            elif leaderN is None:
+                # node may not have recieved the event yet
+                time.sleep(7)
+                leaderN = cli.electionTestLeader()
+                leaderList.pop()
+                leaderList.append( leaderN )
+        consistentLeader = main.FALSE
+        if len( set( leaderList ) ) == 1:
+            main.log.info( "Each Election-app sees '" +
+                           str( leaderList[ 0 ] ) +
+                           "' as the leader" )
+            consistentLeader = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error(
+                "Inconsistent responses for leader of Election-app:" )
+            for n in range( len( leaderList ) ):
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( n + 1 ) + " response: " +
+                                 str( leaderList[ n ] ) )
+        leaderResult = leaderResult and consistentLeader
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=leaderResult,
+            onpass="Leadership election passed",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election" )
+
+        main.step( "Run for election on old leader( just so everyone " +
+                   "is in the hat )" )
+        if oldLeader:
+            runResult = oldLeader.electionTestRun()
+        else:
+            runResult = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=runResult,
+            onpass="App re-ran for election",
+            onfail="App failed to run for election" )
+
+        main.step( "Leader did not change when old leader re-ran" )
+        afterRun = main.ONOScli1.electionTestLeader()
+        # verify leader didn't just change
+        if afterRun == leaderList[ 0 ]:
+            afterResult = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            afterResult = main.FALSE
+
+        utilities.assert_equals(
+            expect=main.TRUE,
+            actual=afterResult,
+            onpass="Old leader successfully re-ran for election",
+            onfail="Something went wrong with Leadership election after " +
+                   "the old leader re-ran for election" )
+
+    def CASE16( self, main ):
+        """
+        Install Distributed Primitives app
+        """
+        import time
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests
+        global pCounterName
+        global iCounterName
+        global pCounterValue
+        global iCounterValue
+        global onosSet
+        global onosSetName
+        pCounterName = "TestON-Partitions"
+        iCounterName = "TestON-inMemory"
+        pCounterValue = 0
+        iCounterValue = 0
+        onosSet = set([])
+        onosSetName = "TestON-set"
+
+        description = "Install Primitives app"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.step( "Install Primitives app" )
+        appName = "org.onosproject.distributedprimitives"
+        appResults = CLIs[0].activateApp( appName )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=appResults,
+                                 onpass="Primitives app activated",
+                                 onfail="Primitives app not activated" )
+        time.sleep( 5 )  # To allow all nodes to activate
+
+    def CASE17( self, main ):
+        """
+        Check for basic functionality with distributed primitives
+        """
+        import json
+        # Make sure variables are defined/set
+        assert numControllers, "numControllers not defined"
+        assert main, "main not defined"
+        assert utilities.assert_equals, "utilities.assert_equals not defined"
+        assert CLIs, "CLIs not defined"
+        assert nodes, "nodes not defined"
+        assert pCounterName, "pCounterName not defined"
+        assert iCounterName, "iCounterName not defined"
+        assert onosSetName, "onosSetName not defined"
+        # NOTE: assert fails if value is 0/None/Empty/False
+        try:
+            pCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "pCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            pCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            iCounterValue
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "iCounterValue not defined, setting to 0" )
+            iCounterValue = 0
+        try:
+            onosSet
+        except NameError:
+            main.log.error( "onosSet not defined, setting to empty Set" )
+            onosSet = set([])
+        # Variables for the distributed primitives tests. These are local only
+        addValue = "a"
+        addAllValue = "a b c d e f"
+        retainValue = "c d e f"
+
+        description = "Check for basic functionality with distributed " +\
+                      "primitives"
+        main.case( description )
+        main.caseExplaination = "Test the methods of the distributed primitives (counters and sets) throught the cli"
+        # DISTRIBUTED ATOMIC COUNTERS
+        main.step( "Increment and get a default counter on each node" )
+        pCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        addedPValues = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="counterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ pCounterName ] )
+            pCounterValue += 1
+            addedPValues.append( pCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            pCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        pCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedPValues:
+            tmpResult = i in pCounters
+            pCounterResults = pCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in partitioned "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=pCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="Default counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing default" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Increment and get an in memory counter on each node" )
+        iCounters = []
+        addedIValues = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counterTestIncrement,
+                             name="icounterIncrement-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ iCounterName ],
+                             kwargs={ "inMemory": True } )
+            iCounterValue += 1
+            addedIValues.append( iCounterValue )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            iCounters.append( t.result )
+        # Check that counter incremented numController times
+        iCounterResults = True
+        for i in addedIValues:
+            tmpResult = i in iCounters
+            iCounterResults = iCounterResults and tmpResult
+            if not tmpResult:
+                main.log.error( str( i ) + " is not in the in-memory "
+                                "counter incremented results" )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=True,
+                                 actual=iCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="In memory counter incremented",
+                                 onfail="Error incrementing in memory" +
+                                        " counter" )
+
+        main.step( "Check counters are consistant across nodes" )
+        onosCounters = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].counters,
+                             name="counters-" + str( i ) )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            onosCounters.append( t.result )
+        tmp = [ i == onosCounters[ 0 ] for i in onosCounters ]
+        if all( tmp ):
+            main.log.info( "Counters are consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.TRUE
+        else:
+            main.log.error( "Counters are not consistent across all nodes" )
+            consistentCounterResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=consistentCounterResults,
+                                 onpass="ONOS counters are consistent " +
+                                        "across nodes",
+                                 onfail="ONOS Counters are inconsistent " +
+                                        "across nodes" )
+
+        main.step( "Counters we added have the correct values" )
+        correctResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( onosCounters[i] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Could not parse counters response from ONOS" +
+                                str( i + 1 ) )
+                main.log.warn( repr( onosCounters[ i ] ) )
+            pValue = None
+            iValue = None
+            try:
+                for database in current:
+                    partitioned = database.get( 'partitionedDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if partitioned:
+                        for value in partitioned:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == pCounterName:
+                                pValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+                    inMemory = database.get( 'inMemoryDatabaseCounters' )
+                    if inMemory:
+                        for value in inMemory:
+                            if value.get( 'name' ) == iCounterName:
+                                iValue = value.get( 'value' )
+                                break
+            except AttributeError, e:
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) + " counters result " +
+                                "is not as expected" )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if pValue == pCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "Partitioned counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "Partitioned counter value is incorrect," +
+                                " expected value: " + str( pCounterValue )
+                                + " current value: " + str( pValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+            if iValue == iCounterValue:
+                main.log.info( "In memory counter value is correct" )
+            else:
+                main.log.error( "In memory counter value is incorrect, " +
+                                "expected value: " + str( iCounterValue ) +
+                                " current value: " + str( iValue ) )
+                correctResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=correctResults,
+                                 onpass="Added counters are correct",
+                                 onfail="Added counters are incorrect" )
+        # DISTRIBUTED SETS
+        main.step( "Distributed Set get" )
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=getResults,
+                                 onpass="Set elements are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set elements are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set size" )
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=sizeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set sizes are correct",
+                                 onfail="Set sizes are incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set add()" )
+        onosSet.add( addValue )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAdd-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addResults = main.FALSE
+        if addResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set add" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addResults = addResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addResults,
+                                 onpass="Set add correct",
+                                 onfail="Set add was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set contains()" )
+        containsResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContains-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsResults,
+                                 onpass="Set contains is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set contains failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set containsAll()" )
+        containsAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setContainsAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ],
+                             kwargs={ "values": addAllValue } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            # NOTE: This is the tuple
+            containsAllResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        containsAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if containsResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                containsResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                containsResults = containsResults and\
+                                  containsResponses[ i ][ 1 ]
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=containsAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set containsAll is functional",
+                                 onfail="Set containsAll failed" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set remove()" )
+        onosSet.remove( addValue )
+        removeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRemove-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            removeResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set remove" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeResults = removeResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeResults,
+                                 onpass="Set remove correct",
+                                 onfail="Set remove was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set removeAll()" )
+        onosSet.difference_update( addAllValue.split() )
+        removeAllResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        try:
+            for i in range( numControllers ):
+                t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                                 name="setTestRemoveAll-" + str( i ),
+                                 args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+                threads.append( t )
+                t.start()
+            for t in threads:
+                t.join()
+                removeAllResponses.append( t.result )
+        except Exception, e:
+            main.log.exception(e)
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        removeAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # not in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif removeAllResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                removeAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if removeAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set removeAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        removeAllResults = removeAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=removeAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set removeAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set removeAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set clear()" )
+        onosSet.clear()
+        clearResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestClear-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, " "],  # Values doesn't matter
+                             kwargs={ "clear": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            clearResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        clearResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if clearResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Nothing set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif clearResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                clearResults = main.FALSE
+        if clearResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set clear" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        clearResults = clearResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=clearResults,
+                                 onpass="Set clear correct",
+                                 onfail="Set clear was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set addAll()" )
+        onosSet.update( addAllValue.split() )
+        addResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestAdd,
+                             name="setTestAddAll-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, addAllValue ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            addResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        addAllResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if addResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif addResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                addAllResults = main.FALSE
+        if addAllResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set addAll" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " + str( size ) +
+                                " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        addAllResults = addAllResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=addAllResults,
+                                 onpass="Set addAll correct",
+                                 onfail="Set addAll was incorrect" )
+
+        main.step( "Distributed Set retain()" )
+        onosSet.intersection_update( retainValue.split() )
+        retainResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestRemove,
+                             name="setTestRetain-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName, retainValue ],
+                             kwargs={ "retain": True } )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            retainResponses.append( t.result )
+
+        # main.TRUE = successfully changed the set
+        # main.FALSE = action resulted in no change in set
+        # main.ERROR - Some error in executing the function
+        retainResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if retainResponses[ i ] == main.TRUE:
+                # All is well
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.FALSE:
+                # Already in set, probably fine
+                pass
+            elif retainResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                # Error in execution
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+            else:
+                # unexpected result
+                retainResults = main.FALSE
+        if retainResults != main.TRUE:
+            main.log.error( "Error executing set retain" )
+
+        # Check if set is still correct
+        size = len( onosSet )
+        getResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestGet,
+                             name="setTestGet-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            getResponses.append( t.result )
+        getResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if isinstance( getResponses[ i ], list):
+                current = set( getResponses[ i ] )
+                if len( current ) == len( getResponses[ i ] ):
+                    # no repeats
+                    if onosSet != current:
+                        main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                        " has incorrect view" +
+                                        " of set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                        str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Expected: " + str( onosSet ) )
+                        main.log.debug( "Actual: " + str( current ) )
+                        getResults = main.FALSE
+                else:
+                    # error, set is not a set
+                    main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                    " has repeat elements in" +
+                                    " set " + onosSetName + ":\n" +
+                                    str( getResponses[ i ] ) )
+                    getResults = main.FALSE
+            elif getResponses[ i ] == main.ERROR:
+                getResults = main.FALSE
+        sizeResponses = []
+        threads = []
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            t = main.Thread( target=CLIs[i].setTestSize,
+                             name="setTestSize-" + str( i ),
+                             args=[ onosSetName ] )
+            threads.append( t )
+            t.start()
+        for t in threads:
+            t.join()
+            sizeResponses.append( t.result )
+        sizeResults = main.TRUE
+        for i in range( numControllers ):
+            if size != sizeResponses[ i ]:
+                sizeResults = main.FALSE
+                main.log.error( "ONOS" + str( i + 1 ) +
+                                " expected a size of " +
+                                str( size ) + " for set " + onosSetName +
+                                " but got " + str( sizeResponses[ i ] ) )
+        retainResults = retainResults and getResults and sizeResults
+        utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE,
+                                 actual=retainResults,
+                                 onpass="Set retain correct",
+                                 onfail="Set retain was incorrect" )
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.topo b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.topo
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5f87b9d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/HAsanity.topo
@@ -0,0 +1,170 @@
+<TOPOLOGY>
+    <COMPONENT>
+
+        <ONOSbench>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>1</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOSbench>
+
+        <ONOScli1>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>2</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli1>
+
+        <ONOScli2>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>3</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli2>
+
+        <ONOScli3>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>4</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli3>
+
+
+        <ONOScli4>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>5</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli4>
+
+
+        <ONOScli5>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>6</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli5>
+
+
+        <ONOScli6>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>7</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli6>
+
+
+        <ONOScli7>
+            <host>localhost</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>OnosCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>8</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOScli7>
+
+        <ONOS1>
+            <host>OC1</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>9</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS1>
+
+        <ONOS2>
+            <host>OC2</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>10</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS2>
+
+        <ONOS3>
+            <host>OC3</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>11</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS3>
+
+        <ONOS4>
+            <host>OC4</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>12</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS4>
+
+        <ONOS5>
+            <host>OC5</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>13</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS5>
+
+        <ONOS6>
+            <host>OC6</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>14</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS6>
+
+        <ONOS7>
+            <host>OC7</host>
+            <user>sdn</user>
+            <password>rocks</password>
+            <type>OnosDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>15</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+        </ONOS7>
+
+        <Mininet1>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>MininetCliDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>16</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+                #Specify the Option for mininet
+                <arg1> --custom ~/mininet/custom/obelisk.py </arg1>
+                <arg2> --topo obelisk </arg2>
+                <arg3> </arg3>
+                <controller> none </controller>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet1>
+
+        <Mininet2>
+            <host>OCN</host>
+            <user>admin</user>
+            <password>onos_test</password>
+            <type>RemoteMininetDriver</type>
+            <connect_order>17</connect_order>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
+        </Mininet2>
+
+    </COMPONENT>
+</TOPOLOGY>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsanity/__init__.py b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/__init__.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..e69de29
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/__init__.py
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsanity/dependencies/obelisk.py b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/dependencies/obelisk.py
new file mode 100755
index 0000000..fb6ccdb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsanity/dependencies/obelisk.py
@@ -0,0 +1,70 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python
+
+from mininet.topo import Topo
+
+class ObeliskTopo( Topo ):
+    def __init__( self ):
+        Topo.__init__( self )
+        topSwitch = self.addSwitch('s1',dpid='1000'.zfill(16))
+        leftTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s2',dpid='2000'.zfill(16))
+        rightTopSwitch = self.addSwitch('s5',dpid='5000'.zfill(16))
+        leftBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s3',dpid='3000'.zfill(16))
+        rightBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s6',dpid='6000'.zfill(16))	
+        midBotSwitch = self.addSwitch('s28',dpid='2800'.zfill(16))
+        
+        topHost = self.addHost( 'h1' )
+        leftTopHost = self.addHost('h2')
+        rightTopHost = self.addHost('h5')
+        leftBotHost = self.addHost('h3')
+        rightBotHost = self.addHost('h6')
+        midBotHost = self.addHost('h28')
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,topHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftTopHost)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightTopHost)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,leftBotHost)
+        self.addLink(rightBotSwitch,rightBotHost)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,midBotHost)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,leftTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(topSwitch,rightTopSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftTopSwitch,leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(rightTopSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(leftBotSwitch,midBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(midBotSwitch,rightBotSwitch)
+
+        agg1Switch = self.addSwitch('s4',dpid = '3004'.zfill(16))
+        agg2Switch = self.addSwitch('s7',dpid = '6007'.zfill(16))
+        agg1Host = self.addHost('h4')
+        agg2Host = self.addHost('h7')
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch,agg1Host)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch,agg2Host)
+        self.addLink(agg1Switch, leftBotSwitch)
+        self.addLink(agg2Switch, rightBotSwitch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+8)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('30'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg1Switch)
+
+        for i in range(10):
+            num = str(i+18)
+            switch = self.addSwitch('s'+num,dpid = ('60'+num.zfill(2)).zfill(16))
+            host = self.addHost('h'+num)
+            self.addLink(switch, host)
+            self.addLink(switch, agg2Switch)
+
+topos = { 'obelisk': (lambda: ObeliskTopo() ) }
+
+def run():
+    topo = ObeliskTopo()
+    net = Mininet( topo=topo, controller=RemoteController, autoSetMacs=True )
+    net.start()
+    CLI( net )
+    net.stop()
+
+if __name__ == '__main__':
+    setLogLevel( 'info' )
+    run()
+
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.params b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.params
index 52bded5..c43bea1 100644
--- a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.params
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.params
@@ -17,8 +17,9 @@
     <testcases>1,2,8,3,4,5,14,15,16,17,[6],8,3,7,4,15,17,9,8,4,10,8,4,11,8,4,12,8,4,13</testcases>
     <ENV>
         <cellName>HA</cellName>
+        <appString>drivers,openflow,proxyarp,mobility</appString>
     </ENV>
-    <Git>False</Git>
+    <Git> False </Git>
     <branch> master </branch>
     <num_controllers> 1 </num_controllers>
     <tcpdump> False </tcpdump>
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.py b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.py
index 45bb3bf..dad6099 100644
--- a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.py
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.py
@@ -65,15 +65,28 @@
         # set global variables
         global numControllers
         numControllers = int( main.params[ 'num_controllers' ] )
+        if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes:
+            if main.ONOSbench.maxNodes < numControllers:
+                numControllers = int( main.ONOSbench.maxNodes )
 
         global CLIs
         CLIs = []
         global nodes
         nodes = []
-        for i in range( 1, numControllers + 1 ):
-            CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
-            nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( 1, int( main.ONOSbench.maxNodes ) + 1 ):
+            try:
+                CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
+                nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+                ipList.append( nodes[ -1 ].ip_address )
+            except AttributeError:
+                break
 
+        main.step( "Create cell file" )
+        cellAppString = main.params[ 'ENV' ][ 'appString' ]
+        main.ONOSbench.createCellFile( main.ONOSbench.ip_address, cellName,
+                                       main.Mininet1.ip_address,
+                                       cellAppString, ipList )
         main.step( "Applying cell variable to environment" )
         cellResult = main.ONOSbench.setCell( cellName )
         verifyResult = main.ONOSbench.verifyCell()
@@ -135,7 +148,7 @@
         #       job = name of Jenkins job
         #       Plot Name = Plot-HA, only can be used if multiple plots
         #       index = The number of the graph under plot name
-        job = "HASingleInstanceRestart"
+        job = "HAsingleInstanceRestart"
         plotName = "Plot-HA"
         graphs = '<ac:structured-macro ac:name="html">\n'
         graphs += '<ac:plain-text-body><![CDATA[\n'
@@ -148,6 +161,17 @@
         graphs += '</ac:structured-macro>\n'
         main.log.wiki(graphs)
 
+        CLIs = []
+        nodes = []
+        ipList = []
+        for i in range( 1, numControllers + 1 ):
+            CLIs.append( getattr( main, 'ONOScli' + str( i ) ) )
+            nodes.append( getattr( main, 'ONOS' + str( i ) ) )
+            ipList.append( nodes[ -1 ].ip_address )
+
+        main.ONOSbench.createCellFile( main.ONOSbench.ip_address, "SingleHA",
+                                       main.Mininet1.ip_address,
+                                       cellAppString, ipList[ 0 ] )
         cellResult = main.ONOSbench.setCell( "SingleHA" )
         verifyResult = main.ONOSbench.verifyCell()
         main.step( "Creating ONOS package" )
@@ -1777,7 +1801,6 @@
             main.step( "Packing and rotating pcap archives" )
             os.system( "~/TestON/dependencies/rotate.sh " + str( testname ) )
 
-
         main.step( "Stopping Mininet" )
         mnResult = main.Mininet1.stopNet()
         utilities.assert_equals( expect=main.TRUE, actual=mnResult,
@@ -2095,7 +2118,12 @@
         main.step( "Counters we added have the correct values" )
         correctResults = main.TRUE
         for i in range( numControllers ):
-            current = json.loads( onosCounters[i] )
+            try:
+                current = json.loads( onosCounters[i] )
+            except ( ValueError, TypeError ):
+                main.log.error( "Could not parse counters response from ONOS" +
+                                str( i + 1 ) )
+                main.log.warn( repr( onosCounters[ i ] ) )
             pValue = None
             iValue = None
             try:
diff --git a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.topo b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.topo
index 795b37a..5f87b9d 100644
--- a/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.topo
+++ b/TestON/tests/HAsingleInstanceRestart/HAsingleInstanceRestart.topo
@@ -7,7 +7,8 @@
             <password>onos_test</password>
             <type>OnosDriver</type>
             <connect_order>1</connect_order>
-            <COMPONENTS> </COMPONENTS>
+            <COMPONENTS>
+            </COMPONENTS>
         </ONOSbench>
 
         <ONOScli1>